Thanks Zachary.
First off, how long ago was the site verified with WMT and how long ago did you submit the sitemap?
The sitemap was submitted at the end of August and verified around the same time.
It's clearly indexed at the search returns thousands of pages - I'm just wondering the why GMT dashboard is telling me it's not indexed, while Google search and Health -> Index Status is showing me that it is.
Also, as far as search queries, it could take months for that to really show useful data, at least in my experience.
I'd expect that queries would display here at the same time as they do in Google Analytics. Is that expectation wrong?
Thanks for your help!