Suggestions on Link Auditing a 70,000 URL list?
-
I have a website with nearly 70,000 incoming links, since its a somewhat large site that has been online for 19 years.
The rate I was quoted for a link audit from a reputable SEO professional was $2 per, and clearly I don't have $140,000 to spend on a link audit !!
I was thinking of asking you guys for a tutorial that is the Gold Standard for link auditing checklists - and do it myself. But then I thought maybe its easier to shorten the list by knocking out all the "obviously good" links first. My only concern is that I be 100% certain they are good links.
Is there an "easiest approach" to take for shortening this list, so I can give it to a professional to handle the rest?
-
Hi! - I wrote this guide a few years ago on penalty recovery which may help you as it contains a lot of methods around auditing the links - https://moz.com/blog/ultimate-guide-to-google-penalty-removal
If we were to approach a product with 70k URLs. We'd do the following steps:
- Pull all the URLs into a Spreadsheet
- Split the URLs into domains
- Filter the URLs are search for common spammy words. e.g 'Link', 'Best', 'Free', 'Cheap', 'Dir', 'SEO' etc (mark as spam accordingly)
- Run contact finding across all URLs using a tool such as URL Profiler with Whois Lookups
- Filter by contact name and find duplicates (mark as spam accordingly)
- Filter by website type and mark as spam accordingly
- Manually check remaining links
By working through by domain, you'll rule out thousands of spammy links very quickly. Though 70k will ultimately take a few solid days of work.
Hope this helps,
Lewis
-
Have you looked at www.monitorbacklinks.com, good tool.
-
Hello,
Although it's important to do a link audit if you feel you have been penalized, for some sites a link audit isn't necessary. With that being said, and you feel you need a link audit there are a few options. Ideally, you would go through each link and review it to see how it may be impacting your site, but often site owners don't have the time to do this.
- Review obvious links - Grab 50-100 links at a time and do a quick glance at each one to determine if it should be on a list of potentially bad links. This way you can quickly overlook links you know are not hurting your rankings. Over time you can slowly tackle your list and hammer out which links are bad.
- Focus on spam analysis links - Run your site through Moz open site explorer and review the spam analysis. Now you're not going to get every single link here, but you can get an idea on what links are lower quality.
- Look into other companies - $2 per link is quite high, and there are other companies out there that will do a link audit, removal, and disavow for much less. If you would like a quote please contact us. Look into multiple options, don't get sold on just what one place tells you.
Hope this is helpful, if you have any additional questions please feel free to ask.
Chris
-
$2 per link is very expensive when you are looking at so many, especially as there is a big part of this that can be automated (hint: This should cost you no more than about $5-$10k if outsourced).
Linda has given you some good tips there, but I do agree that you need to tread carefully because you can often go too far and end up jumping out of the frying pan and into the fire.
It really does help to first gather all of the links from as many sources as you can and as already mentioned, create your de-dupe list. Depending on who you speak to at this point, there are different ways to go through the data and start to segment the links into those you know that are dangerous, those that are perhaps a bit of a grey area, and those that are safe.
Cheers,
Andy
-
I concentrate on the "most normal or typical sites will not need to use this tool" part, myself. (Though it sounds like you may not fall into that category.)
So then it's back to downloading as comprehensive a list of links as you can by using various sources and looking them over. (Also, in the past I have used LinkResearchTools to get an overview--it isn't cheap but it is a lot less than $140,000.)
-
Yes. We have confirmed with Sucuri that there was a concerted, intentional spam campaign against our site in 2013 that has since destroyed our rankings. Though Google hasn't given us any warnings, Sucuri had us on a blacklist because of it, and was kind enough to remove us without any cost or obligation on our part to sign up. They also provided us with a list of some of the most offending links so I could disavow them.
With up to 70,000 total, I am confident there are more, and to be honest, I see no reason to "leave some". Or leave any. I believe Google's warning should focus on this part: "...if used incorrectly". That means ... simply use it correctly. And disavow bad links, period. That's my take at least.
-
First, are you sure you need a link audit? Google is pretty good at ignoring regular spammy links that get picked up over time by large sites, as they say in their "Disavow backlinks" help page.
If you think there is a cause for concern, Moz's own Open Site Explorer can give you a list of incoming links that includes a spam score for those links, which can be used as a first pass.
The general drill for a manual link audit is to find all of the links you can (search console, moz, ahrefs, majestic, etc.) and create a de-duped list. From there, the "definitely good links" are usually easy to spot--you will recognize them from your industry or from other authoritative sources. And you will probably recognize the spammy "Get Rich/Viagra" backlinks as well. (If you sort your list by domain, it is easier to pick them out as a group.)
The rest are the ones to look at more closely.
But as I said to start, unless you think you are being penalized, tread lightly when it comes to disavowals.
To quote from Google [about disavowal]:
"This is an advanced feature and should only be used with caution. If used incorrectly, this feature can potentially harm your site’s performance in Google’s search results. We recommend that you disavow backlinks only if you believe you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links pointing to your site, and if you are confident that the links are causing issues for you. In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most normal or typical sites will not need to use this tool."
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
What Links to Disavow?
I am looking through my website's link profile that I pulled directly from Google Webmaster Tools. What is the best way to determine the links to disavow? Maybe the Webmaster Tools list is not the best list for this process but I really need to clean up the links that are hurting the site's SEO. Does anyone have any insight?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | PartyStore0 -
Can you nofollow a URL?
Hey Moz Community, My questions sounds pretty simple but unfortunately, it isn't. I have a domain name (we'll use example.com for this) http://example.com which 301 re-directs to http://www.example.com. http://example.com has bad links pointing to it and http://www.example.com does not. So essentially, I want to stop negative influences from http://example.com being passed on to http://www.example.com. A 302 re-direct sounds like it would work in theory but is this the best way to go about this? Just so you know, we have completed a reconsideration request a long time ago but I think the bad links are still negatively affecting the website as it does not rank for it's own name which is bizarre. Actual Question: How do I re-direct http://example.com to http://www.example.com without passing on the negative SEO attached to http://example.com? Thanks in advance!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | RiceMedia0 -
Quotery.com Suggestions?
Hello, I'm hoping to find some advice on how to proceed with a site I started last year — Quotery. I've spent a ton of time and money on it, tried my best to build value to what is typically a copycat niche, and adhered to Google's SEO recommendations (I believe, anyway). Yet, subpar sites rank well above mine. Now I'm wondering if I should find a buyer for the site and cut my losses. Does anyone have any suggestions on what the next steps might be in order to rank higher? Here is what we've tried/accomplished so far: We were mentioned on Netted. We built a well-designed and easy to navigate site that works on all devices. We've added topic descriptions and images, unique author descriptions and pictures, and exclusive picture quotes. We built a well-designed and useful WordPress plugin, and kept the backlinks nofollow (note: our main competitor also has a subpar WordPress plugin with dofollow backlinks, yet they don't get penalized for it). We've published curated blog posts, along with infographics that have been shared millions of time #1, #2, #3. We've built up significant social media profiles on Facebook, Twitter, and elsewhere. We even tried hiring 97thFloor (highly recommended on Moz) for 4 months, although most of their efforts seemed spammy and/or very basic to me (and cost a fortune), so we decided to take SEO into our own hands afterwards. We've added sources, pictures, and relevant information for thousands of quotes (e.g. example seen here). We started working on user profiles, and had plans for much more down the road. However, despite these efforts, sites like BrainyQuote dominate Google's rankings. So is it truly value that will earn you rankings... or is it still all about gaming the system? Of course, any suggestions in my case specifically would be much appreciated.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | JasonMOZ0 -
If linking to contextual sites is beneficial for SE rankings, what impact does the re=“nofollow” attribute have when applied to these outbound contextual links?
Communities, opinion-formers, even Google representatives, seem to offer a consensus that linking to quality, relevant sites is good practice and therefore beneficial for SEO. Does this still apply when the outbound links are "nofollow"? Is there any good research on this out there?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | danielpressley0 -
Question about duplicate listings on site for product listings.
We list products on our site and suspect that we have been hit by Panda as we are duplicating listings across our own site. Not intentionally, we just have multiple pages listings the same content as they fall into multiple categories. Has anyone else had the same issue and if so how did you deal with it?.. Have you seen a change in results/rankings due to the changes you made?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | nick-name1230 -
Link Anchor Text
As I keep studing SEO I reach to the conclusion that the Anchor Text from other site is crucial to get more positive results for our website and for the link-building strategy. My question is - Is it better to have an Anchor Text to my main link our should I ask for a determine targeted keyword? Tks in advance! Pedro M Pereira
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | PedroM0 -
Changing URL Structure
We are going to be relaunching our website with a new URL structure. My question is, how is it best to deal with the migration process in terms of old URLS appearing whilst we launch the new ones. How best should we launch the new structure, considering we've in the region of 10,000 pages currently indexed in Google.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | NeilTompkins0 -
Reciprocal link finder tool - not looking to do reciprocal links.
The company I work for had an old SEO company that did a lot of reciprocal links with websites that are not what we want to be associated with. Does anyone know of a tool that might be able to tell us if there are still reciprical links to our site? I want to try and find them, but the old pages we had with links going out have been deleted.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | b2bcfo0