Google has indexed some of our old posts. What took so long and will we lose rank for their brevity?
-
Hi,
We just had a few of our old blog posts indexed by Google. There are short formed posts, and I want to make sure we're not going to get dinged by Google for their length. Can you advise?https://www.policygenius.com/blog/guaranteed-issue
-
No problem. Screaming Frog (or any crawler) won't pick it up, because it's not being linked to within the website (it's an "orphaned" page).
Google could still index them because they are in the sitemap, but it took so long because they are no actually linked to from the website.
So... if it's not supposed to be indexed at all in the first place, you can add a meta "noindex" tag to the page and remove it from the sitemap. Then you'll be all set
-
Thanks, Dan!
Is there a reason why Screaming Frog wouldn't pick up, even though it was on the sitemap to be crawled?
Google has actually indexed two pages for these pages here (trailing slash and non-trailing slash). We've got our 301 redirects and canonical tags setup correctly though.
To add another layer to this puzzle looks like this URL shouldn't be indexed at all, as it is instead of the home of content referenced in other places, like here: https://www.policygenius.com/blog/glossary/life-insurance.
Appreciate the help!
Looks like this URL shouldn't be indexed at all, as it is instead of the home of content referenced in other places, like here: https://www.policygenius.com/blog/glossary/life-insurance.
-
It was probably indexed so late because Google couldn't find it
I just crawled the whole site with Screaming Frog and that URL wasn't picked up in the crawl --> http://screencast.com/t/xzunkNR3K
But it's in your sitemap --> https://www.policygenius.com/blog/post-sitemap.xml - so this makes total sense why it took Google so long to find it
-
It depends on how accessible they are to search engines. If you've recently updated your sitemap, and those posts are on the new one, but weren't on the old one, that could cause it. New internal/external links pointing to those pages could have helped as well.
-
Thanks for the responses! Is there a reason why some of these pages were indexed so late (we published them several months ago)? We've had some newer posts index quicker than this one. I know there's not an exact reason, but trying to get some insights.
Thanks!
-
Hi Francois,
As Logan said, the problem comes when the whole site has short content issue.
I might ask, if that post is ranking well, why dont you edit it and creat some valuable content? Google loves when re-editing and improving your content.
Hope it helps.
GR. -
Hi,
As long as that's not the bulk of your content, I don't see it being a problem. Thin content penalties are more common when short-form content is the majority of a site. I've mostly seen this with ecommerce sites where product detail pages make up about 95% of the page count and the product descriptions are thin or non-existent. It's hard to be viewed as authoritative or trustworthy when only 5% of your pages have a decent amount of content.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Google mystery: Website ranks inversely proportional in 2 countries for the main keyword. Any ideas or thoughts?
Hi all, Our website ranking for mail keywords is inversely proportional in the 2 countries (US and India). I mean...if the ranking is improved in one country, it drops in other country and vice versa. The graph looks like exactly something triggered and making this happen at Google. I wonder what might be reasons for this? We have been facing this for more than a year and made number of on-site changes, so I presume if it's something to do with backlinks. Any clue or thoughts on this? Thanks
Algorithm Updates | | vtmoz1 -
Not showing in Google map listing. Why?
We have a client who's law firm is the highest google reviewed, on page two or three of St. Louis personal injury lawyer, but does not show in the map listing. Any ideas why this would happen or how to ensure they are viewable in the map listing?
Algorithm Updates | | David-Kley0 -
Distinguish a Post from a Category
Hi Community, The company I work for wants to create a blog as a subfolder from https://www.petpremium.com/ (we are working on it's structure yet). Our main site its build on wordpress and so our blog (with a differente design). What would be the best way to distinguish a post from a category if they are in the same level of the url, example (example.com/blog/CATEGORY/ and example.com/blog/post-name-here). Or should a post always be under a category? Im asking this because the way we have it, we need to place a .html at the end of the title to make it clear that the title is NOT a category or tag.
Algorithm Updates | | revimedia0 -
Google Penguin update
When Google Penguin update will run again. The last time was in October 2013 and I'm still really curious now. Or have they stopped this and this is now continuously just like the panda?
Algorithm Updates | | NECAnGeL0 -
How to show your ratings in the Google SERP
I've noticed that some organic search results are showing ratings just above the meta tag. How are these sites doing this? Example: If you search "cash advance", there is a result between #4 and #6 in the organic results. The site is "goldcashadvance.com". It's showing a 5-star rating in the result.
Algorithm Updates | | sparagi0 -
Lesser visited, but highly ranked landing paged dropped in rank on Google. Time for a content update?
I noticed that my page one ranked landing pages that don't get a lot of love from me have dropped in rank big time on Google this week. This is a site that has static (meaning, I can't freshen up the content easily) landing pages for products that we sell. The pages that dropped are the ones that have the fewest inbound links, and don't get much attention on the social media side. Our most important landing pages have also dropped, but just a few spots on page one. This is a first for me. Does anyone think that this is a "lack of freshness" penalty? We are still number one on page one for our brand search terms. Would fresh content give me a shot at getting the pages back up? I'm willing to update them slowly, but before I go crazy, I'm reaching out to the pros here.
Algorithm Updates | | Ticket_King0 -
Google UK search volumes
If a user searches using Google.com but is based in the UK, is it classed as a Google UK search or a Google US search in terms of monthly search volumes? Most of my clients are targeting UK consumers and often rank well on Google UK but outside the top fifty for Google US. I have mentioned that that is fine unless a client happens to use google.com. Am I talking rubbish?
Algorithm Updates | | Switch_Digital0 -
Some rankings fluctuate dramatically
Hi guys, just a quick query this one. For one of our keywords, the rankings are fluctuating wildly. One week we went up 32 spots, then the next friday we were down 28. Nothing dramatic was being done to the site, I have not been trying to "force" any rankings instead focusing on just making our content better. It just seems odd that one week we're on page one, then a few days later we're down on page four. It seems impossible to actually maintain a reliable ranking. I know to expect some fluctuation but every week it's up 20/30, then down 20/30 the next. How can we try to give this keyword some stability? Ideas?
Algorithm Updates | | JetBookMike0