Different WP Taxonomies seen as duplicate content
-
Hey guys,
We're seeing Moz report "duplicate" content on pages like: mysite.com/interesting-category/ and mysite.com/interesting-tag.
Why exactly is this, and is there something that we should do about this? Obviously some of the same posts will intersect on pages like category, tag, author pages.
Thanks
-
Thank you so much for the detailed debrief Nigel. Very helpful!
-
Hi Andy
There is no problem using tags and categroies on a Wordpress site as long as they are handled correctly with whichever SEO plugin you are using.
Categories - Should be seen as a natural hierarchy for the site so I would fill in the Meta titles and description and add some fleshy text to those page so that the you are describing the content for the user. It's also great for SEO and sets those pages aside from others on the site as the content is unique - 300 words plus, (preferably a single line of text at the top and a beefier section below)
Tags - these are a pain in the butt and I would simply noindex/follow them so that they do not show up in SERPS. I see these as simply an extra form of grouping for the user. They generally create skinny content pages of little value and should be completely downgraded.
There is often confusion between functionality and SEO as they rarely go hand in hand. You need to present the best view for your reader, user, customer - that is the priority. At the same time you have tools like noindex and canonicals to get you round the problems of skinny content and duplication.
If you stick to the one page/one keyword (or tight, contextually similar group of keywords) then you will be fine.
When it comes to author archives I noindex them and when it comes to article snippets then the shortest one available or none at all - as every line of text that is repeated on different pages is duplication.
Regards Nigel
-
Once again, Authors on the site will have their own archive pages as well. A chronological list of all posts by that author. So if you tag or categorize without purpose and the tags and categories have no separation you will have duplicate content across all three types of archive pages.
Here is a good post explaining tags and categories. http://www.wpbeginner.com/beginners-guide/categories-vs-tags-seo-best-practices-which-one-is-better/
Don,
-
Thanks for the reply Don. Solid points, all of them, however not really ideal case-scenario, not solution.
Tags are more helpful than Categories on a per-page basis (especially on our end) so we'd rather use those. This presents a diff problem, because using 4 tags on a post would duplicate it across the tax page for all 4 tags OFC. I'm really curious what others think of this as well, simply giving upgood user functionality doesn't seem to be a smart strategy in my eyes. I would probably go ahead and noindex nofollow all other taxonomies except on.
By the way - this situation happened with a category vs author page. So not even cat vs tag. Even more annoying!
-
Hi Andy,
I recommend using tags or categories not both on your WordPress website. You see, they are essentially the same thing. A Tag or Category will create an archive page once it the taxonomy is created. All posts or content that is either categorized or tagged with will display on the tag or categories archive page.
So if you have a post called Why I use Moz, and that post is categorized as SEO and Tagged as Best SEO Practices. You just created 2 new archive pages with the same post. Creating duplicate content. Now because these archive pages are in chronological order, new posts that are tagged and categorized using the taxonomies given above, the archive pages will always be duplicated because the content never differs.
To combat this use one or the other. I prefer categories. You will not get an extra SEO benefit for tagging your posts or categorizing them. This is for user experience and will have little effect on your ranking. However if you use tags and categories wrong you can get lower rankings for duplicated content.
Thanks,
Don
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How important is exact keyword match in content for SEO in 2018?
Is it necessary to have the exact keyword which you are trying to rank for within the first sentence of the content on your web page? For example if we are selling men's shoes, is it ok to have have the meta title and h1 on page say men's shoes and just talk about shoes within the first sentence of the content on the page. Is it obvious to search engines that this page is selling men's shoes even if you don't have the word men's shoes in that first sentence or is it necessary to have the exact keywords which you are trying to rank for written there?
Content Development | | whiteonlySEO0 -
Content - Similar but not exactly the same content - Duplicate or Spammy?
Hey, so I have been wondering for some time now as some pages will get indexed and others won't appear at all. That makes me think that I am either creating to similar content or it is becoming too spammy. Take these two pages I created for example. The body content is very similar but h tags, meta tags and title are different. So my questions is; would pages not be displaying due possibly being too similar and spammy or duplicate? I have linked two pages that are very similar below and would love to hear any thoughts about it. https://www.dlmremovals.com.au/queensland/interstate/removalists/gold-coast-to-ballarat-removalist-backloads-and-moving-service.html https://www.dlmremovals.com.au/queensland/interstate/removalists/gold-coast-to-bendigo-removalist-backloads-and-moving-service.html Any feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.
Content Development | | Niclasfa0 -
Same content but translated. Penalization?
Hi There, I’ve got a question. There are two website that are under the same proprietor but must stay not related (different brand, different IP, different country, different language). The question is: Does google penalize one of the site if I entirely translate the content from site 1 to site2? Thank you very much for you input 😉
Content Development | | Midleton0 -
Where to outsource product pages contents?
We have been told to write good unique content for every products but we just don't have the skill nor the time. (english is not my first-language) Can anyone suggest where to find a good product content writer?
Content Development | | ringochan0 -
Content Curation & Duplicate Content
Hi, I have a client that wants to do content curation but it has been my understanding that adding external content that is already live on another website to your website, you get penalized for duplicate content. I have read that you can create an excerpt and then Google won't penalizes you for duplicate content. Can anyone shed more light on this topic. Thanks
Content Development | | M_80 -
How to make new content Indexed faster by google
I would like to know what can I do. Normally it takes google around 3 days to index my content. I got a site map, swiched the crawling rate to the fastest in my webmaster tools. I also tried crawling my homepage as google bot and sending it to the index with all linked pages but even if I do so my content takes around 3 days if not more to get indexed. I publish around 20 posts a week. My SEOmoz page authority is 48. Some sites of my competition seem to be getting their content indexed in the same day. What else can be done?
Content Development | | sebastiankoch0 -
Prevent average users from copying content and pasting into their websites
Please do not respond with a "you can't stop them" comment, I understand this. Most of our pages have content that is duplicated across multiple domains. The recent Google algorithm update focused on penalizing pages that have duplicate content, and it could be one of the reasons that we have been seeing traffic loss. I'm looking for some type of javascsript/php code that will help minimize this issue.If could be code that does not allow you to copy and paste the code without turning of javascript or a dialog box pops up and says "this content is copyright protected, anyone copying this content is subject to legal action" I've found one script that might work http://www.ioncube.com/html_encoder.php My questions are still the same: 1 What is the best method to achieve my objective? 2 Will this additional code affect how the webbots see our site and or affect rankings? I know that anyone can figure out how to get the code, I am trying to mitigate by providing a warning about copyright infringement and making it more challenging to copy our content. Please do not respond with a "you can't stop them" comment, etc, I understand this. Thank you for your comments!
Content Development | | 4RealLocal0 -
Fresh content ideas for a static site?
I have an ecommerce site. My home page is set-up just as I want it. I'm not looking to redo it or change my site to a blog. Just looking for some new, different, SEO friendly ideas or concepts to keep it "fresh".
Content Development | | VictorVC0