Ecommerce Canonical Question
-
Hi all, first question (eek)
Could I pick the brains of fellow users around an issue we are having with canonical urls on a magento website. At the moment we do not have these enabled as it seems to break our indexing. Cut a long story short, we have thousands of products but haven't rewritten many of the descriptions from the manufacturers yet and so have noindexed all the product pages (freeing them as we go). The goal, for now, is to pull in traffic via the filtering options we have on the site
The goal, for now, is to pull in traffic via the filtering options we have on the site. For example, if you go to Dresses, there then are several filtering options which would allow you to choose a colour, shape and material - if you wished to filter that precisely. These filtering options are all crawlable and so we would then have a page that google could index for, for example, Green Lace Maxi Dress. All good there, few people search for specific products and a lot search for types of products so we are covered.
To get back to the issue at hand. If we enable the canonical option on our magento plugin it will stop us from being able to target these terms. Whereas the filtering option would create domain.com/dress/green/maxi/lace with the page title of Green Lace Maxi Dress, if we enable the canonical part of the seo plugin the canonical link which would be added to the page would be - instantly removing our ability to rank for longer tail dress related searches (we are not going to compete with the big players on the premium terms, yet!).
There are alternative plugins we can buy for magento to add the correct tag, however, if every page's canonical just points back it itself like this, is there really much point spending nearly $1000 on the 4 licences we would need to cover our range of sites. Is it really necessary, in this case, that we have a canonical for the product filtering?
Sorry for the long post, hope it made sense.
Thanks for any assistance.
-
Bernadette, many thanks for the reply.
This is a very tricky issue, and I'm still very confused. If I go to dresses and then 'red' i get a set of products, if i go dresses and then 'blue' i get a different set of products so I cannot see any potential for duplication there. All of these products may appear on other pages in small numbers - for example one of the red dresses would appear in the lace dress filter as it is a red lace dress, however, the other 15 dresses on that page would not match the red dress page.
There are about 250,000 products in the store, so while products will appear under several attributes, the chance of the same 16 products appearing on the same page for multiple attributes is tiny. I guess this is why I'm thinking there wouldn't be a need for a canonical tag as no page is really duplicating any more than a tiny % of another. There is only one way to access the list of products on any one page.
If i borrow Amazon as an example - would rather not share my url at the moment as it isn't 100% finished. On amazon we have a page for Black Prom Dresses at https://www.amazon.co.uk/s/ref=sr_nr_p_n_size_two_browse-_0?fst=as%3Aoff&rh=n%3A83450031%2Cn%3A!425571031%2Cn%3A!425573031%2Cn%3A9780907031%2Cp_6%3AA3P5ROKL5A1OLE%2Cp_n_size_two_browse-vebin%3A1946173031&bbn=9780907031&ie=UTF8&qid=1476896938&rnid=1836991031&lo=clothing (whoa that's a big url!) with the canonical tag of https://www.amazon.co.uk/Prom-Dresses-Edit-Black-Clothing/s?ie=UTF8&bbn=9780907031&page=1&rh=n%3A83450031%2Cn%3A!425571031%2Cn%3A!425573031%2Cn%3A9780907031%2Cp_6%3AA3P5ROKL5A1OLE%2Cp_n_size_two_browse-vebin%3A1946173031" />
If we go to red dresses we have a url https://www.amazon.co.uk/s/ref=sr_nr_p_n_size_two_browse-_0?fst=as%3Aoff&rh=n%3A83450031%2Cn%3A!425571031%2Cn%3A!425573031%2Cn%3A9780907031%2Cp_6%3AA3P5ROKL5A1OLE%2Cp_n_size_two_browse-vebin%3A1946185031&bbn=9780907031&ie=UTF8&qid=1476897017&lo=clothing
Both of these two sets of dresses were reached by going Dresses and then clicking on the colour filter. Both have unique urls. This is pretty much the same situation as my site - the products on each of those pages is different so is not a duplicate of any other page on the site, so would they really need that canonical tag?
I'm not sure if I have managed to confuse myself. My understanding of the canonical tag is that it is to be used if you have the same, or very similar content on more than one page. You point all versions to just one page to avoid duplicate content penalties and to make one page have all the links which might point to alternative versions. Therefore, if the page isn't a duplicate of another, is the tag really necessary
Thanks, Carl
-
DSCarl, taking care of the duplicate content that the site appears to be generating is a big deal. So it definitely needs to be fixed--and that's good that you've identified it.
Ideally, you really do need to be able to canonical the sizes of the dress, for example, to the product page, which is "Green Lace Maxi Dress", assuming that you will have a unique page (along with a unique product description) written for the Green Lace Maxi Dress, which would be different than, say, a Red Lace Maxi Dress.
There are generally two ways to deal with duplicate content like this. One way is to deal with it using canonical tags. But before we had the canonical tag, we certainly did have duplicate content--and we dealt with it using the robots.txt file. You can deal with this issue with a canonical tag or robots.txt.
With the robots.txt file, you would need to identify which pages (for example by looking at your URL parameters) and stop the search engines from indexing URLs with certain parameters in them. This is pretty easy to do if you understand your site structure, your parameters in your URLs (or how you have those set up in folders in the URLs), and can add those to the robots.txt file. Using the robots.txt file sounds like it would be a cheaper option for you (rather than spending $1,000 on plugins or add-ons to your CMS).
Alternatively, the canonical tag is the way to go if you can get it to work properly. Oftentimes if it's not working properly you can contact the developer of the plugin or add-on and see if they'll help you install it or get the settings right so that it works properly on your site.
Either way, it's definitely an issue that you need to deal with, as it will have a dramatic effect on your site's rankings. The canonical tag option is probably preferred if you can get it to work properly, as all of the "link juice" and other "credit" will be passed onto the page you're canonicaling "to".
-
hmm not sure how 'The goal, for now, is to pull in traffic via the filtering options we have on the site' ended up twice. Oops
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Page Hierarchy Question
I understand the basic concept of page hierarchy, i.e. parent and child pages. My question is: Should the home page be the parent of all 2nd-level pages? Can/should there only be one top-level page, the home page? In other words, is this: site.com/homesite.com/home/products site.com/home/products/widgetsite.com/home/aboutsite.com/home/contactbetter than this:site.com/homesite.com/products site.com/products/widgetsite.com/aboutsite.com/contactThanks for your opinion!
On-Page Optimization | | BillWoods0 -
Ecommerce URLs with numbers
Hi everybody! I have to optimize an ecommerce where somebody has previously done the SEO optimization, although the URLs have numbers before the product's name They have told me that these numbers are useful to find the products, so I think it shouldn't be really bad if I don't redirect them to "clear" ones. For example: /colesterol-sobrepeso/2217-hc-grass-capsulas-duras-15-capsulas.html > /colesterol-sobrepeso/hc-grass-capsulas-duras-15-capsulas.html Am I right? After all, they contain the keywords and the subfolders are also ok. Or it would be better if I redirect the whole site? Thanks!
On-Page Optimization | | Estherpuntu0 -
Moz showing 384 description duplicates on my ecommerce store.... when I download CSV, most pages are coming from my WordPress Blog, why?
Hi, I am trying to investigate why I am getting 384 description duplicates on my ecommerce store (www.doggie-diva.com)? When I download the CSV file from MOZ, the majority of the pages they refer to are pages from my Word Press blog, which is hosted on a different server (blog.doggie-diva.com). I do have a link from my website to my Word Press blog and vice versa. Can you please explain to me why this is happening when I don't have duplicate content? Example of a page flagged from www.doggie-diva.com with duplicate content (http://blog.doggie-diva.com/tag/dog-gymnastics. Thanks, Rachel <colgroup><col width="549"></colgroup>
On-Page Optimization | | doggiedivalicious
| |0 -
Canonical Question For Different Languages
My client has a site that supports different languages in the following structure: www.domain.com - English version www.domain.com/IT - Italian version www.domain/DE - German version etc.... I have set the languages up within Webmaster Tools but do I need to set up the canonical tag for all internal pages as they are basically the same but just in a different language i.e. www.domain.com/index.php is the same as www.domain.com/DE/index.php but in a different language. Thanks
On-Page Optimization | | bigfootdigital0 -
Using Transcription Service For Videos - Have Question Around Search and Spiders
Hi All, So I have put together a weekly video series on security topics. I have read an SEOmoz post around how you can boost SEO by adding the transcription to the page, which makes perfectly good sense. My question is, can I include the first couple of paragraphs and then have a "read the full transcription" so when the user clicks, the rest of the content appears? Do the search engine spiders only crawl the first two paragraphs in this instance or do they crawl the whole thing even though the entire content is not on the page? I dont mind making the page longer and including the entire transcription if it is easier for SEO but if there is no difference, than I think the first option would be the best user experience. Thanks for the help Pat
On-Page Optimization | | PatBausemer0 -
Is reported duplication on the pages or their canonical pages?
There are several sections getting flagged for duplication on one of our sites: http://mysite.com/section-1/?something=X&confirmed=true
On-Page Optimization | | Safelincs
http://mysite.com/section-2/?something=X&confirmed=true
http://mysite.com/section-3/?something=X&confirmed=true Each of the above are showing as having duplicates of the other sections. Indeed, these pages are exactly the same (it's just an SMS confirmation page you enter your code in), however, they all have canonical links back to the section (without the query string), i.e. section-1, section-2 and section-3 respectively. These three sections have unique content and aren't flagged up for duplications themselves, so my questions are: Are the pages with the query strings the duplicates, and if so why are the canonical links being ignored? or Are the canonical pages without the query strings the duplicates, and if so why don't they appear as URLs in their own right in the duplicate content report? I am guessing it's the former, but I can't figure out why it would ignore the canonical links. Any ideas? Thanks0 -
What does Canonical mean?
Hi, I was wondering what is meant by canonical? I ran a test on my site and in the notices, SEOMOZ came back with a total of 90 canonicals. As far as I can tell, it refers to the preferred page (not really sure what that means though). I thought initially it was talking about duplicate content, but all the pages are totally different. There is no duplicate content on any of he pages that it lists. So I'm not sure how to fix this. Thanks for the help. Don
On-Page Optimization | | ge01734000 -
Canonical Help?
This canonical thing is brand new to me and I'm trying to wrap my mind around it. Here is my situation: I use Wordpress. I am showing duplicate content with the following url's http://crosstrainingandfitness.com/online-workout-blog/ http://crosstrainingandfitness.com/online-workout-blog/page/2/ Would setting a canonical link solve this? If so, what do I put in the Canonical box for this category (online workout blog). I use Yoast's Wordpress SEO plugin. Any help is greatly appreciated.
On-Page Optimization | | carbbon0