Discontinued products on ecommerce store
-
Hi,
I have a high number of very-low/zero traffic and zero backlinked product pages that have been discontinued (and wont come back).
For these pages we automatically remove them from our website indexes and also removed internal links and then essentially kept the product pages and their urls intact but just added a note saying "no longer available, how about these..." with alternate similar product options. This seems to be the general consensus online for discontinued product pages that have little value.
The questions is do I either 404 or noindex these now discontinued pages? What are the pros or cons?
Thanks
-
Yes, I meant 301, server-side redirects.
Regarding performance, I currently have a little over 50,000 entries in my redirects file with no discernable performance impact. But, different platforms handle differently, and also we have a CDN which caches redirects too, so that could make a difference. I guess the safest approach would be to insert a hundred thousand or more dummy redirect entries into your redirect file, temporarily, and stress test it.
-
That's really informative, thanks!
I assume when you recommend I redirect discontinued pages to the associated category page you mean redirecting via a 301?
Sorry I probably wasn't very clear on my final point about my concern about having too many 301's. My main concern about building tens of thousands of 301's into my site was that it would potentially have an impact on how quick my pages loaded for users (and crawlbot) since it would have to check through so many 301 rules. Have you experienced this as a reason not to use mass implementation of 301s?
-
Th approach of redirecting with an informative message is potentially a good one. I have not implemented nor seen this done. If you go this route, make sure it is a true server redirect, with a 301 response code. But I could see how the redirect could include a query param in the destination URL which could then be used to display a fairly generic message.
As far as better vs. worse, from my perspective that differs depending on the nature of the products. One good use case for keeping the old product page around would be like a consumer electronics product page which contained technical info or resources which would be hard to find otherwise (but an alternative could be to have a support library for that). Another example, when I was on the agency-side, I worked with an apparel brand which each season introduced and retired thematic prints. And they kept a library of retired prints, which visitors could upvote to try to get them returned into service.
You wrote in your OP that these pages are zero/low traffic, with few backlinks. So, I'm inferring that the actual user experience isn't going to be really experienced very much.
But the reason to redirect to the category page, is to preserve any link equity the product page might have built up over time. Again, even if each product has very few backlinks, if you add them all up redirected to a parent category page, that could make a difference in how that category page ranks. If you can accomplish this without confusing real visitors (if any).
To your last point, yes it's possible that the search engine might consider some of these redirects to be "soft 404s". In which case, the link equity wouldn't be preserved because it would be treated like a 404. But, that's exactly what you're proposing to do anyway. So, if even just some of them get treated as 301s, you're ahead of the game, as I see it.
-
Thanks for the response. Just to further query...
-
Do you have any data or insights from you experience as to whether redirecting a user to a category page (with a message stating why they have been redirected) would be a better/worse user experience than showing the user the product page as is (with a similar message about being discontinued)?
-
Also the only thing that concerns me with the 301 approach is that we have potentially 10k products per year being discontinued. Wouldn't the inevitable ten of thousands of 301s cause a performance issue?
Thanks again
-
-
If you are keeping them, rather than redirecting them, I assume that means you have a reason for people to be able to find those pages so that they can get some information abot the discontinued product, or at least understand that it was discontinued. If that's the case, then I don't think you would want to noindex or 404 them. On the other hand, if there is no reason for those pages to still exist, from a visitor standpoint, then usually I would redirect them to a category page (generally the parent category the product belonged to), to preserve any link equity, even if the number of links are low. Especially if you have a lot of discontinued products from a category, even if each product had let's say on average 0.1 links, then if you have 1,000 of those pages you would end up with 10 backlinks to your category page, which could be valuable. Again, this is assuming that you don't want/need to preserve the pages for your users to be able to find the info.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Minimum amount of content for Ecommerce pages?
Hi Guys, Currently optimizing my e-commerce store which currently has around 100 words of content on average for each category page. Based on this study by Backlinko the more content the better: http://backlinko.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/02_Content-Total-Word-Count_line.png Would you say this is true for e-commerce pages, for example, a page like this: http://www.theiconic.com.au/yoga-pants/ What benefits would you receive with adding more content? Is it basically more content, leads to more potential long-tail opportunity and more organic traffic? Assuming the content is solid and not built just for SEO reasons. Cheers.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | seowork2140 -
Duplicate URLs on eCommerce site caused by parameters
Hi there, We have a client with a large eCommerce site with about 1500 duplicate URLs caused by the parameters in the URLs (such as the sort parameter where the list of products are then sorted by price, age etc.) Example: www.example.com/cars/toyota First duplicate URL: www.example.com/cars/toyota?sort=price-ascending Second duplicate URL: www.example.com/cars/toyota?sort=price-descending Third duplicate URL: www.example.com/cars/toyota?sort=age-descending Originally we had advised to add a robots.txt file to block search engines from crawling the URLs with parameters but this hasn't been done. My question: If we add the robots.txt now and exclude all URLs with filters - how long will it take for Google to disregard the duplicate URLs? We could ask the developers to add canonical tags to all the duplicates but these are about 1500... Thanks in advance for any advice!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Gabriele_Layoutweb0 -
Menu Structure for Large Ecommerce
Hi We have a large ecommerce site, the menu at the moment is limited by the amount of categories we can display. As our site is so large, the menu at the moment only has the top categories and their immediate subcategories, however we have level 3's which go deeper, as there is such a large range. At the moment, they;re not in the top menu, but I want to put a case forward to say why we should include them - I am however mindful of a menu not being overcrowded with hundreds of links. Has anyone had a similar experience of this? Or a case study on how adding important categories to the menu helped improve things? Becky
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | BeckyKey0 -
Optimizing for Branded and Unbranded terms - ecommerce
Hi, To date, we have gone with optimizing our website for branded search terms - we have done this by including the manufacturer + product name in the links to the product, product urls, page titles, h1's etc... Now, we are looking at optimising also for non branded terms - but all of our products are already optimized as above and I'm a bit lost as to how we would proceed with this process - my thoughts are: Create the generic categories, e.g, "Decorative Mirrors" But then, if they link through to the existing mirrors which are optimised for branded search, how do I go about it? Do I create a duplicate of the product and remove all the branded terms in the page title, h1, url and create new content for it? E.g., the same product but available twice... Doesnt seem logical from a user perspective but I cant think of another way to do this?? Thank you
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | bjs20100 -
Searching for SEO/SEM with eCommerce Experience
I've debated on whether I should ask this on the Q&A forum. Many times I have started to write it, then changed my mind. So today, after sending another round of emails out to potential SEM and SEO consultants and getting zero response, I said what the heck and decided to post it. I will point the finger at myself and say I must be doing something wrong in my approach and the way I am seeking out consultants or maybe what I am not saying. However, I cannot seem to get SEO companies to return my phone calls or emails. Is my company too small? Are most of the companies recommended here too busy with other work to worry about following up? Is my company and brand not sexy enough to deal with? Am I coming across wrong in my emails and phone calls? With that being said, I decided to write a post here and clearly state some basic and general requirements in hope someone interested will respond. I would be more than happy to answer and specific questions about my company, budget, etc. in a PM. I am looking for an SEO firm or consultants who: Will deal with small businesses with revenue under $2M. I have budgeted for this and am ready to start a project immediately. Have experience and a successful track record working with eCommerce sites who sell a large number of products. Interested in a long term relationship that will produce long lasting, durable results. Try to understand my business and what it will take to make grow my ONLINE profitability. I look forward to speaking to anyone interested. Jake
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | jake3720 -
How deep should ecommerce categories be?
Hello, I have a client with 300 products. He's thinking of about 20 main categories built mainly with the user in mind. How deep should each category be? For example, 3 clicks from the home page, 18 products on 2 pages (9 products per page)? or 2 clicks from the home page simplifying as many categories as possible to get them on one page? or what is the best practice for product indexing and usability? Thanks.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | BobGW0 -
Why Put an H1 Tag On A Product?
Why would you put an H1 tag on a product name? I came across this in another forum and thought I'd float it here.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | AWCthreads0 -
What directories are best for health or health related products?
I am trying to find out if there are any reputable directories related to health supplements and general health information.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | DonovanHarrell0