I'm new and seeking help with the following scenario:
1. Main site: is a domain.com established authority type site
2. Second site: is a domain.org (has robots.txt to no index) but someone obviously not site owner has done negative seo campaign against the .org domain and built spammy links to it. In fact, that's all that exist on this second domain because it is used for development purposes only right now.) No one would link to this one normally as it is just secondary domain used to protect trademark and for development use.) When searching for it by domain name it does not appear on first page for search results. Checking link profile the only links that show for domain.org are spam links.
Have contacted site/s where spam links were placed (no answer)
Main site domain.com and domain.org have same whois and hosted on the same server as they are owned by same company
Main site domain.com still appears first for its name but has lost some rankings. I am working to fix some technical issues ie: duplicate urls with CMS etc, but would like to find out what to do about the domain.org content that clearly has had someone target it with spammy non requested backlinks.)
domain.com has Google webmaster tools account, no messages about unnatural liking in those reports
1. I'm not sure I should add domain.org to GWT to see if there is an unnatural link penalty applied or if this would further connect the two domains through association.
If I could get some feedback/suggestions on what my options are with regards to making sure that the domain.org domain has a clean profile that would be most appreciated. Also because site owner has would like to begin using domain.org in the future for some unique content, but as it stands right now cannot because domain has been targed by poor backlinks.
Anyone else run into situation where the .org or .net versions were targeted by spammy backlinks even though the domains were not actively used?
What's the safest way to proceed? a) Concerned about possible co-penalty between main site domain.com and domain.org b) how to remove problems issues with domain.org so that owner can use it in future.
Many thanks for your thoughts and help with this one. I appreciate any help or feedback.