Change 10yrs old home title tag seo safe?
-
Howdy everyone! Wish you the best for 2012!
We have a client who is ranked #1 for keyword "blue widgets". Their site's homepage title has the keyword "blue widgets" in it and has been the same for 10yrs+.
Recently they have added other types of widgets to their offering.
Is it safe to change their title by adding more keywords to it? For example: "blue widgets | green widgets | brand x widgets".
May our client lose their ranking if we change their title?
Thanks in advance for your help!
-
Ryan,
Thanks for all the great info. Let me ask you this. Regarding the title, do you think it is better for local terms to be used? IE, using the example above, if have a site that manages rental properties in Orlando, do I want to still use "rental properties" as my main keyword and build content that uses Orlando, Orange County, etc. around that or would including the city or surrounding cities in the title be advantageous for a local business?
-
I would be more than willing for anyone to give me a complete site exam!
The community is exceptionally helpful. May I suggest sharing your site URL in a new Q&A so as to keep this one on topic?
Keep in mind there are over 200 metrics involved with determining search engine ranking. I always recommend taking a holistic view of the majority of factors and not focusing too much on any one metric.
To use a medical analogy, there are some people who smoke and live to be 100. Life's unfair that way. But you know when your doctor advises you not to smoke, the advice is correct. You can point at the 100 year old smoker all you want, but it would not be wise to copy that behavior in an effort to live a longer life.
-
Ryan you are correct,
The main search is not localized for what the original post is. But even if you take out the local search it still is #1 or #2 for every search. Drives me crazy but you are accurate in your response. You ever have those days you think to yourself how can I get there? I am having on of those days LOL!
I would be more than willing for anyone to give me a complete site exam!
-
Thanks for sharing some examples Robbie.
The first observation I would share is these examples all involve local SEO. The example the original poster shared did not involve local seo ( "blue widgets"). That changes things a lot. Local SEO eliminates most of the competition.
"rental properties" shows 2,240,000 monthly searches
"orlando rental properties" shows 18,100 monthly searches
Adding the local parameter eliminates over 99% of the competition. It's not the same at all. In addition, the 7 pack results dominate local search making the organic results much less meaningful. Even though Rentals.com site is the first organic listing, it shows after the 7 pack. There is strong evidence that users prefer the 7 pack results even when those results are lower then the top organic results. Without the 7 pack, the CTR of result #1 averages 44%. In this case I would bet the CTR is in the ballpark of 5%.
I would further add the first title keyword (which is offered the most weight) in each case is relevant to the search result. Also, several of the variants are relevant to the search result. Again, these examples are completely different then the original poster's query. "Blue Widgets, Green Widgets, Brand X Widgets" was the example. The examples for the keywords you presented are similar to "Blue Widgets, Widgets Blue, random word, Big Blue Widgets".
I appreciate what you are sharing but I still feel the original response I shared is accurate and it would be a large mistake to make the changes the original poster suggested.
-
Hi Ryan,
I am a kindergarten SEO myself.
Ok, Search these terms in Google and you will see for almost any city you replace my city with in the search term and rentals.com ranks #1 almost every single time.
orlando rental properties
houses for rent in tampa
houses for rent in jacksonville
houses for rent in denver
atlanta rental homes
california homes for rentAs you will find out this site ranks #1 for almost any high ranking search term you can think of.
Even though for many of these terms the search phrase is not even on the page that ranks #1 ??
Switch around the terms all you want to not match the title tag and you will see this theory is not always true with big domains like this.I do realize the power of the domain but sometimes you just gotta say "Come on Man!" Really?
-
Hi Robbie,
I consider myself first and foremost a student of SEO. I am human, I make mistakes, and I enjoy learning. If you have a good example please share it. Try to choose an example which would be relevant to most webmasters. A NY Times article which has a DA of 100 and an incredibly high PA would not be ideal as 99% of websites do not have that kind of leverage.
Let's all learn together on this one.
-
I can show you a company who ranks #1 for multiple terms in SERP'S for Multiple keywords with the same title targeting only one or two phrases. All day long. Even though I do respect your opinion highly but I will take that challenge.
Good thread for sure going on!
-
The wonderful thing about SEO is there are multiple approaches which all can lead to success. With respect to focusing multiple words on a page, I would challenge anyone to be able to provide a web page focusing multiple keywords in a competition versus the same page altered to only focus a single keyword.
If the goal is to rank #1 for a competitive keyword, a page focusing a single keyword should win the competition. Otherwise, even if you earn the #1 spot you are quite vulnerable to others taking your ranking.
If I provide a "blue widgets" page with the url as /blue-widgets, title as "blue widgets", header tag as "blue widgets" and the content as "Blue widgets are an incredibly helpful tool.....", how do you expect to compete if you target 3 keywords? You can't.
-
I disagree with a focus on just 1 word for each page. It is very limiting in link building 3 to 4 variants will allow for a stronger page in my opinion.
-
Alan and EGOL have shared some solid information but I have the sense you would like another viewpoint so I will share some thoughts.
Search Engine Optimization requires focus. You are competing with others for the #1 spot. The title tag is not only a ranking factor, it is offered a lot of weight. If your present title tag is "Blue Widgets" then 100% of that weight applies to that keyword. If you add two additional keywords to the title then you are de-optimizing (I think I made up a new word!) the page. You are taking a page which focuses a single keyword and dividing that focus amongst 3 keywords.
If you were to make that change, your page will then be less relevant to "blue widgets" and more relevant to "green widgets" and "brand x widgets". Your client may not only lose ranking, but if it is a competitive keyword, it's likely that you will lose ranking.
My recommendation is to focus a single keyword for each page of your website. It is fine to offer one or two minor variations such as "blue widgets", but you can't expect to rank # 1for a competitive term and target multiple different keywords.
A # 1 ranking is hugely important as statistically you receive 44% of the traffic for a given term. You should not be afraid to make any changes which improve the page's SEO. On the other hand, I would never make the change you are suggesting unless the client was 100% prepared to give up their # 1 ranking on their main term.
-
One of our client recently went through a complete site change and upgrade everything has changed and at first as the SEO I was apprehensive of the change. I was worried and in a similar boat to the opening of this thread but all ended well and as Alan mentioned you can always change it back if you find a major negative effect as a result of the change.
I think sometimes in seo you have to show you have a pair and go for it. You never know you might be pleasantly surprised which will give you confidence for further changes in the future.
-
That's right, I think that as long as you use 1-3 core, related keywords, it can't be considered stuffing...
-
"If you are not confident about working on this site then I see a few possible routes... there are probably more
1) give the client a refund and confess that you are uncomfortable with this job"
It's not that we're uncomfortable, it's that we want to know what the community think.
"2) explain title tags to the client and how reaching for additional keywords could result in a rankings loss for the primary term but a possible rankings gain for the secondary term, then let the decision up to him
3) attack the new keywords with new pages
4) optimize the homepage with off-page methods"
Great advice. Thanks.
"None of your replies mentions the strength of your competitors. Are they soundly beaten or are the threatening in their strength?"
Good question. They are really strong.
-
3 and 4 all the way. There's a bunch of ways to peel a potato!
-
running shoes and skate shoes | Shoe Shop is pretty much what you have mentioned above, and thats completely fine
if changeing your title tag breaks your business model, you have other problems
-
What do you think?
If you are not confident about working on this site then I see a few possible routes... there are probably more
-
give the client a refund and confess that you are uncomfortable with this job
-
explain title tags to the client and how reaching for additional keywords could result in a rankings loss for the primary term but a possible rankings gain for the secondary term, then let the decision up to him
-
attack the new keywords with new pages
-
optimize the homepage with off-page methods
None of your replies mentions the strength of your competitors. Are they soundly beaten or are the threatening in their strength?
-
-
I would call this keyword stuffing
"blue widgets | green widgets | brand x widgets".
As for changing it, as i stated you can change it back, there will be no harm, except it may take a few weeks to get re crawled.
I would go with "Keyword relative to page content - Branding name"
The title should reflect page content to get maximum value, too many keywords you lose a value and may be seen as stuffing.
Google now replaces your title with the url if you stuff it. Many have come to this forum asking why they google has replaced their title in the serps, and each time it is too many keywords.
-
Thanks for your quick reply.
"Yes they may well do, you dont want to look like you are keyword stuffing. Also I believe that a titile has a set amount of power, and have having many keywords dilutes the power of the title tag. Dont expect each keyword to get the same benifit as you would with one keyword."
We don't plan to keyword stuff, the idea is to use 3 related core keywords in the title. At the moment there's several keywords in the title, and the site is ranking #1 for one of them.
"As for the fact that it has been the same for 210 years does not matter, you can change and if it does not work out for you you can simply change it back."
Our client is getting over 20k visitors a day for that keyword, hence the worries about changing the title. We cannot risk to experiment, even losing a few positions would equal great loss in sales.
What do you think?
-
Yes they may well do, you dont want to look like you are keyword stuffing. Also I believe that a titile has a set amount of power, and have having many keywords dilutes the power of the title tag. Dont expect each keyword to get the same benifit as you would with one keyword.
As for the fact that it has been the same for 210 years does not matter, you can change and if it does not work out for you you can simply change it back.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Difference in using dividers in TITLE TAG
Hi everyone, i know that dividers in title or even title tag doesnt have much of an impact on better rankings. I had great rankings for many keywords, not using dividers or using only one divider. However for better reading comprehension and usability, and also aesthetics i started to use the pipe as my main divider and other secondary dividers. I saw many pages drop in rankings vs other less competent and with less content pages. My format was as follows: Product Brand | Product description - Additional info or local info ie. Fiber Glass MBI | Insulation Batts for Home and Commercial use - Acoustic and Thermal Insulation I changed the format for a handful of pages, and saw immediate results on rankings and traffic on those pages. Product Brand with Product Description - Additional Info ie. Fiber Glass MBI Insulation Batts for Commercial use - Acoustic and Thermal Insulation. Does it sound like something i should implement page wide. I personally like the aesthetics of the pipe as it gives a cleaner look, but the better rankings on the changed pages with using only one divider makes me think. Does it sound familiar, or its just a coincidence, Regards,
On-Page Optimization | | JesusD0 -
Homepage SEO
Hi I have designed my site with about 10 pages which focus on my main keywords. My question is what should I do about the homepage? Do I focus on a keyword on just my brand name? The homepage is a showcase of all my services and a bit about us. Thanks
On-Page Optimization | | TIG990 -
Meta Title in Google does not match the HTML meta title I have coded in a site
I have a client site that is pulling a meta title that is not in his code. I am using Yoast for the titles and descriptions on this site. Not 100% sure why Google is not listing the title we have in place. Could the code be pulling from somewhere else? Is there a fix for this?
On-Page Optimization | | Bryan_Loconto0 -
Shortening Titles
Have a ecommerce site using woocommerce. Most product titles contain the information needed for the product. I have shorten the title as much as possible but; Most of the titles are about 18-19 characters over 70 characters the recommended max. I have removed all possible characters from the title but I could remove the site name - this would get it down by about 18 characters - meaning most titles would then be just under the 70 characters recommended. Would removing the site name from the title of all the products be a bigger problem than good?
On-Page Optimization | | royRR0 -
Duplicate Home Page
Hi, I have a question around best practise on duplicate home pages. The /index.aspx page is showing up as a top referrer in my analytics. I have the rel=canonical tag implemented for the www.mysite.com on both pages. Do I need to 301 the /index.aspx to the mysite.com? I have a lot of links pointing to the /index.aspx (half of those are coming from the mysite.com). www.mysite.com/index.aspx www.mysite.com Many thanks Jon
On-Page Optimization | | JonRaubenheimer0 -
H1 tag in the footer?
Quick question: I have been scouring SEOMoz.org along with webmaster forums looking for an answer, but we have a person who insists that the H1 tag be located in the Footer. I feel that is is fundamentally wrong because it is not the intent of the H1 tag, and I do not believe it is a best practice. That being said would we see what little value the H1 tag has disappear if we put it in the footer, would we be penalized, or am I being too vanilla by wanting to keep it in the Title position?
On-Page Optimization | | travelclickseo0 -
2 Titles
The analysis said that I have two titles on our main page. www.msperformanceonline.com the 1st is "Camaro Accessories, Camaro Parts, MS Performance" and the second is ( and""). I have looked and can't find out where it is!?! I been looking for hours through the code. Is there anything else I can use to find it? I Anyone's help will be appreciated.
On-Page Optimization | | msperformance0 -
SEO Titles and Keyword Density
Hey guys, I'm doing some on page SEO for a few clients and I've always wondered about this question. I have read tons of articles on the perfect <title>tag, but they don't often mention this.</p> <p>So my titles, like most others follow this format:</p> <p>Keyword 1 | Keyword 2 - Company</p> <p>So say for example I am trying to rank for 'life insurance' and 'life insurance quote' for 'axa sunlife'.</p> <p>It's my assumption that the title should be:</p> <p>Life Insurance Quote - Axa Sunlife</p> <p>rather than:</p> <p>Life Insurance | Life Insurance Quote - Axa Sunlife</p> <p>Am I right in thinking that putting it twice has no added value, and could in fact have an adverse effect?</p> <p>Thanks,</p> <p>Lewis.</p> <p> </p></title>
On-Page Optimization | | SEOMyGod0