New EU Laws governing cookies; will Google Analytics still be usable after May 25th?
-
Hi, first time I've posted a question, New EU Laws governing cookies; will Google Analytics still be usable after May 25th? - apologies in advance if its already been covered, but I couldn't find any answers when I searched - google search showed someone else ask the question already, but no straight answers were given:-
From May 25th the Privacy and Electronic Communications Directive will come in to force which prohibits the use of cookies without informed, prior consent from web users. I've been trying to research to see whether or not this will affect Google Analytics.The Directive seems to be designed to prevent behavioural tracking, rather than web stats, but after reading the directive (with no law experience) I'm fairly confused by what will be prohibited. If anyone has any thoughts on the matter, I'd be very grateful!
-
Today's YouMoz is also about this subject. http://www.seomoz.org/ugc/not-freaking-out-about-the-eu-cookie-legislation
-
I’ve been keeping an eye on this topic myself, specifically trying to spot new & useful information from authoritative sources. The main area that’s of concern for all our customers is the grey area of Analytical cookies.
These two might be of interest:
1. It’s not about cookies, it’s about privacy – That’s from the Government Digital Service who look at websites like direct.gov.uk. It looks at the subject with some common sense and raises an interesting point that focussing on cookies may push sites into tracking users in other ways; using super cookie methods that the user cannot detect or control/disable as they can with standard cookies, which would be more intrusive.
Interestingly the GDS has taken a stance that analytical cookies are ‘minimally intrusive’ and (most importantly) ‘essential’ – which is a different line to the ICO. There’s a link to a PDF with guidelines at the end for government departments and other public sector bodies:
“Use of web-analytics/metrics: The use of metrics are integral are to departments’ being able to provide the best possible user experience in order to encourage citizens to use more cost-effective channels for accessing government services. They also allow departments to assess and demonstrate whether the digital services they offer provide “value-for-money” as demonstrated by the recent National Audit Office (NAO) report.
Consequently, collecting these metrics are essential to the effective operation of government websites, at present the setting of cookies is the most effective way of doing this. The ICO guidance supports this view as it states ’...it is highly unlikely that priority for any formal action would be given to focusing on uses of cookies where there is a low level of intrusiveness and risk of harm to individuals. Provided clear information is given about their activities we are unlikely to prioritise first-party cookies used only for analytical purposes in any consideration of regulatory action’”
2. EU cookie legislation – a look at some of the implementations – That’s new as of Friday, written by one of the Information Commissioner’s Office Technology Reference Panel:
_”+ First of all the 27th May deadline for implementing the legislation is more a marker for ICO – not a hard date. This means that from this time the ICO will start looking at the subject more closely.
- In the meantime in the run up to the end of May the ICO will publish information for individuals to allow them to raise concern via the ICO website. Note the ICO has not had much activity on the complaints front in last 12 months.
- They will also be making it clear that on an individual level it is unlikely that ICO will pursue 1 cookie on 1 web page
- The ICO can’t audit every UK website but can look at trends or patterns – eg if many issues raised about specific types of cookie
- ICO will also be issuing a clarification of its line on analytics cookies – these are not exempt from the law”_
It’s certainly a topic where the regulation and solution is still evolving. Personally I wonder if this might end up in the same situation as the DDA subject from a few years ago; the end result being that the worst offenders get a letter asking them to clean up their act, but for the rest of us who follow good practices there’s nothing to worry about.
-
As with many things in government, most of this is a "fix" to a problem that doesn't exist. If you don't want to be tracked, you can easily opt out. But the EU seems to think it knows better and declares that ALL cookies must be opt in only. This rule screams that it was written by people who want to push an ideology (i.e. government is going to save your privacy at all costs) and have no idea how the Internet works.
The largest problem with this rule is that there's no way to ascertain why a cookie was placed (most commonly called a session). In virtually all cases, cookies are pointers to something else. What's stupid is that you can still easily track people without cookies, you just pass your session ID in the URL. It's clunky but it works and there's no law against it. And there's always log parsing.
My bet is that there will be some sort of legal action taken against Google (the biggest fish in the pond) and we'll see where that goes. My bet is it stays in limbo until that trial is complete. I can't see anyone wasting the resources going after every violator.
-
Hi Ben
I've been looking into this a fair bit myself and have arrived at the following conclusions.
As already mentioned this whole legislation is up in the air to say the least, there is little guidance on how this will be practically implemented. From what i gather, general cookies that enhance usability by remembering information such as preferences etc are ok, however cookies that hold information that is deemed to be personal are more of an issue. Therefore i guess the case you make regarding Google analytics could be an interesting one.
We look after a number of medium weight websites that use cookies, some of which could be deemed to fall foul of this legislation, however so is just about every ecom site on the Internet. I am taking the view that i will see how the big boys tackle this, the likes of Amazon, Ebay, etc and follow their lead. For me this is one occasion not to be ahead of the game, especially as it will interfere with the purchase process and pretty much goes against every UX rule out there.
One other interesting point is that almost every site i have seen cover this story (BBC, Mashable, TechCrunch etc) all use cookies on the pages they are reporting this story on.
I suspect there will be a lot more debate and tweaking of this law before it is actually enforced as it seems impractical to implement as it stands
-
Hi Ben
welcome to the Q&A.
As (other) Ben says, there's no real clarity on this. Best practice would seem to dictate giving site visitors the option to opt-out the first time they visit after May 25th.
In reality, nobody is going to do this and kill their webstats, unless and until site owners are taken to court, and IMO that's most likely to happen to high-profile pubic service sites.
I'd suggest that good practice and as insurance, review your Privacy Policy to ensure it's clear what's being tracked and what's not using cookies, and ensure there's a reasonably prominent navigation link to the Policy.
-
Last time I checked (last month) no body knew. There is a definite case for them being allowed as part of the functionality of a website but it looks like this is going to be decide the first time the ICO takes someone ot court over it.
Sorry I couldn't give you a straight answer but I don't think there is one yet.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
What would the US traffic increase be for a website YoY if all Google SERP rankings remained the same?
This question has come up a few times with some of our clients and I've spent some time researching this question, but I can't find an answer online so hopefully, someone at MOZ has this data available to them with all the data they collect. The data points that would be needed to answer this question off the top of my head: Increase in the # of Google Searches in the US YoY The decrease in CTR for organic results "10 blue links" which take a searcher off of Google YoY, as Google continues to keep more searchers on Google.com with rich snippets, increased AdWords prominence, AdWords extensions, etc I'm sure this greatly varies per industry, but an average for all industries is all that is needed to answer this client question. Many thanks in advance and I've included a video which hopefully helps to better explain the search "plus/minus" that we can expect to see as SEOs in 2018. WF1yLlJC6LetnpbD3
Search Behavior | | WebpageFX1 -
Privacy Policy requirements for Demos and Interests in Google Analytics
I have a client who is activating the Demographics and Interests in Google Analytics, and I need to provide an appropriate privacy policy, per Google's TOS. Can anybody suggest what to state in the privacy policy? Google says: "If you’ve implemented Google Analytics Demographics and Interest Reporting, you must also disclose in your privacy policy: How you use data from Google's Interest-based advertising or 3rd-party audience data (such as age, gender, and interests) with Google Analytics." So, I guess it's advisable to state that the site gathers "3rd-party audience data." Is it enough to say that the info is being used to better understand and communicate with the website visitor?
Search Behavior | | jrae0 -
Industry Benchmarks for Google Analytics
Hey Mozites! I was wondering if anyone has come across any good resources for industry benchmarks relating to google analytics? (Social stats would be great as well, but Google Analytics is my main concern) Specifically, I have a client that is a bank and I would love to be able to compare their stats (traffic, unique visitors, bounce rate, time on site, conversion rates...) to other regional banks. Any ideas? Thanks for reading and for your help!
Search Behavior | | iBecC0 -
Google indexing PDF's
Hello, We work heavily on E-commerce SEO and recently Google has started to index PDF pages (Datasheets) added to the product pages instead of the actual product pages. Has anyone else noticed this at all? Seems to have got worse over the last month or so. Thanks
Search Behavior | | voipme0 -
Google Analytics Search Engine Optimisation Report
Hello, Quick question. How much data should be available within Google Analytics within the Search Engine Optimisation Reports? I was always of the impression it was 6 months, however the data available as of this date only extends back to January 1st 2013. Thanks,
Search Behavior | | HelloAlba0 -
Will creating sub folders for foreign versions of the website, remove rank juice from the main site?
Hi, We plan to create sub-folders for our german, spanish and italian language versions. If we do will this pass rank juice to the new sites, but at the same time badly effect our main site, regards link juice/serp? Or is this not such a huge factor in people's experience? Many thanks. James.
Search Behavior | | Quime1 -
Google Places rankings go away, but organic rankings stay the same / get better?
Hello, I hope you all can help me out here with the information I could provide. Anyways, the past number of months I have had 1 of our clients rank extremely high organically and on Google places. For example: My client is a law firm so if you search “CLIENTS-TOWN Attorney” they would come up organically on the first page and if you were in that town and search “CLIENTS-TOWN Attorney” or even just “Attorney” they would also come up in the Google Places list. Now for some reason starting a week ago I noticed they have completely disappeared from Google Places. No changes have been done to their site and everything is the same as it was. Their organic searches are the same if not better than before. Do you guys have any clue as to why this happened and how I could possibly turn this around? Thanks for your help in advance!
Search Behavior | | WhiteHat120 -
How to test a site for usability with hundreds users and get genuine feedback?
My question is twofold; firstly is there a recommended company that I could use to get feedback on my site usability. Ideally I would like this company to arrange a focus group of a couple hundred people that fit into the right demographic and organise a report on the opinions of the group and the issues faced. Secondly an in-house understanding of usability Now I would like to think that when I review a site for usability I am not biased in any way. But I believe that if I look at the page that I have created or even collaborated on that I will always miss usability issues as I frankly think my/our creation is amazing. I'm interested to know how people rank and check their site usability and what factors rank highest in their assessments i.e. the tools you use and how you use them.
Search Behavior | | Stefan-Thorpe0