Should I be taking a gradual approach to link removals?
-
Quick background: My parents run a travel company and have seen their google ranks drop dramatically in the last few years (usual story: they employed an SEO agency, saw good results to begin with, and then a massive decline in their rankings post-Penguin).
Over the last few months I've been working to remove as many of the spam links pointing to their site as I can. However, as I've been doing so, our keyword rankings have been declining even further, not improving. This time last year we were bottom of page 1 for one keyword, then we suddenly dropped to page 5 around Nov with the Penguin update, and now, since I started cleaning up our backlinks, we're no longer in the first 20 pages - we've vanished. Similar situation for other keywords (though not as dramatic)
I've been pretty careful to only delete links that are clearly spam (article directories, forum signatures, spam comments on blogs with a keyword-rich username linking to our domain etc). It may be that some of these links were still helping us, but I'd be surprised - they were pretty obvious cases of spam.
My question: Is it normal to see this sort of decline at the start of a clean-up campaign? Does google see a sudden decline in the number of links, spam or otherwise, as suspicious? I've devoted weeks already to trying to work on the problems affecting my parent's website, and the situation just seems to be getting worse and worse! Do websites ever recover from a severe Penguin hit?
-
Travis, your comments are a massive help. Thanks so much. That Screaming Frog tool is also really helpful.
I had noticed that different backlink checkers were giving me different results, and so I've been working with several (Webmaster tools, webmeup, Moz, and ahrefs) Originally, i was just working with webmaster, and so it was something of a revelation when I first looked at the data provided by the others and found that there were about five times as many spam links pointing to our site as I had first suspected. I think many of the sites pointing to ours have been deindexed, so won't show up in webmaster tools.
I had also noticed that recent reports I'd generated were picking up on far fewer spam links than older ones, despite me not having managed to get rid of that many links. The post from Robert Fisher helps explain why.
With most of the links I'm deleting, I think they're clearly spam. The seo company we used depended mostly on article directories, but also some forum and comment spam - some on legitimate sites, most on forums that were clearly just created for SEO spam. What I'm thinking is that I will focus on deleting the links with the most repetitive anchor text, and leave a few of those with more varied anchor text. From my understanding of penguin, google doesn't so much penalise you for having a large number of links from spammy sites - it penalises you for having a large number of links with identical anchor text, so I'm prioritising those links with keyword rich anchor text ('Tanzania safari', in our case) and leaving in place for the time being some of the smaller number of links with less repetitive anchor text (a small number say 'trips to Tanzania', for instance).
The content audit looks like a mammoth job, but I'll try and work on that this weekend. I know that our site has a lot of duplicate content, for one thing (in some cases for good reasons). Perhaps we've been hit by panda as well as penguin.
Thanks again.
-
It sounds like you've been doing link removal manually. That's all well and good. You should manually inspect inbound links. There are quite a few that jump right out, like easylinkseodirectorygooglerankings4ulol.com.
Though there isn't any easy 'yes' or 'no' to this one, especially without knowing the site. So with my bed-wetting white hat on, I would say; "Cleanse and burn - scorched earth, sir." With my realistic hat on, I would say; "Don't go terribly overboard. Really think about what you're doing. Sure the pure spam should go, but be careful."
The interesting thing is that Google has to pick The Best of The Worst. Travel can be a particularly spam-ridden vertical. But I would look into backlink profiles for competitors in your niche - say African Safaris. Round them all up.
Know that your sources of backlink data are flawed. A lot of spam sites have started blocking popular backlink data provider's bots. That means you have to crawl all of your 'deleted' links while spoofing Googlebot. You can do this with Screaming Frog. It also makes Google Webmaster Tools data more important, even though it's lacking in volume. Robert Fisher and his team at drumBEAT caught this skulduggery.
Get all of the backlink data you can. We're talking Majestic SEO, Ahrefs, Moz OSE, Google Webmaster Tools, Bing Webmaster Tools and The Kitchen Sink. Seriously, get all of the backlink data you can. Throw them all into a spreadsheet, then eliminate duplicates. Just know that it's a big internet and you will never have the complete picture.
While it's kind of an expensive tool, you should more than likely go with Cemper Link Detox once you have your master spreadsheet. It will give you a pretty solid understanding of where the site stands in general. From there, you should manually review each link. There are false positives and false negatives, but the tool is getting better all the time.
If the tool states the site has a Risky or Toxic profile, then you will want to start looking at a prudent disavow list. Removing bad links is great, if you can, but it's not entirely reasonable nor is it expected.
But if it's not saying your backlink profile is Toxic or Risky - you definitely have other problems. Still, you should always try to earn quality backlinks. Here's a great guide from Moz if you're not sure where to start.
You can also use Cemper's tools to get some good ideas from your competitors.
Man, that was a screed.
TL;DR:
Definitely get a better idea of where your backlink profile stands from a top level perspective. There are tools that will get you there. When you know where you really stand, you will know your priority.
The next Penguin update may be a long time away. It may come tomorrow. Take some time while you're getting all of this together. Then do a content audit on your site. And use the link building guide to move forward. (I slipped that ginormous sucker in there at the end... XD.)
-
Thanks, Travis. I will look more into potential on-site problems. I've been devoting a lot of time to removing backlinks but not much else.
So, just to clarify, you wouldn't advise that I slow down in the link removals? Get rid of all the spammy links, even if it means a decline in our rankings for the time being, and then focus on good links?
-
Yes, there are sites that recover from what appears to be a Penguin related penalty. It's generally a good idea to get rid of the spam backlinks. However you must also replace the spam with quality links. Low quality links can still somewhat prop up a site.
There has been a significant delay between Penguin updates. Now would be a good time to focus on acquiring quality backlinks.
You might want to give siteliner.com a try. There are also the Moz Pro tools that can help determine if the site has some on-page problems. There's usually always more than one main problem.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
I am getting automatic spam links to my site, how can I remove them?
Hello, I need assistance, recently I noticed a huge traffic drop from my blog, lost all the rankings in SERP. I got to know that it's Google OCT Spam Update mainly it's about spamming and black hat techniques. But I haven't done any spammy practices or Black HAT SEO. I pay good amount of $ a month to freelancing content writers and don't make any spam backlinks. My site is : tcmguide.com Checked my site in search console and noticed that I had out of no where got 13000+ links from different dirty sites, as I have never tried to building those links in my life. 13 382 links.jpg I tried to export and Disavow this but via Export I got access to 1000 only and can't find these links in MOZ. Moz is showing other links, can any one help me out to recover my traffic and If my site is hit with Spam Update, how can I recover from it. Please help me felling pretty demotivated and stressed
Link Building | | dsdfsdfdfdfvg330 -
Internal Link Building and Link Juice Quality
Hi There! I manage the website for a law office that covers many geographical locations. For very specific niche content, we would prefer to create one piece of content and link to the various geographic locations where we would handle that topic instead of posting multiple variations of the same content for each specific geographical area. If we put a button on these pages that has links to each location, will that have the same "link juice" effect to the pages we're linking that linking directly in the text would? (example: the Where can we help you? button on this page : http://www.zdfirm.com/volkswagen-recall/) Thank you!
Link Building | | ZDAdmin0 -
Link removel
When removing links should I be worried about bad links from websites that have already been deindexd from Google or should I think that since it is not in these index any more it cant do harm?
Link Building | | Joseph-Green-SEO0 -
Deleting links
I've got 280 links on my wordpress blog site, apparently it's recommended to keep under 100 links. How would I know which links to get rid of and which links to keep?
Link Building | | gimes0 -
What do you do if you have been hit by recent Google updates but cannot remove the links?
We have a potential new client who did their own SEO about 6-7 years ago.They ranked really well for years then obviously recently got hit. Some of the links they have are shocking, directories, articles sites etc. They did not use links farms but the links do not look great at all. The problem is they do not have log ins to remove these links manually themselves. Asking for a reconsideration with Google will not get us anywhere due to more recent link building issues we are trying to resolve. They have sent removal requests at least 10 times to these sites but no response. Has anyone overcome these types of issues previously and can give any tips? This would be a good client for us so keen to see what I can do to get them on-board.
Link Building | | tempowebdesign0 -
Why my twitter handle link is not getting counted in links, though for other sites it is counting!
My twitter handle page link is not getting counted, though it is getting counted for other sites
Link Building | | EG0CENTRIX0 -
Does the ratio of external nofollow links to external "do follow" links matter in terms of SERPs ranking?
My site has an external link nofollow:dofollow ratio of approximately 1:1 That is, there are about as many nofollow external links as "do follow" external links. I have an impression that the ratio of no-follow to "do follow" links is a factor in the way that our website shows up in SERPs. I have the impression from reading a variety of sources, and from looking at Seomoz, that calculate "trust" factors as if they mattered (in SERPs), that seem to value a relatively low nofollow:dofollow ratio. Am I correct about that? Thanks,
Link Building | | tcolling
Tim PS - I don't know whether or not this matters, but our website is at: www.trustworthycare.com - Tim0 -
Link footprints
Hi! I have question about link footprints. What should be taken into consideration? Is it real issue when your backlinks have heavy footprint? Thanks for answer..
Link Building | | asystematic1