How does a Responsive Site kill SEO?
-
How does a Responsive Site poentially kill SEO?
I've seen a few feeds on twitter how a website took a rankings dive after implementing a Responsive theme; yet, it's not clear to me what is actually going on within a Responsive site that would cause the SEO rank to tank? I can only speculate that it introduces a bunch of 404 errors, or that it changes all of the URLs into gibberish, so you loose all of the links coming into your website if not 301'ed?
Can someone clarify, what are the actual mechanical issues on a Responsive website that becomes a concern to SEO? Thanks.
-
Hello Jason,
This is one of the best (ok, IMO the best explanation of responsive design I have seen to date) especially laying out the difference between server side - dynamic design - and responsive. The thought you placed into this whole answer to provide one that is concise and cogent is excellent.
I like the point up about the lazy designer and page speed as something to be aware of.
Typically, as an agency, we are not often dealing with a client bringing mobile and desktop forward. It is more likely we will be dealing with someone whose site has lost appeal, power, relevance, etc. and we typically build responsive for all. So the thoughts around url changes are helpful as well.Thank You,
Robert
-
Hi Steve,
At this point I wouldn't say responsive design is fundamentally better or worse than other options from an SEO perspective. But there are a number of SEO pitfalls you'd want to avoid when moving from some other structure, to a responsive design.
First a Quick Set of Definitions:
"Responsive Design" means different things to different people. If you ask 5 people to define it, you'll get 8 different definitions.
Most people (including Google and the W3C) would say that "responsive design" is primarily using media queries and proportional layouts to adapt a webpage to different viewport widths on the client.
Detecting UserAgents is actually a server side technique that would commonly be used for an alternative approach to responsive design, that google calls "Dynamic Design".
Many people mistakenly call both Serve Side Adaption and Client Side Adaption "Responsive Design" when in fact there are important distinctions for SEO.
Changes in URLS can hurt SEO
In either case, if you're moving from having separate URL's for your desktop (www.mysite.com) and mobile (m.mysite.com) to a new design based on responsive or dynamic design, then you are going to be changing some URL's in the process. Any time you change your URL's you run the risk of hurting your SEO. The best practice is to 301 redirect all the m.mysite.com pages to their new www.mysite.com responsive design equivalents If you happen to be changing the main desktop URL's at the same time, it's even more important that you use 301's to preserve the equity in your old URLs.
Responsive vs. Dynamic
Google loves client side responsive design (it's the easiest/cheapest for Google to crawl), so it's actually their first choice, and you don't have to do anything special for responsive design SEO.
If however, you are doing "Dynamic Design" such as detecting user agents on the server to adapt pages for different devices, then you need to tell Google that the page will look different for different user agents. This is done using the Vary HTTP header.
Content Differences
Responsive Design means that you basically have the same content on your desktop and mobile version of your site. That can mean that you don't have keywords which are popular on mobile devices, such as "download mobile app" which can obviously hurt SEO for those keywords. Having a dynamic site (with different content for mobile and desktop) or even having separate URL's for mobile and desktop can sometimes give you a better chance to optimize your keywords for mobile searches.
Speed
Most Responsive Designs are slower than Dynamic designs or separate URLs. It doesn't have to be that way, as their are work-arounds for Responsive Design speed challenges. But fundamentally, responsive design means downloading more variations and code to the client, than a well behaved dynamic site, which means it's usually slower. Too often, lazy designers use the same images for all devices on a responsive design page, and then it's quite a bit slower.
Pagespeed is an SEO ranking factor so, it can hurt your SEO. If you choose Responsive Design, make sure you are only downloading properly optimized images for each device, and that you have highly optimized the pageload of your responsive design. Your users and your search engines will thank you for having fast pages.
Conclusion
Responsive Design doesn't have to be bad for SEO, and in many cases it is better for SEO than other options. The search engines have given us good options to have optimal SEO with any of the three major techniques for addressing device diversity, so I would't let SEO drive my architecture decision.
I'd choose separate URLs, Dynamic Server Adaption, Responsive Design Client Adaption, or mixes of the last two (Responsive Design with Server Side Components or RESS) based on my user base, the tasks my users are going to want to complete on each device, and my development resources, rather than any concerns over SEO.
All the best.
-Jason "Retailgeek" Goldberg
-
Steve
First, I stumbled onto this discussion and my mouth fell open as I gurgled out ... What the....
So, I then read the good answers from Thomas and Daniel and felt a twinge of relief. Here is what I suggest when you hear something like that: First ask the question It was your site that fell in rankings or someone elses? If they say someone elses, ask if they personally saw the rankings drop post implementation of the new design. If theirs, ask the same pointed questions if you were trying to help someone determine what the problem is.
Now, once you ascertain (and I am willing to bet over 90% fall into this group) that they never personally saw the data, you have answer one: Somebody said that somebody said. OK, not great SEO work. But, if they say it is theirs or they got to dig through, ask this How did it affect the rankings and how did you determine that was the cause? Now you are getting into some serious SEO detective mojo! That's where we find the real answers.Great question Steve!!
Good job Thomas and Daniel, Thanks for keeping the world clean!
Robert
PS - we build a lot of sites and 80% plus are responsive. We have see NO drop in rankings that could be attributable to a responsive design. BTW our site and several of our large firm owned sites are fully responsive and rocking cool. They are fine.
-
Hi Steve,
I think you should rephrase the question...
How can a responsive design harm SEO?
Typically a responsive design is driven by either USER AGENT or screen size... Both of these, if implemented correctly will not affect the way the Google Bot crawls the site. I would doubt there will be issues with 404's as the URL will be the same regardless of the device.
I would suggest it is poor implementation of the design.
Hope this helps!
Dan
-
The re-ordering of content on a page could give the page different emphasis. You would have to take a look at the page as a Google bot, to determine if the responsive theme displays the content differently. This could even go as far as throwing up links that should be navigational as content. What does or doesn't fall between a
and
makes a difference.
For the most part, I wouldn't expect a properly designed responsive site to change your SEO.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
HELP! IE secure page display issue on new live site
For some reason IE 7, 8, & 9 do not display the following page: https://www.jwsuretybonds.com/protools.htm All they show is the Norton seal. It shows properly in all other browsers without issue (including IE 10+), but the earlier versions flash the page for a split second, then hides everything. Can someone shed some light on this? This is a new live site we just launched minutes ago and these browsers account for 12% of our overall traffic. UGH I hate you microsoft!!! Thanks all 🙂
Web Design | | TheDude0 -
How do I optimize a site designed to be one scrolling page of content?
Our website uses section ID's as its navigation so all the content is on one page. When you click About Us, the page scrolls down to About Us. Products, the page scrolls to Products section, and etc. I am getting crawl errors for meta descriptions but will this go away once the main domain has this info? We just added the meta keywords and description to the header and since the navigation sections use the same page, I assume it will correct the errors. Any other advice on optimizing for site designs like ours would be great. www.theicecubekit.com is the site. Thanks,
Web Design | | bangbang
Chris0 -
So apparently SEO moz will get us de-indexed according to a SEO company!
Each and every day i get called up from an SEO company who promises to get me top spots in Google rankings if i quickly get on their special offer they have today normally i would say "no thanks and put the phone down" but i had a bit of spare time so i indulged the guy and we got talking. After the introductions and speal about his company he was showing me what his company does and how they go about it to get me top ranks (they don't get me ranks but create a website they own which then passes leads to me- kinda clever since they could then start charging me per lead or my competitors) We continued to talk and i mentioned i used SEOmoz to check my rankings and back links etc and he told me that Google are cracking down and anyone using these types of software/websites will get their websites de indexed. This struck me as BS but i wanted to get your thoughts on the matter, i personally don't believe Google would ever do such a thing as this since it would be so easy to get your competitors websites taken down (i.e. negative seo) but its certainly a talking point.
Web Design | | GarethEJones0 -
How to determine if my site map needs work?
I recently spoke to a consultant at a search conference who took a look at my site map and mentioned it looked like google would have a hard time crawling the site and indexing new pages and changes. I am managing an ecommerce site with a bunch of products, however, I am not an XML expert by any means so i'd appreciate any advice on what to look for in the site map that would possibly be affecting googles ability to crawl/index.
Web Design | | GregWhiteStarMedia0 -
SEO tricks for a one page site with commented html content
Hi, I am building a website that is very similar to madebysofa.com : means it is one page site with entire content loaded (however are commented in html) and by clicking on sections it modify the DOM to make specific section visible. It is very interesting from UX point of view but as far as I know, since this way most of my content is always commented and hidden from crawlers, I will loose points regarding SEO. Is there any workaround you can recommend or you think sites like madebysofa.com are doomed to loose SEO points by nature? Best regards,
Web Design | | Ashkan10 -
I need to buy a website template with seo focus - any tip? what technology is better?
Due to lack of resources, my company usually buys website templates and we adjust it internally. So we can always be with new designs, spending less money. With all this changes of google panda recently, I will change my website again. Usually we buy then from templatemonster, but some templates are far away from seo standards. Do you have tips where to buy than? Should I search for a specific technology or layout? Is this JS Animated website a goog choice?
Web Design | | Naghirniac0 -
How about some SEO tips for small local businesses
The amount of time I hear people say write good content and people will naturally link to you. I appreciate this must be valid for large websites that a driven by content. However, it doesn't really hold much hope for smaller businesses with just service information etc. I work for a small business that does web design in the UK. However, I'm finding it difficult to do any sort of link building. In my opinion nobody is going to link to any of our content naturally or if it is, its going to be small time. Our rankings have dropped slightly (only to 4th in our local county). I've done the following thinks to try get it back up there but its having little or no results. Adding us to local business directories External Articles on site Cleaned up some duplicate title tags. What link building can I do? Is link building the home page sometimes not always the way to go? What content can I write that google will like? See what I mean? My rankings did climb a little bit but then dropped straight back down to their original places 2 weeks later. Help would be appreciated.
Web Design | | sanchez19600 -
Do you have an SEO 'plugin' recommendation for SharePoint 2007?
I'm not a programmer and our 200+ person company isn't going to change their CMS just because I asked them nicely. Do you know of any SEO plugin I can use on SharePoint 2007? I just don't want to have to keep going into each of 110 websites time after time.
Web Design | | DaveGerecht0