Is it reasonable to not give an SEO access to our CMS?
-
A client (we designed their website) recently employed an SEO who required FTP access or access to the CMS.
We told the client they would need to take full responsibility for any updates the SEO carried out, otherwise, the SEO could send over the changes and we would put them in at no extra cost to the client.
The client didn't want to take responsibility and denied the SEO access to the CMS, and told the SEO to send over the completed work for us to put into the site.
The SEO was not happy with this arrangement, and didn't seem to understand that we needed to trust him before access was would be given at a future date.
Other SEO's have never had a problem with this arrangement, but this SEO claimed what they do is secret and for no one else to see.
SEO want's to proceed, client doesn't want to proceed, we are happy to update the website with the client's approval. This particular client has a reputation for backing out of things. Also from the initial client, SEO contact the SEO was ready to update the website within 24 hours.
Are we being unreasonable?
-
Exact same thing has happened to us in the past too....
One of our clients is a major Canuck city's Economic Development dept whose mandate is to get new businesses and investors to come to their city to invest and open new businesses. At first, we too were denied access to anything - we had to create long Word .docs with full directions and screenshots of what to do and where to do it. However, after 5 renewals over the past 5 years, we were given full access to their site via both their CMS and ftp too...
Proving I'd suspect that trust needs to be "earned" - not given freely is how I'd see it...
Oh in another case another SEO client - a major Canuck University has not been able to give that same earned trust access as their site includes credit card info - buried deep and encrypted - but PCI specs say that they should limit access....so again we do the full Word .doc blueprints for their site....
-
you can use whatever CMS or code you want on this part.
How to keep your hosting and create a staging environment NON WordPress as well
you can use it on a server as bespoke as you please. (You must have root access)
https://confluence.atlassian.com/display/JIRA/Establishing+Staging+Server+Environments+for+JIRA
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3844369/git-production-staging-server-workflow
I hope this will be more helpful.
all the best,
Tom
-
Call me batty, but in 10 years and a bunch-load of clients (usually agencies), I've only touched a small percentage of sites. I write up the changes that need to be implemented so that designers/webmasters/programmers can either cut and paste what's necessary or have a good understanding of the changes that are necessary, and then I review once they're finished. If they do have questions, I help them by phone.
-
Cheers for all the information.
I don't work with Wordpress or Joomla.
Usually bespoke systems only.
-
Are you running WordPress? If you are here are a list of hosting companies that provide staging servers.
I'm glad to hear you guys are looking into possibly working this out hopefully it's just a miscommunication.
I think staging servers are a godsend and allow people to do things that they will know if they could have gotten away with are not once they try it.
This list is partial to staging every web post is very good there's one I state do not use unless you use their VIP plan I wish I did have to say that but I can't recommend them without stating that.
http://wpengine.com/plans/ (probably the best staging environment available)
You can get four months for free of WPengine & 30% off for life from Pagely via https://Moz.com/perks
https://kinsta.com/features/ (outstanding staging and hosting)
https://pantheon.io/features/version-control-workflow (awesome)
http://www.presslabs.com/ (great hosting and staging)
https://getflywheel.com/tour/staging-sites/ (must just say please turn on staging)
https://pagely.com/plans-pricing/wordpress-vps-hosting/ (one of my favorites but staging only available on VPS & enterprise plans. I must say it is worth it)
https://pressable.com/ (unless you're going to get a private “VIP” cloud the downtime is very bad and will hopefully get better soon but until then I cannot say use these guys in less you are going for the VIP plan an amazing staging set up.)
https://www.siteground.com ( inexpensive offers staging)
http://mediatemple.net/webhosting/wordpress/ (offers staging)
** How to keep your hosting and create a staging environment NON WordPress as well**
http://www.wpbeginner.com/wp-tutorials/how-to-create-staging-environment-for-a-wordpress-site/
https://confluence.atlassian.com/display/JIRA/Establishing+Staging+Server+Environments+for+JIRA
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3844369/git-production-staging-server-workflow
I think if the person is really trying to do things without other people knowing what they are that's not good. At the same time I would be wary of anyone keeping secrets.
I hope this information is a step towards you guys working it out.
Sincerely,
Thomas
-
We will certainly look into a staging server.
Although the web developer does some magic and I'm not usually updating the live site.
-
Unfortunately we weren't part of the process to hire the SEO company.
-
Try using a staging server it's kind of crazy to be making changes to the live site regardless. There are some great staging servers out there that will allow access to them then only once the site is definitely not broken or heard in any other fashion then you can move forward.
Saves you having to do their work and them having this issue. I do agree everyone talking about the secrecy stuff there's no secret sauce it's create the best website and best user experience.
Most people would be proud to say what they're doing not say that this is MI fives operation
-
I want to say I agree anything they say is "secret" is probably not white hat. I don't think anyone here is worried about someone stealing their formula for on page search.
However it's possible the person he's used to working in a certain way.
If you're going to do the work and allow them to delegate to you and you're actually going to do what they say I don't see an issue with it all.
-
Thought should then turn to the original decision made to hire that SEO firm and how a similar decision could be avoided in the future.
-
Thank you everyone for giving us feed back.
We don't want to be difficult but ultimately we are there to protect our client and to give them the best advise. We have already had one client suffer at the hands of a bad SEO, which cost them their on-line business.
After investigating this particular company, I've found plenty of complaints about them. I've also found they use linking farms. In this instant I'm glad I protect my client from them.
-
no its not being unreasonable - what happens if the SEO guy changed something and broke the website - would would the client ring up and moan at the SEO guy or the web design agency.
If the guy was willing to take responsibility for his changes, then they would be unreasonable, but why would they allow someone to edit their work and potentially break the site - only for them to get moaned at.
SEO is 'secret' anymore - so I don't get what they guy has from not willing to work with the agency. To me it sounds like he will be doing stuff he isn't willing to share so either black hat techniques or doesn't actually knows what he is talking about so was going to bluff it until the client clicked on that the guy was b*ll shitting.
-
In short- Yes, you are being unreasonable. You are not allowing the SEO to do their job, and will be hindering your own results.
-
"Other SEO's have never had a problem with this arrangement, but this SEO claimed what they do is secret and for no one else to see."
Run a mile!!!
-
Obviously I don't know the conversations between the client and the SEO.
We also do SEO work and alarm bells ring when something doesn't sound quite right. Such as "their website doesn't rank anywhere in the SE" when it's in position 5 for their chosen keyword.
Since posting this message I've had a quick look into the SEO company, they seem to work on linking from this domain which looks dodgy to me.
-
This is exactly how we work.
We don't want to block someone else doing their job, but to us it is similar to handing over full banking access to a stranger.
-
We aren't using this company our client is, we aren't stopping them from doing their job but have concerns about black hate issues.
-
I kind of have the feeling that there is something missing in the story. This is one of the challenges that happen when dealing with multiple hands in the kitty.
I wouldn't really buy the SEO's excuse of what they do is secret. Rather what they really mean is, we don't want to train another web company how to do what we do.
As a web developer I would understand why an SEO would want access, it could make things easier and faster. Having to go through company A to submit to get company C a change may not be exactly the service company A purchased.
As an SEO I understand why a web developer would be skittish about giving access to a company they had no hand in hiring. The web devs do a lot of hard work, some of which can actually be proprietary. I would of course in an SEO perspective be willing to work within those constraints if need be.
In the end it becomes Company's A issue. They need to find a compromise between company b and c. If it takes extra money to get the service for the SEO, or figure out which one they feel is the most valuable and fire the other and find a replacement that is willing to work within the constraints they lay out.
My thoughts..
-
I agree, I wouldn't have given them access without trusting them, all it takes is for them to alter one line of code and the site could crash.
Sometimes SEO's ( and I used to be like this but have changed) look at SEO in silo and don't think about how the changes impact other parts of the business / website - so a change that is good for SEO isn't always good for the website or the business.
So nope, I wouldn't give him access - our developers don't allow me access, I have to put a business case forward each time to get changes done, which has to be present and approved by senior management. Without this I could ask for a change which could cause a lot of issues.
-
Christina,
It's ridiculous that the SEO says what they do is secret. It's also ridiculous that they demand access to the site, else the changes won't be made. It seems like an easy enough solution though--if they want the business, then they send you the changes to incorporate, otherwise, the job goes to someone else.
-
I understand how that SEO feels you are preventing them from doing their job if you do not allow them root access.
If you do not trust them enough to actually be in there on the server then you should not be using them.
There are alternatives like staging servers but search engine optimization is done over a long time and definitely requires admin access to the server I imagine this person does not want you doing what you think is best and affecting their work just the same way as you do not want them affecting you by doing something else to the server.
A good SEO should work with a developer if they do not have that knowledge.
this is actually something a SEO should know before taking the job although it is definitely assumed.
I would not presume to tell you how to do your job I feel that they probably feel the same way.
Hope that helps,
Tom
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Do You Work At Home As An SEO Or Have An Office?
I'm curious how many of you all work at home or mostly at home either through an company or freelance. Or are most of you employed at a corporation? My company was recently bought by a very large global company. Recently I found out that all the SEO and web design is contracted through outside sources. With the headquarters in Europe, this being my primary job function I kinda feel well you know.... down.. Websites I put my life into for the last 7 years are going to be handed over to a corporation to do with whatever they feel they should. I know they were never really mine, but when you spend so much of your life to making them the best you can, so much so to attract the attention of a global billion dollar company, you should feel great right? But I feel like my dog just died. I don't have a bad impression of the company but the shift of moving me to the IT guy has begun. Normal web updates I would have done, are now being pushed aside. I don't hate IT I like helping others, but I really loved being able to make a difference through the web. Now I'm left contemplating my future, big corporations have so much bs, I just don't feel comfortable. I would really appreciate you all giving me your thoughts and tell me about any similar experiences you have had in your life. Cheers, Don
Industry News | | donford0 -
Where to Look for a Standard 9-5 SEO Job
Hello, I'm looking for a standard 20-30 hour a week SEO job. I'd like to make $30/hour. My resume is here. So far I'm making a list of all the SEO companies in Boise, Idaho. Then I'm going to also call up the larger companies in my local area. I'm interested in knowing how to best look for a job, and if there are any national companies where I could do work locally for. Let me know what other information I can provide.
Industry News | | BobGW0 -
Can not get the ranking needle to move even after a year with a US based SEO company
Hello community, I have spent the last 16 months spending lots of money on our USA Based SEO company and on content. For some reason. The powers who may be at Google are not giving us any love. I am beginning to become very dissapointed after all of our efforts. We did have a link penalty a year ago however that has long ago been removed. We have been doing everything our SEO company has asked us but the needle is not moving. Any ideas for us? http://tinyurl.com/n2yoeyn Thank you in advance. Chris
Industry News | | scamper0 -
SEO Service Needed
Any suggestion about hiring an SEO individual? Primary focus will be proper link/relationship building. What questions would you ask them? What is a fair compensation method? Can the compensation be based on results vs. effort? Thank you, Joe
Industry News | | csamsojo0 -
SearchDex for SEO consultation? Price feedback?
I know the JCPenny story from 2011 and read their CEO response to that. I've been pleased with my conversations with them so far and was given a reference that checked out well. Now us. We are a small business and our expertise is in print manufacturing and fulfillment. A portion of our business is running a network of retail websites related to the print business and that network generates six figure revenue, but we rely entirely on our affiliates to promote and drive traffic. I've been learning SEO for about 9 months - primarily just so that I can be informed while managing our direct to consumer initiative. But we don't have the internal expertise to pull off a campaign that is not heavily outsourced so that is why I'm open to talking with SearchDex. Does anyone have any feelings about them one way or another? Does anyone have a recommendation for me to talk to that might be an even better fit for what we want to do?
Industry News | | rickpeyton0 -
SEO-contests like “hochgeschwindigkeitsSEO” worldwide?
In Germany people out of the SEO industry seem to love SEO contests - the latest one being to bring up the keyword “hochgeschwindigkeitsSEO” on Pos. 1 on Google until a set time (contest entry example here). There obviously is a price (newest iPhone) and a sponsor (Randolf Jorberg), but for the most part it's a contest which holds the Olympic thought: Being there just means most of it 🙂 So I was wondering: are there any other countries where such contests are being held? I have not heard of any examples and I am quite curious if any other SEO communites out there have something similar going on 🙂
Industry News | | blueSummit1 -
How to pick an SEO pro?
I run a community site that has over 1 million pages of user-generated content specific to a very defined vertical. I recently switch to the Drupal CMS and have paid the price in the search rankings. I need to find someone to help with my site's SEO efforts. What should I be looking for when selecting an SEO professional?
Industry News | | proforums0 -
Do "big" SEO companies remove links after termination of service?
Or worded differently: Has anyone heard of "big" SEO companies removing links after termination of service? I have a client who isn't particularly happy with the SEO he's getting from a big Aussie SEO firm, and he wants to terminate, however they've built thousands of links for him and he's a little concerned they might all get pulled. Has anyone heard of this happening, or; Do you think this is a legitimate concern? I think its physically possible to remove backlinks like this because it seems the SEO firm in question is building links by using other client's websites. I also wonder if they might have large content farm style sites where they place links for clients which might be quite easy to take down. Please discuss!
Industry News | | CheapGames990