Did any one else notice rankings drops since 14th-21st Feb this year?
-
Hi everyone,
I'm looking for some guidance please. Our website saw a drop in rankings on around 14th - 21st Feb 2019 and the rankings haven't really recovered. I can't see anything significant in Search Console, there was a possible unconfirmed algorithm update during early Feb but I can't really find anything factual to determine if this was the cause.
The ranking drop seems to be across different keywords.
What else should I check?
Did anyone experience such a drop around this time and if so found out why this happened and how to recover?
Thanks for your help
Caroline
-
Hi Caroline,
Recommendations would be to do as you have suggested review keywords, & pages.
Make sure you have a robust About us section that proves you are experts, look to introduce new high quality and relevant content.
Start actively searching for relevant and quality backlinks.
Steve
-
Hi Steve,
Many thanks for sending the links over. I've reviewed them and there seems to be some suggestions that algorithm updates happened around the time mentioned (14th - 21st).
There are few posts on here: https://www.seroundtable.com/google-search-ranking-algorithm-update-27131.html and here: https://www.seroundtable.com/google-search-ranking-algorithm-update-27077.html mentioning updates around this time.
There's the Valentine's Day update: https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-update-valentines/293451/ which talks about the algorithm focusing on relevance.
https://www.thewebmaster.com/google-updates/google-update-12-february-2019/ talks about the relevancy of content, E-A-T and how we should look at the keywords each page is targeting.
So it looks like there have been algorithm updates that may have affected our site? Some of the above links talk about how people saw their rankings recover shortly after the update. Ours dropped (our rankings practically halved around 14th - 21st Feb) and remained at this level until around 18th April where they have improved very slightly.
What would your advice be? Maybe review the keywords & pages that have dropped in rankings and check if we are utilising the most suitable keywords for those pages?
Thanks again for your help
Caroline
-
Hi Caroline,
thanks for the response. It appears that you haven't made any changes that would have this sort of impact.
You have checked everything I would look at and found nothing to show that the site may be "broken" which is good.
Here are some links which show minor changes around the dates you have asked about, take a look and see if they may relate to your site. If they do please let us know. If not again let us know and we can keep on investigating.
https://www.seroundtable.com/category/google-updates
https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-update-valentines/293451/
https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-february-march-2019-updates/297493/#close
https://www.thewebmaster.com/google-updates/google-update-12-february-2019/
https://moz.com/google-algorithm-change
https://www.seroundtable.com/google-search-ranking-algorithm-update-27077.html
Hopefully this will help you.
If not as I say let me know.
Steve
-
Hi Steve,
So sorry for the delay, I've been manic. Amazing thank you for the info!
I don't think any changes have been made to sitemap.xml or the htaccess files. Sitemap.xml is automatically updated when we create new pages on the site. However, I have asked our developer if he has access to a change log just to be sure, so will let you know.
I've used Moz's On Demand Crawl and there are 73 crawler warnings (no critical crawler issues), please see a breakdown below...
- Meta Noindex (50 total) - these are all blog category or blog tag urls
- URL Too Long (12 total) - these are all blog URLs which I will improve and create 301s to the new url
- Title Too Long (5 total) - I will update these
- Missing Description (5 total) - I will update these
- Missing or Invalid H1 (1 total) - this is sitemap page on the website
I'm guessing none of the above would have affected rankings, the Meta Noindex warning has been visible in Moz for over 18 months, its not a recent warning.
I've looked in GA and I have compared the second half of the month, including the week where we saw a drop in rankings (14/02 - 21/02) with the first half of the month (14/02 - 28/02 vs 30/01 - 13/02) and below are the results:
- Organic: 2%
- Direct: -14%
- Referral: 12%
- Social: -61%
The keywords are pretty static and the vast majority are higher during the second half of the month. If I should be using different dates for comparison please let me know and I'll take another look.
I've looked to see if there is a particular site that stopped driving traffic to us but there isn't one really. Facebook and Instagram traffic reduced due to a change with campaigns but all other referrers' figures increased.
The site speed according to Google's Page Speed Insights is 37/100 (mobile) and 77/100 (desktop). We are currently working on some of the recommendations but we haven't seen a huge improvement so far. The report suggested we would benefit from around 7 seconds by serving images in next gen format (WebP). We implemented this change last night and the mobile score only increased from 33 to 37. We have also properly sized a couple of images and ensured text remains visible during webfont load.
Is there anywhere else you recommend I look into?
Thanks very much for your help
Caroline
-
Hi Caroline,
Apologies for the delay in replying it's been a busy day.
- ok that's good
- The change looks good and was made a few months before the drop in traffic so it should not be related
- you can use MOZ on demand crawl, SEO power tools or if you are using any SEO tools they should pick it up.
- Good work
Did you check the sitemap.xml and the htaccess files to see if there had been any changes?
When you look at Google Analytics is there any particular traffic source or keyword that has suddenly dropped or is it roughly the same across the board?
Again if you let me know the answers to these questions I will try my best to help further.
unfortunately, I do not have any websites in the leisure market so cannot compare there.
Steve
-
Hi Steve,
Many thanks for your reply
The website is for a leisure company, their site has been live for over 18 months
1. The site has been on https for a couple of years
2. The only change to robots.txt was made by myself in Dec where I added the below, no other changes have been made as far as I can think:
Disallow: /basket/
Noindex: /basket/3. What is the best way of detecting redirect issues? Is there a particular tool you recommend?
4. We have 1 x 404 which I've just corrected and I've just created 2 x custom 404 reports in Google Analytics for future reference.
Is there anything else I can check please?
Thanks again, Caroline
-
Hi Caroline,
it would really help us to help you if you could share more information, such as the topic of the site(s), URLs if you can (we understand this is not always possible) but if you could give us an idea as to the topic this will really help us.
Otherwise, we can only provide generic information and guestimates.
Some things to check
- Did you make any significant changes to the site - implementing HTTPS for instance
- Has someone changed your sitemap, robots.txt or htaccess files
- Are you having redirect issues?
- Are you getting more 4xx errors in Google analytics
Steve
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Any suggestions why I would rank 1 on google and be on 3rd page for bing/yahoo?
Currently the site I'm working on ranks very well on google rankings but then when we cross reference into yahoo and bing we are basically in the graveyard of keywords. (bottom of 3rd page). Why would that be? Any suggestions or things I can do to fix this or troubleshoot it? Here are some things I can think of that might affect this but not sure. 1. our sitemap hasn't been updated in months and URL changes have been made 2. Onsite for yahoo and bing is different from google? 3. Bing is just terrible in general? 4. Inbound links? This one doesn't make sense though unless the search engines rank links in different ways. All jokes aside I would really appreciate any help as currently the few top ranked keywords we have are about 30% of our organic traffic and would have a huge affect on the company if we were able to rank as we should across all platforms. Thanks!
Algorithm Updates | | JemJemCertified0 -
How long does google take to re-ranking pages in results?
I mean when google dance, the pages in results go up and down frequency every minue, but finally your page will rank in any position in google, what is the time when you get another position in google
Algorithm Updates | | engtamous0 -
Hummingbird - Client took hit. Anyone else?
I recently landed a client about 2 months ago. About 1 month ago organic started to go down. I'm not 100% sure it's Google hummingbird. Has anyone else looked at their GA or GWT and seen a decline?
Algorithm Updates | | Francisco_Meza0 -
Does adding lots of new content on a site at one time actually hurt you?
When speaking with a client today, he made the comment that he didn't want all of the new content we'd been working to be added to the site all at once for fear that he would get penalized for flooding the site with new content. I don't have any strong data to confirm or refute the claim, is there any truth to it?
Algorithm Updates | | JordanRussell0 -
A Serious drop in Pages crawled per day
On 21st April ,I spotted a sudden decrease in pages crawled per day.Previously it was about 5,000 bust after the drop it reached to 225.From the crawl rate never spiked. Here is my website url - http://www.wpstuffs.com/ 8fQHW2G.png
Algorithm Updates | | vividvilla0 -
Dropped out of Google top 50 - Jan 28 2013
On Jan 28 - 2013 google dropped many of our keywords from its index.Here is the history of Rank June 24 2012 - RANK 2 Nov 18 2012 - RANK 8 NOV 25 2012 - RANK 15 JAN 6 2013 - RANK 10 JAN 13 2013 - RANK 21 JAN 20 2013 - RANK 9 Jan 27 2013 - RANK 6 JAN 28 2013 - DROPS OUT OF GOOGLE Graph http://i.imgur.com/ABYJ3MS.jpg The ON PAGE is an A for the homepage, errors and warnings are all DOWN over time. Would the last Google Update have caused this? Bing and Yahoo went UP and google dropped right out http://i.imgur.com/vP8Uvu8.jpg The red box is the keyword in question, but many others dropped out of top 50 Anyone have any ideas on what I should look for or which update could be responsible? ABYJ3MS.jpg vP8Uvu8.jpg
Algorithm Updates | | syndicate1 -
301 from multiple domains to one single webshop
First of all i want to introduce myself. My name is Jennifer and i am a webshop owner from the Netherlands (we sell plants/herbs products) I have a very important question (and i can`t find a clear answer on the internet). So i hope someone can help me, At this moment me and 4 other friends own each a seperate webshop. We all started the webshops 5 -7 years ago and work all in the same business. (plants/herbs). We talked last week, and we want to make one big company and combine all 5 company`s. All 5 webshops have a huge pagerank, lots of organic traffic and very good incomming links. We registered new domainnames and want to redirect the 5 "old" domains to one new domain to pass over the Google juice. Our new company is a multilanguage webshop and each language has its own domain. (for example) (www. plantsandherbs example .nl)
Algorithm Updates | | snorkel
(www. plantsandherbs example .de)
(www. plantsandherbs example .de)
(www. plantsandherbs example .es)
(www. plantsandherbs example .fr)
(www. plantsandherbs example .com) Does it harm us if we 301 redirect all the 5 "old" websites to the new webshop? And what is the best way to redirect the "old" webshops to the new one? I am afraid of a Google penalty because it maybe looks like we bought some domains to pass the juice to the new project.0 -
How did my Page Authority and Page Rank disappear?
I've hit a problem. A couple days ago my site's page authority was 51 and the PR was 3 and now they're 1 and 0 respectively. The developer did adjust some of the code in the site in the past couple days but that shouldn't have affected this. It was last cached by Google on the 5th. Can anyone offer some good advice? If it helps the page is www.duracard.com
Algorithm Updates | | Andrea.G0