Backlink Dilemma & Typewriters (Seriously...Typewriters)
-
Hi all. I have a bit of a unique issue.
My company, Smith Corona **used **to be one of the world's premier typewriter manufacturers.
However, we have completely got out of that business roughly a decade ago. Instead, we sell blank thermal shipping labels.
As you might imagine, writing content and getting links about paper labels is not easy. Quite simply, no one cares about labels. They either stick or they don't.
Typewriters is a whole different story. We still get tons of calls and emails everyday about them. There are online communities dedicated to them.
I think if I even tried a little, I could get backlinks from people interested in typewriters. The problem is... that we don't do ANYTHING with them at all anymore. I would really just be pimping out our brand name in hopes of getting some cheap links.
The real question is... do I even want these links? If they are semantically about typewriters and not labels, is it really helping my SEO efforts?
Any advice is welcome. Thanks all!
-
I agree with Paddy here. I'm not suggesting you use typewriter links to link to thermal label content - let me make that clear. You should still go after links specifically to the main thermal labelling business pages.
-
Hi there,
As you may have noticed, you have two answered from Nigel and Chris which conflict a little. So I'll do my best to help!
I think the answer lies somewhere in the middle in that in an ideal world, links that aren't quite 100% on topic would still help you, but the reality is that there is probably at least some thought given by Google as to the relevance of the link. In my experience, it comes down to the overall link profile and the quality/relevance of it rather than individual links. Websites are linked to 24/7 from random websites on all sorts of topics, so I don't think it would necessarily hurt you.
For me, it comes down to three things that you should keep in mind:
- As Nigel said, the topics aren't a million miles away from each other, so it's very unlikely that building links related to this topic are going to hurt you
- Your main focus should be on the quality of the links, if you're worried about the quality and the relevance, then it may be worth staying away from them
- I'd recommend a dual approach whereby you use the great history of the company in this topic to get links, but also start looking at ways you can build links for the new era of the company too.
I hope that helps!
Paddy
-
Hi SmithCarona
I'm quite sure there was a smith corona that bounced between family members in my household when I was young and in my mind, the brand name, and typewriters seem inseparable. The problem, as you're recognizing, is that to Google, they're almost inseparable too.
Those "typewriter" links are not going to help you rank for "label" searches. The authority all those links give you is to die for but the fact that they are off topic means that authority isn't doing much to help you rank for your label-oriented terms.
I'd say you have a long project in front of you of seriously cataloging those existing backlinks and wrapping your arms around creative ways the company and website could make use of some of them and even seriously considering disavowing many of them. Maybe seek out a consultant who developed a lot of experience back in the Penguin algo change days because a lot of what you will need to do will require that skillset and toolset.
-
Hi Smithcorona
I absolutely would. I would have a proper set of pages charting the company's history from the very beginning, showing mages of the early typewriters you used to make bringing the story up to the present day. If that leads to people linking to you and sharing your images with backlinks then I can't see it doing any harm whatsoever.
The extra backlinks will help enhance your overall domain authority so frankly, you have little to lose. There is a relationship between typewriters, ie the transferring of the written word on to paper and thermal labels so at least you are still in the same 'industry'.
I would have no hesitation in promoting this and saying just go ahead. Nothing to lose and lots to gain.
I'd even blog about it - 'Did you know we used to make typewriters...'
I hope that helps - Regards Nigel
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Can Foreign Language Backlinks Be Valuable?
I've done a lot of searching on this subject, but I keep seeing conflicting answers. Are backlinks from foreign language websites valuable? For example, a travel website in English picks up a couple backlinks in Indonesian language (and other languages) from foreign sites that have a DA of 60-70 or higher. The topic is partially related, but the language is totally different. Would those links still be valuable for the English website's DA? Has this ever been answered conclusively? Thanks
Link Building | | David56751 -
Negative SEO & How long does it take for Google to disavow
Following on from a previous problem of this sweetandsavorymeals completely dropping from index, we have discovered that 150+ spam, porn domains have been directed at our pages (sometime in the last 3-4 months, don't have an exact date). Does anyone have exerpeince on how long it may take Google to take noticed of a new disavow list? Any estimates would be very helpful in determining our next course of action.
Link Building | | sathoiue80 -
Inherited site with high Spam Score backlinks
When building backlinks myself I have been conscious to avoid going over the 30 spam score as recommended on Moz somewhere. But one of the sites I have recently started working on: https://www.osborneplanning.uk/
Link Building | | Donsimong
has a number of very high spam score backlinks, 5 above 50. Some are follow some nofollow.
I am wondering if its a good idea to disavow them, or should I just leave them as they are, I have read some suggestions that Google will just ignore the majority of spammy backlinks, and its better just to keep them, I dont want to start deleting links if they don't cause any problems.0 -
Are Sidebar Backlinks worth for SEO?
Hello! Let's use the following example: I have a blog (let's call it Blog A) and I find another blog in the same niche (this will be Blog B) that has higher DA and PA than mine. Will Google penalize me if the Blog B puts a link to my blog in their sidebar? Remember, the Blog A and Blog B are from the same niche. I ask this because Google says that links on sidebars appears in every page and in some pages the link may be useless. But if both blogs are from the same niche, there won't be pages where the links will be from different themes and with less relevance. So, is my thought correct: we can use sidebar links without caring about penalization ONLY if the blogs are from the same niche? Thanks in advance!
Link Building | | btqkelvin0 -
Backlinks not showing in OSE
Hi I have been undertaking back linking for our website and have submitted our site to a range of online directories and quite a few of them are currently live. However when I download the Open site explorer report I'm not seeing these links included in the back link list. Can anyone tell me when they are likely to appear please?
Link Building | | Hardley0 -
Backlink Lists
I am trying to create a valid list of backlink domain to disavow after a 50% traffic cut by Penguin......problem is I have now pulled lists from 4 tool and the lists are all different. I find a toxic domain from the tool run on LinkResearchTools and look on Google and Site Explorer and the toxic link does not even show. I look at the page and sure enough the link from year ago on a link farm is there. Is there really a rue definitive tool that will give me a list of all links? Better yet is there a tool that will help me evaluate which domain to disavow ? I want to follow Dr. Pete's advice and go slow but I am also anxious to cut ties with SEO work done by someone else in the hay day of link farm SEO and frankly looking at resent links some Bad SEO by competitors.
Link Building | | freestone0 -
Backlinks to site.com (without www)
I have a website with 301 redirection from site.com to www.site.com. And we have built many backlinks to site.com (without www). Are these backlinks still give us juicy?
Link Building | | bele0 -
Building backlinks for a newspaper site?
Anyone have tips on building links to a newspaper site? I am looking for a strategy to create links to a news site beyond building one link at a time. We have so much content that is constantly updated that it would be impossible to do this one page at a time.
Link Building | | BostonWright0