Is there a Penguin Time Limit
-
Hi, so I am curious if Penguin has a time limit?
Like say after 90 days it resets and looks to see if any penalties still exist?
Thank you
-
The Penguin refresh comments, on my part, have been entirely speculative. It's hard to believe Google would go that long without some kind of data refresh on something with such wide repercussions. On the other hand, the data so far seems to suggest that that is what they're doing. I have no credible evidence, other than my own disbelief, that a site hit by Penguin can escape Penguin outside of a confirmed update.
I hate being at Google's mercy for knowing when updates happen, and I do believe that Penguin will be more tightly integrated over time, but I also am fairly sure that Penguin had wide-ranging collateral damage that Google didn't entirely foresee. I think they're still trying to wrestle the Penguin update themselves.
So, for now, the best evidence I have is that the only Penguin updates are the ones we know about. I can't prove it either way. I definitely don't think it's like Panda. I wonder if they occasionally do smaller data-only refreshes on Penguin, but I can't back that up.
-
Great response Marie! I'm not going to add anything to it because I don't want to end up in a useless discussion. I don't think that's of value to anybody
-
It's certainly possible that Penguin refreshes without Google telling us, but if it has happened, no one in the SEO world has been able to definitively pick it up and there are many of us who monitor a large number of Penguin hit sites. Last year John Mueller said something in a hangout that implied that Penguin was refreshing regularly. I wrote about it in my blog, here. However, John quickly responded on Google+ saying, "I was probably a bit too fast there :). While we do rerun link analysis regularly, the “Penguin” algorithm is in the stage we don’t do regular pushes of all of the data in the same way that we update Panda once a month or so, for example. We’re always working on improving that, of course."
Now, that was a while ago and it's possible that things have changed, but my belief is that Penguin is still in the stage where there are only announced refreshes and updates at this point.
In this recent Webmaster Central Hangout at about 17:18 someone asked John if Google would announce when it would start baking Penguin into the algorithm like Panda and he said he couldn't promise if that would happen. In this March 24 hangout at 16:30 when John was asked when the next refresh would be, he replied, "It’s been a while, so hopefully we can do one soon."
I've seen what Matt Cutts was talking about in regards to sites getting affected with "just a little bit of Penguin". These are sites that have good links along with some bad ones. Instead of seeing a dramatic drop to page 10+ they may drop 5-10 places or so. But, in almost every case, in order to recover a Penguin refresh has to happen. I don't believe that this means that they were affected at times other than a Penguin refresh.
With that being said, I've seen Dr. Pete postulate that Penguin might be having regular little refreshes that are unannounced but that's not the popular opinion. (Sorry Dr. Pete....I'm sure you'll be ok with me disagreeing with you, right?)
I do believe that Google finds ways to discount bad links and some sites can see a devaluation in rankings that happens at a time other than a Penguin refresh because of this. But, if a site is affected by the Penguin algorithm, as far as I understand, at this point they can't escape Penguin until Google refreshes the algorithm again.
-
Marie, I know that Google announced a couple of them, but although I don't have proof I don't think it's reasonable that they haven't had a new Penguin update since October 2013 if I follow the change history by Dr. Pete: http://moz.com/google-algorithm-change
Also when seeing this thread at SearchEngineLand and Matt Cutts response mentioning a mild Penguin that clearly shows that there is something more structural going on then it seems in my opinion.
-
Hi Martjin,
"by now the 'Penguin algorithm' has been fully integrated."
I think you may be confusing Panda and Penguin. Panda has been integrated into the algorithm and Google doesn't give us updates on when it happens. But, for now Penguin is still an announced event as far as we know.
-
Be careful not to confuse manual penalties and algorithmic link based issues (i.e. Penguin). This might be worth a read: http://moz.com/blog/the-difference-between-penguin-and-an-unnatural-links-penalty-and-some-info-on-panda-too
If you've got a manual penalty, they can expire but often it takes years to expire. If you've got issues with the Penguin algorithm then your site will remain affected by Penguin until the algorithm sees that you have fully cleaned up.
-
No, as Rishi said there is not. It used to be in the beginning that Google would provide a date when there had been a Penguin update, but by now the 'Penguin algorithm' has been fully integrated.
-
No it doesn't. You need to disavow and remove as many bad links. Unlike a manual penalty, which has a time limit reset factor, penguin is algorithmic, so the filter will keep your site down if you don't do anything about it.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Static content pages ranking dropping all the time
Hello all. I have been working three months in my current job in the hotel industry. I have been publishing a lot of content to our website (mainly articles), which in general have been ranking well and really boosted our website traffic. The problem that I am facing, though, is the fact that our static pages' rankings are basically constantly dropping. Especially one of our main pages, which is this hotel page. I haven't been doing any real changes to the content, but the ranking (with keywords "hotelli helsinki" [Hotel in Helsinki in Finnish]) has plummeted from 13th position all the way down to 19th... What has been happening during these last three months is that we did change to a new domain and we have done all the redirections and also informed Google about this change through search console. I have also done some minor changes to the on-page content, such as changing the meta titles and descriptions as well as the page title and some of the text content to more natural ones instead of clumsy SEO texts and optimizing the images. This hasn't helped at all though and the rankings seem to steadily drop all the time. What would YOU do with this page? Maybe add more text content to the page to be more informative? All tips would be highly appreciated.
On-Page Optimization | | haapalatuomas0 -
Is it a good practice to reduce number of redirections (301) after a period of time?
Is it good to use disavow tool and get rid of old URLs i.e. links for pages and posts which we have deleted from our website and added 301 on them?
On-Page Optimization | | Ravi_Rana0 -
Should I spend time going back and optimizing old blog posts for SEO or just write new posts?
The site I manage (Boutique Estate Law Firm) has at least 350 old blog post archived that were not well optimized for SEO. Would it be valuable to go through and optimize those old posts or just write new optimized posts even though they are on the same subjects? My boss loves to churn out 300 word posts.
On-Page Optimization | | SEO4leagalPA0 -
Moz Pro recommends not using a keyword more than 15 times. If there is a lot of content and the density is low, is it okay to go over that?
From MOZ on-page grader... "Recommendation: Edit your page to use your targeted keywords no more than 15 times." But if I use a keyword 50 times and the keyword density is only 2 percent, is that ok? What is more important, the raw number used or the density?
On-Page Optimization | | Jeremy-Marion1 -
Big shift in local results with Penguin 2.0?
Is anyone else seeing a big shift in local results since Penguin 2.0. I am logged out of Google, all personalisation switched off but my results are being personalised to my location for all results, not just Google+ Local results? I'm pretty sure penguin is bigger than 2.3% of queries or whatever was reported..
On-Page Optimization | | Karen_Dauncey0 -
Seeking a Google Penalty / Panda & Penguin recovery expert
Hi folks, I've been dealing with an online travel agency who came to me looking for content marketing services. One look at their analytics & GWT was all I needed to see they have some serious site cleanup to do before they can start spending money on our services. Their search traffic floored with the first Panda update back in Feb 2011, and they've gone through all sorts of turbulence with the Penguin updates too. There are no messages in GWT, but I suspect their previous SEO guy might have deleted them to cover his tracks. I did a quick look at their link profile and there's all kinds of junk in there, they have dupe content all over the place and the whole thing needs cleaning up. In other words, it's a mess. I'd like to win some business from them, but first they need to talk to a Panda/Penguin recovery specialist. If you're interested, drop me a private message and I'll put you in touch with them. Thanks, Matt.
On-Page Optimization | | MattBarker0 -
I run a Q&A site, should I limit post questions to 64 characters?
I run a Q&A site (Recessionitis.com), should I limit posts (questions) to 64 characters for SEO purposes?
On-Page Optimization | | 10JQKAs0 -
Optimally, how many times should the key word or phrase you are targeting for a particular page be mentioned or appear on that page?
Our marketing team is debating how many times the key phrase on each of our web store's product pages should include the word/phrase we are trying to be competitive with. Can you advise?
On-Page Optimization | | Glynlyon0