Forum being heavily penalised
-
Hi everyone,
I've just signed up for Moz and I'm getting well and truly stuck in. I have just completed my first site crawl and have a frightening 5,363 errors and 25,319 warnings.
The main culprit is the forum on my site, it contains hundreds of pages dating from as far back as 2002. It is full of Duplicate Content, Duplicate page titles and a fair few 404 errors where old links are now outdated.
Can anyone advise what would be the best course of action? Should I hide the whole forum from Google's robots? My only concern with doing this is the loss of hundreds of pages of regularly updated content which I feel is boosting SEO.
Help!
Thanks guys
-
Your welcome. If that was your issue and you have a lot of pages, I am sure this will help a lot.
Have a great day and happy holidays.
-
Great advice Matthew, I have actually gone through and setup dynamic meta tags as you suggested, I'm hoping that should get rid of the majority of duplicate titles.
Mafiasecurity - The software is Snitz Forums 2000.
Thanks for your answers guys!
-
What software are you using for the forum? phpBB, SMF, YaBBa, vB, IPB, MyBB etc?
-
Are you referring to duplicate meta titles or actually pages that are the same>
if it is meta then I would personally setup dynamic meta tags as a quick fix. I would then make it pull from the titles of each post , this way you will have unique meta tags and cut down on some errors quickly. You can obviously still define the pages you want to define like your home page with manual tags instead of dynamic.
Again that is a quick fix instead of going over 1000's of pages all at once. This is better than hiding the whole site.
Have a great night.
Matthew Boley
-
I am not an expert on forums.
In general, you can noindex/follow the individual threads if they are causing a problem.
The category pages might be SEOed to pull traffic and they could be planned to pull traffic on valuable topics.
But, before those things are done you should get an assessment from someone who has watched and experimented with forums to get best results.
That's about all I can say on this topic.
-
Thanks for your reply EGOL.
I agree that hiding the whole forum wouldn't be the greatest idea but I just wonder how heavily my main site is being penalised due to the thousands of Duplicate Page Titles / Content in my forum?
Is there a way of hiding just the page titles of my forum pages or is it all or nothing?
Thanks again
Gareth
-
"Should I hide the whole forum from Google's robots?"
Heavens, NO.
If you want good, reliable, actionable advice a lot more information will be needed.
Anybody who tosses out ideas based upon what you shared is shooting at a blurry target.
Also, this type of problem is not one that can be diagnosed by a person who spends 20 minutes surfing through your website and 20 minutes typing you an answer. They will probably need to get under the hood.
Consider hiring someone who has experience with the forum software that you are using and knows how to structure them for optimum treatment by google.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Google Answer Box For Old Forum Discussions
Thinking about taking some pages that are one question discussion form pages and attempting to gain an answer box in Google SERPs. Just like here on Moz, each page has one questions and often many, many, answers. This would mean making an unordered list with the question and the components of the answer in a box, maybe with a jpg. The info in the box would be kind of a summary of key points in answering the question. I'm looking for suggestions on: a) Is this a good idea? b) What might help achieve the intended search result? c) Does it matter that the box answers are summarized from a variety of folks forum posts, so not just one author? d) Might it drive up bounce rate on the actual page? e) Other considerations? These are pages that have been around for awhile and aren't currently active discussions. Thanks!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | 945010 -
Is it ok to 301 redirect this previously algorithmicly penalised site?
Hi All, Is it OK to 301 redirect site A to site B? Site A: http://goo.gl/P9Zp2y Site B: http://goo.gl/ySDCzb The story - in 2013 site a seemed to be penalised with some kind of anchor text algorithm penalty - SEO couldnt fix, so created site B and turned site A into a holding page with a no follow link to new site. SEO company worked on disavow file etc, implemented in late 2013 301 redirect site A to B in late 2013 - SEO advised to stop 301 about 8 weeks later... This was my fault i didnt realise the implications of a redirect... Stopped the redirect, but too late, as site B dropped in rankings in early 2014 - new disavow files uploaded to both sites, but damage seems done now. No longer have a SEO company, and i would ideally like to 301 redirect site A to B, as it looks messy having a holding page - but wanted to check if SEO would still strongly advise against that? please advise James
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | isntworkdull0 -
Confused about SEO for Forums (Status Code 200)
I recently created a forum for my website (lets say my site is xyz.com so my forum is forum.xyz.com) and I've been getting status code 200s for tons of my forum pages about duplicate content- especially for threads that have a ton of interaction. Is there a way to fix this? I want my forum to be indexed and not get penalized, but if i canonical tag my main forum page wouldn't that take away the glory the awesome interactions my users are having? Anyone with forum experience can shed some light on this? Thank you so much!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | kentien930 -
Recommendations for other good SEO forums?
I learn so much from reading the Moz forum everyday. I would like to expand my learning and start following some other SEO forums as well. What are your recommendations for additional SEO forums?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | GregB1230 -
Question on starting again after being penalised for bad links
Hi, in a scenario where you have been heavily penalised for bad links but the quality of your site is good, If you put the exact same version of your penalised site on a new domain (with no redirects), would Google recognise it and penalise it again, or would that give it a completely fresh start? Any advice or experience with this would be much appreciated. Thanks.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | em_welsby1 -
Suggestions for a cost effective, SEO safe domain that was previously penalised
Hi, I will try to explain my situation as clearly as I can, and any positive advise would be greatly appreciated. Obviously please let me know if you have any questions but I'm sorry the domains are private. I started by business 4 years ago and launched a website (site A) and worked hard to promote it in the best way I knew how. It brought in a good income for around 3 years but then was hit with some sort of google penalty/filter! Knowing then what I know now would probably of avoided the problem altogether but that's another story... So I brought another domain (site B) and started again with a new design and completely re-branded the company, and again have been working hard to promote it. It has been preforming well and there has been steady progress 😉 However since then I have been steadily promoting the penalised site (site A) and keeping an eye on it to see if the penalty/filter may be lifted. It had initially lost around 75% of traffic, but recently has been doing much better in SERPS and is again on the increase. My problem is that with my company now being completely re branded I want to keep consistency but (site A) looks old and dated compared the new one (site B) and I don’t want to be confusing users etc... So I need a cost efficient and “safe” solution to this in terms of SEO and budget. 301 Redirect to site B I thought of a 301 redirect “BUT” I'm concerned about the penalty/filter being passed onto the new site (site B) and have read this dose happen ? Complete Redesign/brand for site A This would probably be the best option except I'm limited on funds. I would need “another” full commerce site as its just way to much money at the moment. Remove site A completely Funds are tight and I'm still feeling the affects of the penalty so really can't afford to loose any traffic at all! Use site A as a micro-site I thought a micro site with just the main product landing pages being used. I would use the same design as site B, then re-write the text and then link everything to the new site. “BUT” I'm concerned about getting another penalty (duplicate) as all the anchor text links going to site B site would be identical! EG. To use the same design as site B I would need to use the same layout etc including navbars, anchor text links in the footer etc.. and I'm worried this may trigger a duplicate content penalty ? I hope there are some suggestion for my situation and thanks in advance for your help. Thanks Chris.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | doorguy880 -
List of Best SEO forums
Could I please get some input on a list of the best SEO forums out there besides SEOmoz? (Both mainstream and non mainstream)
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Luia0 -
NOFOLLOW in Forum Topic External Links?
We run a busy aviation website, with lots of members who post external links within our forum. Currently, we implement NOFOLLOW tags on all external links or links to external sites not in our domain portfolio. Would we benefit from removing the NOFOLLOW attribute? Would we benefit from keeping it? Your thoughts and suggestions are greatly appreciated.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Peter2640