Plurals and the SEOmoz On Page Report Card
-
I have some pages on my website that receive an "A" grade with the SEOmoz On Page Report Card if I use a plural term in a phrase (say, "landscape designers in Dallas") but an "F" grade if I use the singular term (say, "landscape designer in Dallas").
Is this a true and accurate reflection of how search engines see the page?
Am I going to rank well for plural terms but not for singular, given the specific on-page content I'm using in this example?
Or is this an opportunity for SEOmoz to tweak its' algorithm to better reflect the search engines?
-
Thrilled to help! I know it's a pain, but it's worth it!
-
Good advice, Matt, and thanks for taking a moment to provide an actual data point!
And yes, we definitely take a balanced approach combining on page, off page, PR, social, and more. This just happens to be "on page" day for me.
-
I'm a huge fan of the SEOmoz Report Card, and what I would say is that it rates your page for the provided keyword, not for variations. The Report Card is meant to be a tool, and like any tool, the user and the users brain is an intended element.
I would say that if your primary exact match searches prefer a plural, over a non-plural, you primarily optimize towards the plural, but you also build anchor text links that support both.
If I were in your shoes and I got an F, I would go in and use the non-prefered phrase in an effort to reach a "B" or a "C" letter grade from the report card tool.
Google does discriminate against plurals. I just ran a test using one of our clients, with the plural, and then without, and they were #1 for the plural, and #2 for without, with someone else ranking #1. The plural does matter, thus if you're targeting the plural, and you were given an F by the Report Card tool, you will get SOME credit for Partial Match usage, but probably not enough if you're optimizing based on on-site factors alone.
Remember, per the 2011 Search Engine Ranking Factors, on-site SEO only make sup what, maybe 16% of the sites total ranking?
My best answer is a balanced strategy, with a diversified backlink portfolio that covers multiple bases of anchor text, both exact and partial match, plural and singular.
Cheers!
-
Hi Matthew,
I agree with all of your points.
Nevertheless, I still think that it's overdramatic for the On Page Report Card to go from an "A" grade to an "F" grade when changing a single letter. It just doesn't seem to reflect the reality of how search engines look at content.
Akira
-
Hi Ahirai,
This is a great question and something that comes up quite a bit.
Google has some basic forgiveness for Plurals, but you want to mix up your keyword placement at least a little bit so that you're not 100% exact match (this is my opinion, others might disagree). Naturally, websites are going to reference keywords in partial match and exact match formats, and my belief and in my experience I've seen Google give credit for partial match keywords above and beyond simply following the SEOmoz Report Card.
What also supports this is your inbound link anchor text. Diversity is everything. You want to have some nofollow links, you want to have some exact match anchor text links, some brand name anchor text links, some partial match anchor text links. Google doesn't respond well to 100% Exact Match thinking.
We're all taught, in link building, that No Follow is bad, but what if all the competitors have 30% NoFollow links on average, and your site has 0% NoFollow links. That might sound like really good SEO, but you've created an unnatural Backlink Profile.
So mix up your usage as best you can, within reason, and use a majority of exact match keywords, but also use a few iterations and variants as well.
We get so hung up on the keywords themselves, but often just as important is the words that are around the keyword, the "Trees" that support your "Landscaping", etc. You have to look at the bigger picture.
Hope this helped!
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Filter Pages
Howdy Moz Forum!! I have a headache of a job over here in the UK and I'd welcome any advice! - It's sunny today, only 1 of 5 days in a year and i'm stuck on this! I have a client that currently has 22,000 pages indexed to Google with almost 4000 showing as duplicate content. The site has a "jobs" and "candidates" list. This can cause all sorts of variations such as job title, language, location etc. The filter pages all seem to be indexed. Plus the static pages are indexed. For example if there were 100 jobs at Moz being advertised, it is displaying the jobs on the following URL structure - /moz
Moz Pro | | Slumberjac
/moz/moz-jobs
/moz/moz-jobs/page/2
/moz/moz-jobs/page/3
/moz/moz-jobs/page/4
/moz/moz-jobs/page/5 ETC ETC Imagine this with some going up to page/250 I have checked GA data and can see that although there are tons of pages indexed this way, non of them past the "/moz/moz-jobs" URL get any sort of organic traffic. So, my first question! - Should I use rel-canonical tags on all the /page/2 & /page/3 etc results and point them all at the /moz/moz-jobs parent page?? The reason for this is these pages have the same title and content and fall very close to "duplicate" content even though it does pull in different jobs... I hope i'm making sense? There is also a lot of pages indexed in a way such as- https://www.examplesite.co.uk/moz-jobs/search/page/9/?candidate_search_type=seo-consulant&candidate_search_language=blank-language These are filter pages... and as far as I'm concerned shouldn't really be indexed? Second question! - Should I "no follow" everything after /page in this instance? To keep things tidy? I don't want all the variations indexed! Any help or general thoughts would be much appreciated! Thanks.0 -
Moz is treating my pages as duplicate content but the pages have different content in reality
Attached here is a screenshot of links with duplicate content. Here are some links that is also based on the screenshot http://federalland.ph/construction_updates/paseo-de-roces-as-of-october-2015 http://federalland.ph/construction_updates/sixsenses-residences-tower-2-as-of-october-2015/ http://federalland.ph/construction_updates/sixsenses-residences-tower-3-as-of-october-2015 The links that I have placed here have different content. So I don't why they are treated as duplicates BWWJuvQ
Moz Pro | | clestcruz0 -
How to know exactly which page links to a 404 page on my website?
Hi Moz users, Sometimes I get 404 crawl errors using Moz Pro and when my website has a few dozen pages it is hard for me to find the original page that links to a 404 page. Is there a way to find this automatically using Moz or do I have to look for it manually? I just need to find the original link and delete it to fix my 404 issue. Please let me know thank you for you help. -Marc
Moz Pro | | marcandre0 -
Help me to know why are all pages not being tracked by the Moz tool for on-page optimization reports?
The On-page Optimization report that the Moz tool shows, is not tracking all the pages from my website. I know this because it isn't showing a ranking for all pages on my website. Is there a particular reason why this is happening? It is important for me to know details of all pages, else it does not give me a comprehensive picture of what's going on in SEO.
Moz Pro | | jslusser0 -
SEOmoz link report VS. open site explorer
Hi, I run a campaign on one of my new clients in the links report - i see 1970 - external links and i can press " see more in open site explorer) when i press the button, open site explorer is opened but with a message that there is no link data on this website any advice? Are you familiar with another tool that can help me investigate links to website? Thank you SEOwise
Moz Pro | | iivgi0 -
Is it possible to submit a page to the seomoz index?
We recently got added to dmoz and botw and would like to see those links considered in our domain authority as we are tracking our progress and comparing ourselves to other sites. Is it possible to submit links to the seomoz index manually to have those tracked? (If I am even understanding this correctly)
Moz Pro | | hyperthalamus0 -
Can I setup SEOmoz PRO's 3 organic traffic metrics within Google Analytics (as custom reports)?
I like the 3 organic traffic metrics in SEOmoz PRO: 1) Organic Search Visits
Moz Pro | | AndreVanKets
2) URLs Receiving Entrances Via Search
3) Non-Paid Keywords Sending Search Visits They rock - especially for a high-level view of SEO / Organic performance. Is it possible to setup these metrics as custom reports directly in Analytics? Does anyone have these reports setup? Or maybe there are similar custom reports that give a similar high-level view?0 -
Only crawling one page
Hi there, A campaign was crawling fine, but at the last crawl, for some reason, SEOmoz can only crawl one page... any ideas? If I run a custom crawl I still access all of the site's pages.
Moz Pro | | harryholmes0070