Hit by Google updates; Some good advice needed
-
Hi,
Here`s my domain http://www.kent-website-designer.co.uk/. Registered in 2007.
We have took a big hit from the updates in the last 6 months and its really affecting revenue.
I know when you look at the site you may well think WOW this is 2007 SEO and youre right it hasnt been updated in some time as of last year we ranked very highly and it gave us enough business to concentrate on. However up until last year many of my competitors were using same onpage and offpage strategies....and probably a few of you were too!
So now the inquiries and income is drying up. However, I provided myself with an income from my efforts, rather than be unemployed, so I want to get it back on track.
I visited the Google webmaster forums to query a couple of webmaster account queries and basically got beat up by the rude and arrogant google forum admins. Basically they said I was a spam site who shouldnt be in business. How very nice!
1. I have EMD - but domain age should mean something?
2. I lost a few links from https://www.getsafeonline.org/partners-and-supporters/ in the last year which hasnt helped when they reorganised their content. Same with other trusted sites we lost links. We are left with low quality links.
3. Some CMS sites have replicated our footer links on a large scale, which wasnt intentional but may look as link spam, plus they arent no followed as G prefers.
4. Google seems to have become intelligent? Apparently it can detect content which is negative in outdated seo advice. How, can it understand context and meaning so older seo advice isdetected as spam content?
5. No pages are de indexed just a rank drop to 30 - 60 positions.
6. Over optimised H1`s?
7. Is Pipe command in titles now negative?
So its sink or swim time I guess. The siteand domain is honest but neglected and probably should re align the business with what we can offer. We got away with that SEO but clearly things have changed. However with no grey or black hat at least we arent overly worried by removing links.
Also looking for an SEO company who we can outsource with a white label solution in order to offer SEO.
I dont need beating up, short and to the point critiques please. Pros and Cons
Many thanks.
-
Thanks Cyrus,
Well domain age is very important and the link clean up for up to 90% can be achieved by me.
There could be a correlation between the huge rise in footer links by the CMS`s and the period of the ranking fall, that just coincides with the Penguin update, then got noticed.
I really think that this could be the major cause of the problem. 13,000 footer links optimised for anchor texts in 6 months? Not a good sign. WMT is by far the most valuable tool for me as all is listed. Analytics show a 68% average drop in organic traffic...ouwch!
In meant time I can boost my adwords budget and hope.
Removing comment links? Just a case of contacting blog admins?
*Shall I keep the highest page authority links and make real effort on the blog comments and less quality domain authority first? I surely must be able to have anchor text links....I see lots of sites still ranking well from text link pages only and very thin content.
Cetainly no WMT messages from Google.
I just dont have the time to build thousands of manual links.....and if I do for SERPs its surely for trying to improve ranking. We all know that good SEO is really about improving ranking, else why do it. ....its a bit of a contradiction by Google.
NB. Have removed over 19,000 Links with unnatural anchor texts so thats a start!
-
Howdy,
Thanks for stopping in Q&A and letting us take a look at your site. Sorry to hear about the dip in traffic. It's blows when that happens.
Looking at your backlink profile in Open Site Explorer, it's pretty easy to see why you were hit. When I look at a backlink profile, usually the first report I go to is the anchor text report:
Unfortunately, this is exactly the type of link profile targeted by Penguin and other over-optimization updates by Google. Not going to beat you up... you admitted this was like SEO in 2007 - and these tactics worked then! So we're not here to lay any blame. Tens of 1000's of webmasters around the globe face similar issues.
Specifically, there's 2 things in your link profile that jump out at me:
- Over-optimized anchor text - Variations of "Web Design Kent" seem to comprise 90% of the backlinks.
- A high, high amount of comment links
- Tons of exact match footer links, as you noted
All of these together is a recipe for trouble. But you likely already know that. So the real question is, how to fix it?
You realistically have two choices: Ditch the site and start over, or do a thorough link cleanup and file a reconsideration request.
You probably want to try to save the site. I'd start by doing a complete site audit for low quality links. Our friend Paddy Moogan wrote a great post about this: http://www.stateofsearch.com/step-by-step-guide-finding-low-quality-links/
The big question is if you need to file a reconsideration request. Did you receive any messages in Google Webmaster Tools? If not, you may want to file a request just to see Google's response. Often they will verify this way if a site has received a manual penalty or not.
Also a good post by Ryan Kent on identifying penalties: http://www.seomoz.org/blog/identifying-link-penalties-in-2012
Understand that Google's reconsideration process can be a several month process. It's best to try to remove as many links as you can - (and show a serious effort to do so) and use the disavow tool as a measure of last resort.
Finally, and I can't stress this enough, the number one thing that helps after you've cleaned up bad links, is building good links.
Keep us up to date on your progress. With some work and due diligence, your site may come out of this fine.
-
Thank you Brian and Highway5.
Well on analysis I havent got any messages from G in webmasters account for my site or any of my clients.
Looking at Rands flowchart...site pages arent de indexed which I knew, ranks #1 for domain name and relative unique title pages are still ranking page 1, 2 or 3 . So in the words of sherlock holmes, after deduction the only left remaining factor must be the truth! So it must be an algo based change. Which lets face it, is the nicest option!
There must be some kind of memory effect with google because we had a high trust link to one page which we asked to be moved and link to my index page but the former page ranked highly for quite some time (years) although it only had the internal site links to it after.
Plan of action
1. Webmaster tools show 13000 footer links from various clients ecommerce websites as they have made a huge push in products......its a cms tech issue I can deal with immediately. These are ALL anchor text. I can edit all my sites for url based link rather than anchor text and add nofollow.
2. Ive put my money into the business this year with a series of pr web releases ($4000) and those releases have a mixture of url, main keywords and subpage keywords. This is a trusted site, so i am thinking that these pages are worthy enough and dont need amending. If im going to keep any keyword anchor texts it might as well be on those sites.
3. There has to be a point of where i still need concise anchor text over url or non keyword inbound links. Lets assume I find a 450 highly relevent sites, 250 non relevant sites and 150 directories to link from, is there a ratio of mixing these up?
4. OSE doesnt show all my links, only around 1800. I can remove about 18,000 links in a very short period.I think they class as over optimised spam links.
5. Not sure weather i should just ask for removal of links from the less relevant sites rather than adjust anchor text. If they are no value, why have links there anyway?
6. Again not sure when just to use the short anchor text or the anchor text in much longer sentances / paragraphs
7. Rewrite / remove of some content, ammend the H1`s to simplified version of the title.
8. Im battling with analytics (god thats is awfully difficult to use now) to find the traffic drop or ranking drop. I recall I lost web design in kent middle of last year but im sure even in November i still ranked 1 or 2 for website designers kent.
It could tie in with a certain algo update but i think we have identified enough reasons to start with and be getting on with.
9. Thank god for Adwords! Which is just about keeping me going.
NB. Looking at the analytics, its difficult to pin down exactly . Year on year there is a big dip in April 24 2012 onwards (and to date) which coincides the Penguin. I cant measure from October and backwards in WMT but the rankings are blown by then. My pageviews arent easy to use a guidesas my PR releases for this year skew the averages. Graph on graph is down April 12 onwards. Enquiries I got were probably Adwords so didnt notice rankings drop.
-
Hi Chris,
Can you time the drops in traffic and rankings? There are a number of places you can check the dates of the major Google updates. SEOmoz have a cool page here with the dates in by year although nothing yet for 2013
http://www.seomoz.org/google-algorithm-change
As Brian mentioned if its done to an algorithmic change then clean up your links (anchor key is key) and then wait for the refresh.
If is an unnatural link warning then you need to clean up your links and then ask Google nicely to remove the penalty.
There are lots of guides about reinclusion requests.
There is flow chart
Hope it helps
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
During major update rankings update seem to be on pause ?
Hello, I have read in the past that during a major update google puts all his ressources in the update and it seems that they don't update search results anymore. Has someone noticed that too ? How long does it take for an update to be rolled out fully and have everything get back to normal ? Thank you,
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | seoanalytics0 -
Penguin update... is this a good idea?
I have one site that got hit by the latest google updates. Penguin and EMD. The site was making me nice income but now with the traffic drop its not. I was going to 301 to a new domain but was reading that if it works to bring it back in the serps it would only last 3-4 weeks... then i though just get a domain and add the content over time and get rid of the old domain. + take care and build better links. I bought website that already ranks and been around since about 2003 online. Not hit by the updates and has few goood links. Would it be a better idea to move content to this site and make it grow? Not sure what to do..
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | samerk0 -
Why is Google Reporting big increase in duplicate content after Canonicalization update?
Our web hosting company recently applied a update to our site that should have rectified Canonicalized URLs. Webmaster tools had been reporting duplicate content on pages that had a query string on the end. After the update there has been a massive jump in Webmaster tools reporting now over 800 pages of duplicate content, Up from about 100 prior to the update plus it reporting some very odd pages (see attached image) They claim they have implement Canonicalization in line with Google Panda & Penguin, but surely something is not right here and it's going to cause us a big problem with traffic. Can anyone shed any light on the situation??? Duplicate%20Content.jpg
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Towelsrus0 -
Is there a way to contact Google besides the google product forum?
Our traffic from google has dropped more than 35% and continues to fall. We have been on this forum and google's webmaster forum trying to get help. We received great advice, have waited months, but instead of our traffic improving, it has worsened. We are being penalized by google for many keywords such as trophies, trophies and awards and countless others - we were on page one previously. We filed two reconsideration requests and were told both times that there were no manual penalties. Some of our pages continue to rank well, so it is not across the board (but all of our listings went down a bit). We have made countless changes (please see below). Our busy season was from March to May and we got clobbered. Google, as most people know, is a monopoly when it comes to traffic, so we are getting killed. At first we thought it was Penquin, but it looks like we started getting killed late last year. Lots of unusual things happened - we had a large spike in traffic for two days, then lost our branded keywords, then our main keywords. Our branded keywords came back pretty quickly, but nothing else did. We have received wonderful advice and made most of the changes. We are a very reputable company and have a feeling we are being penalized for something other than spamming. For example, we have a mobile site we added late last year and a wholesale system was added around the same time. Since the date does not coincide with Penquin, we think there is some major technical driver, but have no idea what to do at this point. The webmasters have all been helpful, but nothing is working. We are trying to find out what one does in a situation as we are trying to avoid closing our business. Thank you! Changes Made: 1. We had many crawl errors so we reduced them significantly 2. We had introduced a mobile website in January which we
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | trophycentraltrophiesandawards
thought may have been the cause (splitting traffic, duplicate content, etc.),
so we had our mobile provider add the site to their robots.txt file. 3. We were told by a webmaster that their were too many
links from our search provider, so we have them put the search pages in a
robots.txt file. 4. We were told that we had too much duplicate content. This was / is true, as we have hundred of legitate products that are similar:
example trophies and certificates that are virtually the same but are
for different sports or have different colors and sizes. Still, we added more content and added no index tags to many products. We compared our % of dups to competitors and it is far less. 5. At the recommendation of another webmaster, we changed
many pages that might have been splitting traffic. 6. Another webmaster told us that too many people were
linking into our site with the same text, namely Trophy Central and that it
might have appeared we were trying to game the system somehow. We have never bought links and don't even have a webmaster although over the last 10 years have worked with programmers and seo companies (but we don't think any have done anything unusual). 7. At the suggestion of another webmaster, we have tried to
improve our link profile. For example,
we found Yahoo was not linking to our url. 8. We were told to setup a 404 page, so we did 9. We were told to ensure that all of the similar domains
were pointing to www.trophycentral.com/ so we setup redirects 10. We were told that a site that we have linking to us from too many places so we reduced it to 1. Our key pages have A rankings from SEOMOZ for the selected keywords. We have made countless other changes recommended by experts
but have seen no improvements (actually got worse). I am the
president of the company and have made most of the above recent changes myself. Our website is trophycentral.com0 -
Are there new updates in Google Panda? Please help review my website...
My site have significantly went down in google ranking today. Is there a recent update with regards to google panda? Also, please help me review my website for possible errors so I may apply the necessary changes for my site to recover. Here is my url: http://www.homeescapade.com Thanks and God Bless
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Trigun0 -
Google Plus Links - Good for SEO?
I created a link on my Google Plus page under the recommended links with the relevant anchor text and url. It turns out that this is a do-follow link from a webpage with a Page Rank of 8. Is this just too good to be true or have Google genuinely missed something?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | MartinHof1 -
Have we suffered a Google penalty?
Hello, In January, we started a new blog to supplement our core ecommerce website. The URL of the website is www.footballshirtblog.co.uk and the idea behind it was that we would write articles related to our industry to build a community which would ultimately boost our sales. We would add several posts per day, a mix between shorter news stories of around 150 words and more detailed content pages of around 500 words. Everything was going well, we were making slow but sure progress on the main generic keywords but were receiving several thousand visitors a day, mostly finding the posts themselves on Google. The surge on traffic meant we needed to move server, which we did around 6 weeks ago. When we did this, we had a few teething problems with file permissions, etc, which meant we were tempoarily able to add new posts. As our developers were tied up with other issues, this continued for a 7-10 day period, with no new content being added. In this period, the site completely dropped from Google, losing all it's rankings and traffic, to the extent it now doesn't even rank for it's own name. This is very frustrating as we have put a huge amount of work and content into developing this site. We have added a few posts since, but not a huge amount as it is frustrating to do it with no return and the concern that the site has been banned forever. I cannot think of any logical reason why this penalty has occured as we haven't been link spamming, etc. Does anyone have any feedback or suggestions as to how we can get back on track? Regards,
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | ukss1984
David0 -
Check Google ban on domainname
Hello all, If I wanted to know if a domainname has a google ban on it would the following be a good idea to test it. Place an article on the domain page with unique content and then link to the page so its gets indexed and then link to the article from a well indexed page. If it doesn't get indexed there might be a ban on the page, if it does get indexed there is no ban on the page... Or are there other points I should keep in mind while doing this. All help is very welcome. Cheers, Arnout
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | hellemans0