What would be considered a bad ratio to determine Index Bloat?
-
I am using Annie Cushing's most excellent site audit checklist from Google Docs. My question concerns Index Bloat because it is mentioned in her "Index" tab.
We have 6,595 indexed pages and only 4,226 of those pages have received 1 or more visits since January 1 2013.
Is this an acceptable ratio? If not, why not and what would be an acceptable ratio? I understand the basic concept that "dissipation of link juice and constrained crawl budget can have a significant impact on SEO traffic." [Thanks to Reid Bandremer http://www.lunametrics.com/blog/2013/04/08/fifteen-minute-seo-health-check/#sr=g&m=o&cp=or&ct=-tmc&st=(opu%20qspwjefe)&ts=1385081787]
If we make this an action item I'd like to have some idea how to prioritize it compared to other things that must be done. Thanks all!
-
Hi EGOL,
Wow, thank you so very much. This is one of the best answers I've ever received, probably the best, here in Q & A. Your thoughtful comments and suggestions are so appreciated. Honestly, you gave me a check list of things that have potential to be pure gold for us if we act on them.
Yes, you are correct, this is the site that had many issues with content being under tabs. It's also got a tremendous amount of duplicate and thin content issues, in addition to orphaned pages. Progress has been coming along, slowly and surely, but having your comments, and having them be so specific, pointed and concise are something I can take to my team and say "Here's an awesome check list of things that we can actually address right now, without re-platforming the site [you know, there are always people who think that the root of all a site's problems is the platform that it's on...pure mythology]."
I hope many others find your check list useful. Combined with Annie's audit spreadsheet in Google docs, I feel like I have the tools I need to go to battle and help this site fulfill its potential. Nearly every point you mentioned struck a chord. Better yet, now that I know my way around the "guts" of this homegrown CMS, I feel like I can actually make the necessary changes.
Egol, I really can't thank you enough.
-
I totally agree Keri. Every word Egol wrote , to me, is worth its weight in gold. I think this may be the best response I have ever received here in Q & A.
-
If only people realized how much good information members drop in Q&A...
Once again, thanks for this EGOL!
-
From my experience, that is a frightening number of pages that have not received a visit. I would definitely be taking some type of action. This hits to me like a site in very bad health. I have lots of little pages on a weak little site that get a lot more traffic than none since January. This would be high on my priority list of things to solve. Solving this could bring major income so this is potential opportunity as much as it is a problem.
To diagnose, I would check.... I know you and suspect that you have looked at all of these but just making a list, just in case.
A) Duplicate content problem? Does this site have lots of pages with very similar other pages on the same site. Does the company have another site that is running the same product descriptions? Does the site run product descriptions that are used from a datafeed supplied to vendors? Are affiliates using the same content? Have other websites stolen the content?
B) Have you been scraped and republished by a strong website? Just one is all it would take. A strong site was once scraping and republishing some of my short content pages and that killed the traffic into a section of my site. As soon as I asked them to stop traffic was back within days. One site can hurt you like that or numerous small sites - even minor sites in Asia can do this.
C) Lots of thin content? Do you have a lot of pages that might only have two or three unique sentences? Google could be disrespecting your entire site because of this.
D) Technical problem? I would be looking at robots.txt and .htaccess, noindex, badly coded links, content management system causing duplicated title tags or other problems? Faulty analyitics that make it look like these pages are not getting traffic when really they are.
E) Content cannibalization? Lots of separate pages for red widgets that are being filtered from the SERPs.
F) Inadequate linkjuice? This is not a huge site but not a small one. Does it have a nice amount of linkjuice coming in?
G) Does this site have pages that are really deeeeep down in the linkstructure? Many clicks down? Fix that either with a new linkstructure or some kickass powerful links that hit nodes deep in the site to force spiders down. I would solve with linkstructure.
H) This isn't the site that had all of the content behind tabs that I remember from a while ago? (My memory is really bad so it might not even be your site.) If you have pages like that I would get rid of those tabs immediately. I have a personal opinion that Google does not treat content hidden behind tabs as well as content that is out in the open.
I) Are there a lot of other sites - strong ones - publlishing very similar pages - like product description pages - competing for the same keywords. If that is the case you could be crowded out of the SERPs and receiving no traffic on these pages.
J) Does this site have a bad history? Does it have something that might be causing a penalty or filtering?
After doing all of that you might have something that is really worth fixing. If you can't identify the problem I would be slashing, hatcheting those pages from the site right away.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How to effectively de-index in Magento site?
We have thousands of Missing Description issues but most of them are account/login pages. i.s. /customer/account/ etc... We tried to de-index them through the Configuration using the instructions here - https://docs.magento.com/user-guide/marketing/search-engine-robots.html But they're still appearing as issues in the Site Crawl. Even without the site crawl issue, we don't really want these to appear in the SERPs. Does anybody know how to properly de-index these login pages in Magento? Thank you!
Technical SEO | | LASClients0 -
Pages Indexed Not Changing
I have several sites that I do SEO for that are having a common problem. I have submitted xml sitemaps to Google for each site, and as new pages are added to the site, they are added to the xml sitemap. To make sure new pages are being indexed, I check the number of pages that have been indexed vs. the number of pages submitted by the xml sitemap every week. For weeks now, the number of pages submitted has increased, but the number of pages actually indexed has not changed. I have done searches on Google for the new pages and they are always added to the index, but the number of indexed pages is still not changing. My initial thought was as new pages are added to the index, old ones are being dropped. But I can't find evidence of that, or understand why that would be the case. Any ideas on why this is happening? Or am I worrying about something that I shouldn't even be concerned with since new pages are being indexed?
Technical SEO | | ang1 -
Website being crawled but not indexed any thoughts?
Hi Everyone,
Technical SEO | | Ant71
I created a new website a few weeks ago www.drivingseaford.co.uk , did a little link citation, links from Google+, submitted to webmaster tools etc but its still not getting indexed. Webmaster tools crawl stats page is showing pages being crawled, no errors. But 0 indexed. http://www.drivingseaford.co.uk/robots.txt is showing User-agent: * Disallow: /wp-admin/ Disallow: /wp-includes/ Im a bit stumped as never had this before!!! Any ideas from you lovely people?? Antony0 -
Example of Google Indexing my Feedburner Links
As you can see, there are 2 results for the same page. One is the correct page URL, the other has the Feedburner parameters at the end: http://www.thewebhostinghero.com/articles/improving-user-engagement-with-the-right-blog-commenting-system.html http://www.thewebhostinghero.com/articles/improving-user-engagement-with-the-right-blog-commenting-system.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+thewebhostinghero+(TheWebHostingHero.com) Can this cause duplicate content issues? Can I prevent Google from indexing my Feedburner links? My Feedburner settings are already set to noindex, what else can I do?!? 22cfThX.png
Technical SEO | | sbrault740 -
How different should content be so that it is not considered duplicate?
I am making a 2nd website for the same company. The name of the company, our services, keywords and contact info will show up several times within the text of both websites. The overall text and paragraphs will be different but some info may be repeated on both sites. Should I continue this? What precautions should I take?
Technical SEO | | savva0 -
Google Indexed Only 1 Page
Hi, I'm new and hope this forum can help me. I have recently resubmit my sitemap and Google only Indexed 1 Page. I can still see many of my old indexed pages in the SERP's? I have upgraded my template and graded all my pages to A's on SEOmoz, I have solid backlinks and have been building them over time. I have redirected all my 404 errors in .htaccess and removed /index.php from my url's. I have never done this before but my website runs perfect and all my pages redirect as I hoped. My site: www.FunerallCoverFinder.co.za How do I figure out what the problem is? Thanks in Advance!
Technical SEO | | Klement690 -
How to get Google to index another page
Hi, I will try to make my question clear, although it is a bit complex. For my site the most important keyword is "Insurance" or at least the danish variation of this. My problem is that Google are'nt indexing my frontpage on this, but are indexing a subpage - www.mydomain.dk/insurance instead of www.mydomain.dk. My link bulding will be to subpages and to my main domain, but i wont be able to get that many links to www.mydomain.dk/insurance. So im interested in making my frontpage the page that is my main page for the keyword insurance, but without just blowing the traffic im getting from the subpage at the moment. Is there any solutions to do this? Thanks in advance.
Technical SEO | | Petersen110 -
Would this be considered keyword cannabalization?
If I have an article, titled 7 signs of unhealthy eating and the title tag for five different pages looks like this: keyword | article title ex: Binge Eating | 7 Signs of Unhealthy Eating ex: Lack of Fruits & Vegetables | 7 Signs of Unhealthy Eating etc, etc.
Technical SEO | | nicole.healthline0