How do I Address Low Quality/Duplicate Content Issue for a Job portal?
-
Hi,
I want to optimize my job portal for maximum search traffic.
Problems
- Duplicate content- The portal takes jobs from other portals/blogs and posts on our site. Sometimes employers provide the same job posting to multiple portals and we are not allowed to change it resulting in duplicate content
- Empty Content Pages- We have a lot of pages which can be reached via filtering for multiple options. Like IT jobs in New York. If there are no IT jobs posted in New York, then it's a blank page with little or no content
- Repeated Content- When we have job postings, we have about the company information on each job listing page. If a company has 1000 jobs listed with us, that means 1000 pages have the exact same about the company wording
Solutions Implemented
- Rel=prev and next. We have implemented this for pagination. We also have self referencing canonical tags on each page. Even if they are filtered with additional parameters, our system strips of the parameters and shows the correct URL all the time for both rel=prev and next as well as self canonical tags
- For duplicate content- Due to the volume of the job listings that come each day, it's impossible to create unique content for each. We try to make the initial paragraph (at least 130 characters) unique. However, we use a template system for each jobs. So a similar pattern can be detected after even 10 or 15 jobs. Sometimes we also take the wordy job descriptions and convert them into bullet points. If bullet points already available, we take only a few bullet points and try to re-shuffle them at times
Can anyone provide me additional pointers to improve my site in terms of on-page SEO/technical SEO?
Any help would be much appreciated.
We are also thinking of no-indexing or deleting old jobs once they cross X number of days. Do you think this would be a smart strategy? Should I No-index empty listing pages as well?
Thank you.
-
Unique Listing Copy
I would try to get that unique content to the top of the source order - it doesn't necessarily have to appear at the top of the page - it could be in a sidebar for instance, but it should be first in the source so that Googlebot gobbles it up before it reaches duplicate stuff or secondary nav / footer links etc.
No Results pages
Yes, you could certainly noindex your no-results pages with a robots meta tag - that would be a good idea.
Loading duplicate content with ajax
In terms of Google and ajax content, yes Googlebot can and does follow links it finds in javascript.
All I can tell you here is my own experience
On my product detail template, I have loaded up category descriptions with ajax that appear canonically (if that's the right way of putting it) on my listing pages. In the SERPs, the cat description content is indexed for the pages I want it to be indexed for (the listings in this case), and not for the product detail pages where I'm loading with ajax. And these product detail pages still perform well and get good organic landing traffic.
On the product detail page where I'm loading with ajax, I have the copy in an accordion, and it's loaded with an ajax request on document ready. It might be considered slightly more cochre to do this in response to a user action though - such as clicking on the accordion in my case. The theory being that you're making your site responsive to a user's needs, rather than loading up half the content one way and the other half another way, if you get what I mean.
Sometimes of course you just cannot avoid certain amounts of content duplication within your site.
-
Luke,
Thank you for your detailed reply.
I forgot to mention that for each of our important filter pages (like IT jobs in New York) we do have a unique paragraph text which is human readable and at the same time SEO optimized (They are around 200 words long and is not there for all filter pages due to the volume of such pages.) This unique block of text rests at the bottom of the page, just above the footer, after all the latest 20 job listings are shown.
"Filtering & Blank Results Pages Could this not be done with javascript / ajax, so that Google never finds an empty listing?"
I am afraid this cannot be done due to the structure of our system. No-Indexing them would be much more easier. Wouldn't it do?
"You could load this content from an ajax template, either as the page loads, or in response to a user action (eg. click on a button 'show company details')."
Sounds like a good idea. Are you sure Google will not consider this as cloaking and that Google cannot read Ajax content?
"Try not to load up the duplicate description by default."- Do you mean we should implement Ajax again for this part?
"You will want to, where possible, specify a view-all page for Google"- not sure if this will be possible from our side due to engineering limitations. I thought rel=next and prev would solve the issue. However, I still see intermediate pages indexed.
-
Hi, I've tried to address your issues point by point according to your post...
Duplicate Job Posting Content
You can try to offset this by having a couple hundred words of unique copy per listing page url exposed to Google. So, if your page lists all jobs in the catering industry in New Jersey for instance, write some copy on the topic, and try to make it readable and useful to the user as well. Add microdata to the template using schema.org, so that Google can understand what's there at the data level - there will likely be entities available there to describe your content in terms of location, the companies that are hiring, etc.
I'm inclined to say don't bother with reshuffling duplicate content and adding bullet points to it - Google is smart enough to recognise that this copy is the same, and will not give you any points - perhaps the opposite - for trying to disguise this.
Filtering & Blank Results Pages
Could this not be done with javascript / ajax, so that Google never finds an empty listing?
'About the Company' Duplicate Content
You could load this content from an ajax template, either as the page loads, or in response to a user action (eg. click on a button 'show company details'). I have solved this exact problem like this in the past - loading a tour category description that appears on a great many tour detail pages.
Perhaps you can do as I'm suggesting above for the job description duplication - where possible, and as long as it's done in a way that does not come across as cloaking. It's good that you have a unique paragaph above the duplicate description.Try not to load up the duplicate description by default. I'm not sure on your source order or site / template structure so difficult to get too detailed here and I don't want to risk suggesting something that could be interpreted as a violation of Google's guidelines.
Pagination
You will want to, where possible, specify a view-all page for Google - this is suggested by them as a best practice, and in my experience, Googlebot loves to find chunky listing content, PROVIDED that it loads quickly enough not to hamper the user experience.
You can make sure of this by lazyloading images and other media. Be sure to specify the correct image src attributes (not spacer.gif for instance) inside of noscript tags to make sure that image content is still indexed.
You could also load up the markup for all items in the listing, and then use javascript to chunk the content into 'pages', or load it asynchronously where javascript is available. If no javascript, then load all content. By using javascript pagination, you basically avert the need for a separate view all page, meaning only have one template to maintain and optimise.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Woocommerce Duplicate Page Content Issue
Hi, I'm receiving a duplicate content error. It says that this url: https://kidsinministry.org/childrens-ministry-curriculum/?option=com_content&task=view&id=20&Itemid=41 is a duplicate of this: http://kidsinministry.org/childrens-ministry-curriculum I'm using wordpress, woocommerce, and not really sure how to even address this. I tried adding this to .htaccess but it didn't redirect the url: 301 Redirects Redirect 301 https://kidsinministry.org/childrens-ministry-curriculum/?option=com_content&task=view&id=20&Itemid=41 http://kidsinministry.org/childrens-ministry-curriculum/ Anyone have any ideas? Thanks!
Technical SEO | | a_toohill0 -
Google Webmasters Quality Issue Message
I am a consultant who works for a website www.skift.com. Today we received an automated message from Google Webmasters saying our site has quality issues. Since the message is very vague and obviously automated I was hoping to get some insight into whether this message is something to be very concerned about and what can be done to correct the issue.From reviewing the Webmasters Quality Guidelines, the site is not in violation of any of the guidelines. I am wondering if this message is generated as a results of licensing content from Newscred, as I have other clients who are licensing content from Newscred and getting the same message from Google Webmasters.Thanks in advance for any assistance.
Technical SEO | | electricpulp0 -
Duplicate Content - Reverse Phone Directory
Hi, Until a few months ago, my client's site had about 600 pages. He decided to implement what is essentially a reverse phone directory/lookup tool. There are now about 10,000 reverse directory/lookup pages (.html), all with short and duplicate content except for the phone number and the caller name. Needless to say, I'm getting thousands of duplicate content errors. Are there tricks of the trade to deal with this? In nosing around, I've discovered that the pages are showing up in Google search results (when searching for a specific phone number), usually in the first or second position. Ideally, each page would have unique content, but that's next to impossible with 10,000 pages. One potential solution I've come up with is incorporating user-generated content into each page (maybe via Disqus?), which over time would make each page unique. I've also thought about suggesting that he move those pages onto a different domain. I'd appreciate any advice/suggestions, as well as any insights into the long-term repercussions of having so many dupes on the ranking of the 600 solidly unique pages on the site. Thanks in advance for your help!
Technical SEO | | sally580 -
Duplicate Content
SEOmoz is reporting duplicate content for 2000 of my pages. For example, these are reported as duplicate content: http://curatorseye.com/Name=“Holster-Atlas”---Used-by-British-Officers-in-the-Revolution&Item=4158
Technical SEO | | jplill
http://curatorseye.com/Name=âHolster-Atlasâ---Used-by-British-Officers-in-the-Revolution&Item=4158 The actual link on the site is http://www.curatorseye.com/Name=“Holster-Atlas”---Used-by-British-Officers-in-the-Revolution&Item=4158 Any insight on how to fix this? I'm not sure where the second version of the URL is coming from. Thanks,
Janet0 -
Duplicate Content - That Old Chestnut!!!
Hi Guys, Hope all is well, I have a question if I may? I have several articles which we have written and I want to try and find out the best way to post these but I have a number of concerns. I am hoping to use the content in an attempt to increase the Kudos of our site by providing quality content and hopefully receiving decent back links. 1. In terms of duplicate content should I only post it on one place or should I post the article in several places? Also where would you say the top 5 or 10 places would be? These are articles on XML, Social Media & Back Links. 2. Can I post the article on another blog or article directory and post it on my websites blog or is this a bad idea? A million thanks for any guidance. Kind Regards, C
Technical SEO | | fenwaymedia0 -
SEO with duplicate content for 3 geographies
The client would like us to do seo for these 3 sites http://www.cablecalc.com/ http://www.solutionselectrical.com.au http://www.calculatecablesizes.co.uk/ The sites have to targetted in US, Australia, and UK resoectively .All the above sites have identical content. Will Google penalise the sites ? Shall we change the content completly ? How do we approach this issue ?
Technical SEO | | seoug_20050 -
What are some of the negative effects of having duplicate content from other sites?
This could include republishing several articles from another site with permission.
Technical SEO | | Charlessipe0 -
How do i deal with duplicate content on the same domain?
I'm trying to find out if there's a way we can combat similar content on different pages on the same site, without having to re write the whole lot? Any ideas?
Technical SEO | | indurain0