Tags creating duplicated content issue?
-
Hello i believe a lot of us use tags in our blogs as a way to categorize content and make it easy searchable but this usually (at lease in my case) cause duplicate content creation.
For example, if one article has 2 tags like "SEO" & "Marketing", then this article will be visible and listed in 2 urls inside the blog like this
In case of a blog with 300+ posts and dozens of different tags this is creating a huge issue.
My question is 1. Is this really bad? 2. If yes how to fix it without removing tags?
-
I have different meta content since a long time still showing as a duplicate and on just looking at the body content it is identical. Is there any quick way I can manually add something to the robots file to take the duplicates away? Canonical is not working for me as it just points to the same url - not the MAIN one you want. So there is nothing as good as yoast for joomla, they should make that and make a lot of money! OOTB joomla is poor at seo if you dont know how to make menus in joomla your site can have massive issues. Without a tool like MOZ you may never know why your quality content can't rank - gee thanks joomla
-
Hi
Ahhhh... gotcha thought it was wordpress
Your best bet is to have a unique description generated in Joomla for each tag archive. Robots.txt won't necessarily remove the URLs from Google. If you want to deindex them, you need to use meta robots tag.
Anyhow, hope that got you in the right direction!
-Dan
-
Dear Dan,
Thank you so much for spending time on our issue and on the advice. Im looking forward to read your article.
Unfortunetly our blog for technical purposes is not in Wordpress but in Joomla, so i will look for a similar solution there. The desperate solution i guess is to disallow tag urls in robots.txt. But i would try avoid that. On the other hand, since i also use categories to index the content then i assume this will not generate any issue of hiding content.
-
Hey Guys
Again, whether full posts or excerpts are being shown for tag archives, is important (I would vote on excerpts) but see my answer above. The tag archives all have the same description. That's where Moz is likely getting the duplicate errors from - and not likely because of tag pages being similar to post or category pages.
The quick fix on this is to use an SEO plugin like Yoast and create a description template for the tag archives.
But BEST case scenario in a perfect setup, would be have tags totally unique from categories, and not index tag archives at all.
Canonicals should only be used sparingly and when no other measure can be taken.
It also seems this is not the best theme, so there are other issues at play as well, too many to go through in just a Q&A format.
-Dan
-
Hi
Just want to add two cents to this... a canonical should really be the last resort if it can't be resolved with robots meta, url structure, or content.
The issue here is that Moz is bringing back duplicate content errors because the tags all have the same description. This can be fixed (as noted in my full answer) by creating a description template for tag archives with a plugin like Yoast SEO.
The canonical may not resolve anything because the tag pages at best shouldn't be indexed to begin with - and if they are indexed, the descriptions should be unique.
-Dan
Edit - just realized they are using Joomla. The same can apply, but I'm not as familiar with Joomla, so if there's a way to create descriptions for the tags with Joomla that's the best bet still.
-
Hi!
Just need to clear things up here, sorry I'm a little late to responding!
1. Quick Fix - Create a description template for tag archives
You're getting duplicate errors because your tag archives all have the same meta description. Use an SEO plugin like Yoast SEO for wordpress something for Joomla and create a template for your tag descriptions. This will give each tag archive a unique description and eliminate the duplicate errors.
2. Long Term Fix - Root of The Problem
The real ROOT of the issue, is a combination of maybe a poor theme, no SEO plugin (that I can see) and tag pages being used incorrectly.
-
Tags should be completely different than any categories
-
And as standard practice I NOINDEX tags. Because there content is so similar to other pages, and it also may not be the best user experience. There may be exceptions to this but its a general rule I follow.
Now, with that said, don't just go deindexing your tag archives.
Tomorrow (May 8th 2012), I have an extensive article going up on the Moz blog about WordPress and duplicate content. I suggest reading that article to get a good understanding of how all the elements work. And perhaps in the long term you can work towards a more robust WordPress setup. But for now, no harm done the way it is.
Hope that helps!
-Dan
Edit - Realized they are using Joomla. The same concepts apply, but with a technical implementation that works with Joomla (which I am not as familiar with).
-
-
I think you should be good leaving it alone, then.
You could put rel=canonical on the post page only (don't put it on the tags or category pages) but that might be more trouble than it's worth, depending on the restrictions imposed by the CMS.
-
I don't believe the actual tag pages are the issue here. It's the fact that the same page can be accessed by 3 different url's because of the tags it's under. Canonical links will take care of this.
-
I am not sure if it's possible with the publishing system you are working with, but there are CMS systems on the market who have solved this issue.
They have done the following approach:
Create your main Article, Blog etc., tag them with your keywords and on your keyword page show the Article content as a teaser with a ''Read More" link to the full content page.
This is not considered as duplicate content!
Hope this helps!
-
Hi Pantelis,
I think that whether or not this is a problem, and how it should be fixed, depends on how your blog is set up.
The guide Justin mentioned is a good resource. Before you jump in, I think you should consider these questions:
When you go to domain.com/blog/seo etc. are the posts excerpted, or are full posts being displayed?
When someone clicks on the title of a blog post having found it under a tag (e.g. going to domain.com/blog/marketing and clicking on one of the posts) what URL is being displayed for the individual post?
e.g. is it domain.com/blog/seo/great-post-1 or is it domain.com/blog/great-post-1 ?
What really matters for duplicate content and canonicalization is whether the URL for the individual blog post is unique.
If the blog post has one unique URL, no matter how you get to it, and if the tags pages are displaying excerpts, then the only place you should be using rel=canonical is on the blog post itself. I think putting rel=canonical on a tags page that's only displaying titles and excerpts is asking for trouble. I don't like the idea of the search engines potentially thinking that your tag page, which has partials of many posts, is the original source.
If you're displaying full blog posts on the tags pages, then the solution is probably to switch it to excerpts and canonicalize only the individual blog posts.
Reference the SEOmoz blog: The SEOmoz.org/blog page doesn't use rel=canonical, and only displays excerpts, while seomoz.org/blog/post-title uses rel=canonical and displays the full post.
-
Its not really bad, but there is every chance it will affect your rankings as google will not know which page is dominant and in turn will not know which version it should show to searchers
the best method of resolving the issue is to use the rel=canonical tag as this allows you to tell google which page is the dominant version
see article here for more details:
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Content above the Fold, or Below
Hi, I have an ecommerce site with several categories that I consider good landing pages. In order to get better search results I add content to these pages, usually above the fold, then after the content products are listed. Example:https://www.carburetor-parts.com/Carburetor-Kits_c_568.html I worry that customers get to the page and since they don't see the products above the fold, they move on. Should I be putting content in the footer instead of the header and if so how does that effect SEO? This has been bugging me for a long time. Thanks
On-Page Optimization | | MikeCarbs
Mike0 -
What to do with repetitive content
Hi, I recently took over a site from another SEO firm. They created lots of articles targeting the same terms. The articles aren't bad but I fear they could dilute the site's ranking power for a given term. I don't want to give away the specific industry, but let's say they have eight pages targeting the term "______ billing software." I'd rather focus their resources on ranking one page for that term. Does that make sense? And if so, how do I do that? The company has a writer that can see if any of the content is good enough to add to their primary ______ billing software page. Would you 301 redirect all these pages to the one you want to rank, or would you canonicalize them? Or am I way off base in my thinking?
On-Page Optimization | | rich.owings0 -
To create extra pages, or not to create extra pages?
I'm responsible for a site where we cater for all kinds of medical & legal problems. I recently conducted keyword research that shows a lot of questions being 'asked' in relation to the conditions we cater for. Naturally, I want to create content to answer these questions. We have a page for 'Cancer compensation' - the 'possible content' that answers questions won't necessarily help someone claiming compensation for cancer mistreatment, BUT someone who asks a question relating to cancer, answered in the 'possible content' may find the 'cancer compensation' page useful. SO! Do I: Add this content to the existing 'cancer compensation' page? Create individual pages of content answering each question, linking to the 'cancer compensation' page? or do I amalgamate all the answers into one heafty 'resource' page that sits elsewhere on the site? What do you think? Thanks in advance. John King
On-Page Optimization | | Muhammad-Isap0 -
Removing syndicated duplicate content from website - what steps do I need to take to make sure Google knows?
Hey all, So I've made the decision to cancel the service that provides my blog with regular content / posts, since it seems that having duplicate content on my site isn't doing me any favors. So I'm on a Wordpress system - I'll be exporting the posts so I have them for reference, and then deleting the posts. There are like 150 or so - What steps should I take to ensure that Google learns of the changes I've made? Or do I not need to do anything at all in that department? Also - I guess I've assumed that the best decision would be to 'remove' the content from my blog. IS that the best way to go? Or should I leave it in place and start adding unique content? (my guess is that I need to remove it...) Thanks for your help, Kurt
On-Page Optimization | | KurtBullock0 -
Is This Duplicate Content Hurting Our SERPs?
We sell 1000s of audio book title, many of which are published in more than one format (abridged, unabridged CD, and/or unabridged MP3) by the same publisher. Currently each title has its own page but the basic description of the title (story) is the same. Here is an example title that is offered in three formats. 44 Charles Street - Danielle Steel - abridged CD audiobook 44 Charles Street - Danielle Steel - MP3 CD audiobook 44 Charles Street - Danielle Steel - CD audiobook Each of the above pages has a different page title, a different URL, a different meta description however much of the body (from [Listen to a FREE Audio Clip] down is the same. Is this duplicate content hurting our SERPs?
On-Page Optimization | | lbohen1 -
Mozbar # issue
Hi, When viewed through the Mozbar page analysis tool my Joomla site is always displaying a bullet point and space character before the site. Is this likely to effect search engine reading of my ? www.clearvisas.com - is the site. Please have look and let me know what you think. If you are a Joomla expert your feedback on my website and this issue will be really welcome. Thanks, Fuad
On-Page Optimization | | Fuad_YK0 -
Nofollow tags
So on the homepage, should all the links like privacy, contact us, etc...be rel="nofollow" ? I want to get a better handle on passing as much link juice on homepage to important internal pages as I can, and want to get it right. Thanks in advance.
On-Page Optimization | | azguy1 -
Would it be bad to change the canonical URL to the most recent page that has duplicate content, or should we just 301 redirect to the new page?
Is it bad to change the canonical URL in the tag, meaning does it lose it's stats? If we add a new page that may have duplicate content, but we want that page to be indexed over the older pages, should we just change the canonical page or redirect from the original canonical page? Thanks so much! -Amy
On-Page Optimization | | MeghanPrudencio0