Should I migrate clients site to older established domain?
-
I have a new client who had a domain that was established in 2004. About six months ago they moved their site over to a new domain and redirected the old domain to the new one. Their pagerank on the new domain is 1, and I can not find any historical data on the older domain. Would it be beneficial to move the site back to the old domain assuming that it had a higher pagerank? And is there a way to find out what the pagerank of the old site was before the redirect?
-
Oh... argh. Yeah, that makes step one easy. In some cases meta refresh acts like a 301 (if it's set to 0 seconds), and in others it doesn't, and there isn't a lot of rhyme or reason. Get the page-by-page redirects running, and you may see a pretty quick positive impact.
-
I initially that is what I was told by the webmaster. After running my own analysis it appears that they had a meta refresh.
-
I'm slightly confused - I thought you said the 301-redirects already were page level.
-
Thanks for all the help guys. I think I am going to use the new website and on the old domain use page level 301 redirects. Although the old page had a higher pr rank the new page is branded with the companies name. I am hoping with the redirects in place that the new site will catch up with the old ones PR eventually. Thoughts?
-
send Dr. Pete the information that I gave you in the PDFs after running it through all this it different tools showing what links go to which domains and I bet he will have a handle on it in no time.
All the best guys,
Tom
-
Ignoring toolbar PageRank (which can be very unreliable), have rankings and/or traffic fallen? What does DA/PA look like in our numbers? It's entirely possible the domain change was just a coincidence, but without historical data to compare to, it can be very tough to tell.
-
1. Yes I have verified as such.
2. It is redirected on a page by page basis.
3. The new page is the same as the old page with some additions here and there over the past three months.
4. I haven't seen any signs of bad links.
-
Did you happen to get my private message? I believe you are new site is going to blossom. However the tool you and I have both been looking for is been here the entire time.
http://www.seomoz.org/toolbox/pagerank
Please have a chance to read my reply in private message I hope it will be of help to you. Sincerely,
Thomas
-
I apologize the confusion was most likely on my side.
So the company had a domain that they were not happy with for around 9 years?
they purchased a brand-new domain from a registrar?
they move their site 6 months ago to this new domain because they preferred the name over the previous domain.
I agree nothing shady at all please excuse my last comments. Have to stop replying using a cell phone.
are you comfortable sharing that domain name? Either in a private message or in this form?
I would use tools like majesticSEO to determine the link profile of the older domain. then compared directly to the new domain if there is a huge discrepancy in the amount of relevant links I would say you are losing quite a bit.
Did you or did they to any 301 redirecting all? The reason I ask is that never hurts to ask this.
there is a plethora of tools out there that might be able to figure out what your previous page rank was however unless you had a lot of negative links or some sort of penalty going on with your older domain I would imagine it being much higher than a page rank 1.
If you did not do the 301 redirects as they are supposed to have been done and Dr. Pete has done great job of listing what needs to be answered.
"Fast forward to present day where I have taken over the account."
Did you take over this account less than 6 months ago or just recently?
if that's the case you may not really know what happened I'm assuming that makes this a lot more difficult considering if you are not there how would you know?
Do you know who did make the changes if you did not?
if so can you contact this person?
have you tried looking at your compared to your new domains traffic using compete or Alexa?
just to give you an idea of what's going on I would base it on majesticSEO's capability of showing you the history of your old domains back link profile. Obviously if there are quite a few more relevant domains pointing to your older domain comparison to your new domain that is going to make a big difference.
I would also of course look at the traffic using the tools I've mentioned above. I would also contact owner and asked them for a neat Google analytics data that you can get your hands on.
Sorry for my confusion earlier. I hope this will help you. And I would love to know the answers to these questions as well. If you would be kind enough to either paste the domain here or private message me at I would be more than happy to look those things up myself.
Sincerely,
Thomas
-
So, just to be sure: Six months ago, they 301-redirect the old domain to the new domain, correct? A couple of questions:
(1) Have you verified that this is a single-hop 301-redirect using 3rd-party header checkers? In other words, make sure it's working the way they think it's working. I don't say that to be condescending, but because I've seen it screwed up many, many times.
(2) Did they redirect on a page-by-page basis, or did everything just go to the new home-page? Are there potentially pages that got left out?
(3) Is the new page topically relevant to the old page (sounds like they're the same company)?
(4) Is there any sign of bad links on the old domain? Sometimes, links that didn't impact a domain after a long time can cause problems after a redirect.
-
Maybe I did not explain it correctly. My client has a company that has been around since 2004 with the same domain name. The simply bought a NEW domain(not existing from an auction) because they wanted to change their domain name. They moved their site 6 months ago to the brand new domain and pointed their old site to the new domain. Nothing shady happened here just a company wanting to change their domain name.
Fast forward to present day where I have taken over the account. There pr is 1on the new domain. As far as I know I can not determine what their page rank was on the old domain, but I assuming that it was probably higher than 1 because they have been using it for over 9 years and were getting about 10000 hits a month. I am wondering if it would be beneficial to move their site back to the old domain assuming it HAD a higher pr.
-
The domain that was purchased afterwards is going to rank just as your site is equal to whatever Google thinks it is equal to. They're not going to give you credit they know where the Site was that its been re Whois & reindex google knows exactly what's happened they know that who is has changed. And they probably even know that it's been doing auction. So if builder domain had links that were relevant to your site you might benefit from those. However if not you will not benefit from them they will hurt you. In the end unless you bought a domain because you needed it and it was a branding issue Google will most likely started back at zero it won't Happen right away but it Will not benefit you to buy a domain just because it is older and then reindex it and change this who is an think Google is going to give you credit. Those days are sadly over but at least you can get the domain you want I hope that's why you bought it why did you buy if you don't mind me asking?
Wow okay first off start off by looking at the new domain the older new domain and tell me the link profile using the http://www.opensiteexplorer.org/ here if you see any shady links that would We're not on the prior domain that would be a good indication that you've purchased a domain that is not any good. I personally think that purchasing hi PR Domains and trying to move them is coming to a end. However it can be done but it's on the very shady side of things and I would advise against it. On how would you know that it has never been penalized?
What was the prior page rank of the website before you moved it to the older domain that it is on now?
More importantly what was the Moz trust rank?
It seems that this is a fairly new website. And page rank of one or two should be expected for a short while. Google's not Just going to give you credit because you purchased a domain and then put 100% new content on it they know what happened. The only way I can see it working is if you actually purchased a hi rank real website keep Everything the same even the whois in the other person's name even then I would advise strongly against doing that.
Today you have to earn your way to the top of Google
please tell me about the frist Domains rank page rank and Moz rank did it suffer when it moved? I would advise against moving domains back-and-forth extremely strongly in less it has a very high page rank which would probably be diminished because of what's occurred. don't know how old this is a call if you give me some of that information I can give you some more advice.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Forwarding a .org domain to a .com domain: any negative impact to consider?
Hello! I have a question I've been unable to find a clear answer to. My client's primary domain is a .com with a satisfactorily high DA. My client owns the .org version of its domain (which has a very low DA, I suppose due to inactivity) but has never forwarded it on. For branding/visibility/traffic reasons, I'd like to recommend they set up the .org domain to forward to the .com domain, but I wanted to ask a few questions first: 1. Does forwarding low-value DA domains to high-value DA domains have any negative authority/SEO impact? 2. If the .org domain was to be forwarded, am I correct that an SSL cert is not necessary for it if the .com domain has an SSL cert? Thanks in advance!
Technical SEO | | mollykathariner_ms1 -
1 multilingual site, 2 domains in different languages.
My client wants a multilingual site: English and Spanish but with a domain name in both languages: jorgewantstofight.com And jorgequierepelear.com Is it possible? To have 1 site with both domains pointing each one to its version? and how this affects SEO?
Technical SEO | | Trazo1 -
Followed Linking Root Domains and No Followed Linking Domains
If you have more NoFollowed Linking Root Domains than Followed Linking Root Domains is that a problem?
Technical SEO | | INN0 -
302 multiple domains...
Hello, I have a few domain names with orthographic variations that I'd like to redirect to my main site. The problem is my registrar (OVH) does only 302 redirects, so what are my options ? Can I keep a dozen 302's ? Do I have to change all their DNS (it's a load on my server...) ? Thanks for any ideas Johann.
Technical SEO | | JohannCR0 -
Domains and subdomains
When I started a campaign for my message, I got the message: "We have detected that the domain www.vamospaella.com and the domain vamospaella.com both respond to web requests and do not redirect. Having two "twin" domains that both resolve forces them to battle for SERP positions, making your SEO efforts less effective. We suggest redirecting one, then entering the other here." I wasn't sure whether I had said it was a subdomain when in fact it was a domain (or the other way round), so I started another campaign for the same website using the other option and the message didn't come up. However, I still don't understand what you meant by this and whether it's an issue. When I search for my website in Google, it shows as vamospaella.com when other websites come up as www. and then their domain name. If it is a problem, is it to do with my hosting package and how it's set up or is it to do with my local site on my computer? I did ring my web host, 1&1, but they said they couldn't see a problem. Please can you let me know how I can resolve this as my ranking is still quite low in Google and I'm not sure why. If it is because of "twin domains", then will Google see my content as duplicated and keep me low in their rankings? I'm new to SEO and not a website novice, so please answer in lay terms! Thanks Melissa
Technical SEO | | melissa10 -
Help changing category and page titles on established Magento site.
Hi All, This is my first post, I've been a Pro member for a while now, read many posts but have never asked a question here. I have an established Magento site that I need to do a lot of SEO work on. I am a newbie at SEO, so I wanted to ask for advice here. I just changed one of the category names, the url, meta title, and meta description. When making the change I selected the checkbox in the Magento backend that says "Create Permanent Redirect for Old URL" Example:
Technical SEO | | TrulyLuna
Old Category: http://www.domain.com/old-category-name.html
New Category: http://www.domain.com/new-category-name.html Everything worked fine with the exception of one alarming thing... I lost all of the page authority for the category itself and all of the sub categories and pages below it. Now the category and all pages below it show (on the moz toolbar) a PA of 1 and 0 links and 0 domains. I updated the sitemap. I did not do a 301 redirect in the .htaccess, I only chose the option to redirect on the Magento backend when changing the name and url of the category. I need to change a lot of other category and page names and urls but now I'm a bit gun shy, as I do not want to do something that will damage what little page rank I have at the moment. I'm looking for some advice from one of you guys who might be able to help me do this the correct way. I did some research on Google, but I'm still not sure of the correct method to accomplish this. Thanks in advance for any help that you can offer.0 -
Domain authority and rankings?
I have a site that sits in #1 position for its keywords right now. But it only got there about 1mth ago. The site is only about 6mths old with lots of link building. I check the domain authority and its only 37/100 with the #2, #3 sites having domain authority of 57 and 82 respectively. This site has like 800+ backlinks. While the #2 and #3 sites have 20,000+ backlinks. Does it mean that my site will LIKELY drop in rankings very soon? I know there is no certainty but wld you say that it is highly probable my site will drop?
Technical SEO | | jl2550 -
Question about an older more obsolete site
I have a website that I don't use much anymore but it ranks on the first page for one of my main keywords. I am using another few websites in different niches right now that are doing better and are more functional. It may cost around 1,300 or so to get the website that I don't use anymore, to look and function in the new ways of the internet. Would you suggest that I: Do a site redesign (which is more difficult because to make the site do what I want it needs to be out of a wordpress theme) or 301 redirect the site to another one of my sites? Would it make sense to do a 301? The domain is 5 years old but doesn't bring in any leads anymore because it would take a redesign for that to happen. How can I still benefit from the SEO that I have done on that site? Thanks and sorry if this message is hard to follow. If I need to clear anything up please let me know.
Technical SEO | | blake-766240