Site Migration and Traffic Help!
-
Hi Moz,
I recently migrated my website with the help of an SEO company using 301 redirects. The reason for the move was to change our CMS from .aspx to Drupal/Wordpress. The homepage (www.shiftins.com) and the blog (www.shiftins.com/blog) were the only two pages that kept the same url. Everything else was redirected. It's been about two months since the redirects were completed and traffic has dropped off about 90%. I'm starting to worry that something was not done properly and my traffic may never return.
The process for the redirects seem correct when I checked the work the SEO company did. All pages were duplicated, redirected to individual pages, then the old pages were de-indexed. Are there any insights the community can provide? Please help!
-
-
_Just curious what section of the Analytics data are you looking at to make this determination? _
(1) I looked at GA reports, Audience > GEO > Location > United States > California.
(2) I looked at a download of GWMT impression data comparing 9/28 - 10/30 to 10/31 - 12/1 data, sorted by the calculated difference in impressions data.
(3) Then went back to GA, looked at landing pages and searched for "car".
All of the pages I used to have were supposedly moved over to the blog then 301'ed. Was this really not done or were the pages not optimized properly?
I don't know if all pages were moved and properly 301'd. I did see at least one error though. /automobile/car-insurance-program.aspx redirects to /drive_to_learn_scholarship, which obviously is not the correct URL.
Are all of these duplicate pages coming from the blog? How can I identify these?
The screaming frog scan that Thomas sent should help you identify them.
_If you want the list of queries that were driving impressions before the conversion (and now aren't), email me (so I get your email) and I'll pass them along. _
I've emailed you the file.
-
Hi Donna,
Thank you.
The report is something you can customize to be completely white labeled very easily in less than 10 minutes. The tool is https://www.deepcrawl.com it starts at a very reasonable rate $80 and is capable of so much.
I would recommend Deep Crawl to anyone there fantastic.
All the best,
Tom
-
Thanks for clarifying the point about duplicate hits.
-
Excellent summary Thomas. Is that custom or are you using a paid tool to generate that?
-
All done use the URL provided to go through every issue on your site. remember you can click on anything to see more there are thousands of problems you can look directly at and see a fix for.
IN the URL
You will see green arrows to click on you can also click on anything highlighted in red or if there is a word for a number member you can click on it and see a lot more than what you see in the very beginning.
You have a lot of broken links it also appears your canonical URL is non-www but you 301 redirect to www.
USE THIS URL TO SEE EVERYTHING:
UES THIS FOR A summary http://d.pr/f/bvxB
Sorry it took me so long
Tom
-
so far if you look at the Google analytics indexed URLs and site map URLs compared to the URis downloaded you should upload the site map I gave you in the last post screaming frog XML sitemap with a XML image sitemap will be a step in the right direction.
It is a larger photo
http://i.imgur.com/IIhIx7q.png
Tom
-
Here is a photo showing that deep crawl is hard at work.
I've also added this URL which has a zip file that contains all your URLs your screaming frog crawl review and the pages that contain Google analytics the pages that do not and what UA number is attached to the page. http://d.pr/f/1f1AL
I want to clear one thing up you cannot get duplicate hit's using Google analytics twice on one page as long as the UA numbers are different the only thing that will happen is your bounce rate will go down dramatically. ( I am talking about full JavaScript snippets) can have two UA's in the same snippet and be okay.
I started to crawl here is a bigger photo I will post it to you when I'm done I will look at the information I've sent you so far I think you will find it very valuable.
http://i.imgur.com/i0F739b.png
All the best,
Tom
-
"The vast majority of the lost traffic is from local (LA, San Fran & San Diego) locations. People searching for "car insurance", "cheapest car insurance", "cheapest car insurance California" and other similar keyword phrases. You no longer have a page on your site optimized for those terms so you're not showing up in search results. "
Just curious what section of the Analytics data are you looking at to make this determination? All of the pages I used to have were supposedly moved over to the blog then 301'ed. Was this really not done or were the pages not optimized properly?
**"(1) You've got a lot of duplicate pages on the site, e.g. **
http://www.shiftins.com/blog/7-sins-car-insurance-buyers-make/
http://www.shiftins.com/blog/7-sins-car-insurance-buyers-make/www.shiftins.com(See how the domain name is appended at the end of the second URL?) The later is redirected to the former, but it means you’ve got crawlers wasting a lot of time trying to index duplicate content and you're diluting your SEO equity. Of 269 pages, 267 are redirected duplicates. "
Are all of these duplicate pages coming from the blog? How can I identify these?
**Your bounce rates, time on site, page views and conversions all appear to have improved since the new site was deployed. That's great! **
Thank you that was the idea behind the redesign. Now I just need the traffic back!
**If you want the list of queries that were driving impressions before the conversion (and now aren't), email me (so I get your email) and I'll pass them along. **
I would greatly appreciate the list. Please email me at "greasy(at)gmail.com"
-
Okay. I see a few things.
The vast majority of the lost traffic is from local (LA, San Fran & San Diego) locations. People searching for "car insurance", "cheapest car insurance", "cheapest car insurance California" and other similar keyword phrases. You no longer have a page on your site optimized for those terms so you're not showing up in search results.
It looks like you might have auto as a menu choice under "insurance items", but...
(1) It's hidden behind your site logo when the drop-down menu appears so visitors and search engine spiders can't get to it. It IS indexed. (I see it in your sitemap and when I do a site command.)
(2) On your old site, the home page was optimized for "Cheap Car Insurance in California". Now you're tending to use the term "auto" more than "car" and you're also not using the word "cheap" and "cheapest".
Two other observations: duplicate content and drive-to-learn 404.
(1) You've got a lot of duplicate pages on the site, e.g.
http://www.shiftins.com/blog/7-sins-car-insurance-buyers-make/
http://www.shiftins.com/blog/7-sins-car-insurance-buyers-make/www.shiftins.com(See how the domain name is appended at the end of the second URL?) The later is redirected to the former, but it means you’ve got crawlers wasting a lot of time trying to index duplicate content and you're diluting your SEO equity. Of 269 pages, 267 are redirected duplicates.
(2) The drive-to-learn scholarship page is driving a lot of good traffic. But there appears to be a missing page (below). Visits to the 404 page stopped around the 19th, so you may have fixed this already.
/404.html?page=/content/insurance-program-application.aspx&from=http://www.shiftins.com/drive_to_learn_scholarship
I suggest trying to fix these things to see if it makes a difference. I also highly recommend the other item we talked about - indexing and optimizing the blog.
Your bounce rates, time on site, page views and conversions all appear to have improved since the new site was deployed. That's great!
If you want the list of queries that were driving impressions before the conversion (and now aren't), email me (so I get your email) and I'll pass them along.
-
I've identified it as only affecting organic search traffic, direct and referral were largely unaffected. I do not mind giving you read only access. What email should I grant access too?
-
You're right. It wouldn't. Just the analytics.
Updating the title tags isn't the issue cause it looks like they didn't have unique title tags before the transition. But it should help boost organic traffic.
You may be right (it's a lot of small things). Have you looked at your traffic sources before and after to see if anything stands out? Is the drop evenly spread across direct, organic, PPC and referred traffic? Is it primarily in one area?
I'd be happy to take a look if you want to give me temporary access to your analytics and WMT. Sometimes it just takes a fresh pair of eyes.
-
If don't have the analytics code set up on the blog pages, why would that affect my GWMT data?
Both GWMT and Analytics show a decline on the relaunch date. Would updating the title tags be the issue? Even without unique tags would it justify the huge drop?
I have a feeling it's a bunch of small things contributing to the drop in traffic and need help identifying the underlying cause of the decline. Thanks for your input.
-
No. That's not the sole cause b/c I can still see blog content indexed on Google. It looks like you currently don't have Google Analytics tracking codes setup on the blog content, so any visits you are getting aren't getting captured in reports.
Also on the old site, you had two separate sets of Google Analytics tracking codes set up on the blog content (UA-743349-4 and UA-30229507-1). It's possible the code was firing twice causing double counting.
-
Donna,
THE SITEMAP.... What great analysis! This could definitely be the problem. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
The company I'm currently working with created a separate sitemap for the blog than the main site but it does not look like they submitted it to WMT...
Would having two sitemaps but only submitting one to WMT cause the traffic to drop like this and not return?
-
Sorry it's taken me so long to get back to you. I would be more than happy to do that. In order to at the very most out of a crawl I would need access to Google Analytics. Just for the time of crawl.
What I'm going to do this combined wit what I'm going to do his combined SEM rush with deepcrawl.
I obviously will not charge you for this. let me look up how many pages your website days prior to confirming I will send you a private message and emailed or you can Google analytics once this is done you can delete it right away.
Would you do me a favor and use marketing.grader.com in order to show me approximately the size of your site.
I will and use SEM rush in addition because I think he may be ranking higher for keywords and use SEM rush in addition because I think you may be ranking higher for keywords that contain less traffic.
Another big thing that you have to think about did you use a link tool at your disposal Moz OSE, Ahrefs, Majestic & Google Webmaster tools so I can have deep crawl match up the back links with the new URLs? & tools/search console
in order to save yourself money and take it advantage of the Moz OSE, Ahrefs & Google Webmaster tools I strongly suggest that you sign up for a free trial using monitorbacklinks.com it comes with Ahrefs built in. You can add Moz , Majestic & GWT's via there API I can also upload any CSV file from any company like SEMRush exc.
I want to have the ability to she is much of the back link profile we will know so we're not missing something important.
Last but not least could you give me a rough idea of your web hosting set up? Would you mind running your website through. tools.pingdom.com
check your 301's using feedthebot.com (it redirects to a new domain but it is still the same tool set)
For Google Analytics tzickell (at) blueprintmarketing.com
-
I noticed a few problems. They might not be the answer you're looking for, but they could be a start.
- Do you have the same tracking code as before and on every page?
- Looks like your XML sitemap is missing some entries. It lists only 95 pages (none of the blog pages).
- None of the title tags on your blog are populated with unique entries.
- This has more to do with after people visit the site, but I noticed your main menu toolbar doesn't seem to be working correctly. It doesn't allow me to navigate from the home page to any of the insurance quote or customer service pages because the drop-down disappears when you navigate over it.
-
Are the new pages being indexed?
-
Thomas,
Thank you for your time! I seriously appreciate it. I've taken a quick look at the resources you provided and will be digging deeper into them soon. While the current company I'm working with looks like they did everything right by my standards, I'm starting to become worried because of all the online articles stating that I shouldn't lose more than 40% of traffic and that I should only have been affected for 3-4 weeks.
The first image I've attached is the organic search traffic data from my GA account showing the huge drop in traffic over the last two months.
The second image I've attached is the WMT data showing the drop in overall impressions and clicks on October 18th.
The third image is where it gets weird. It shows that the average overall ranking position has actually decreased showing that I'm actually ranking higher but getting less impressions and less clicks.
I'm having a hard time identifying where the issue is coming from. I've kept a pretty good record of data but can't seem to pinpoint what exactly the issue is. Is there anything that you can think of that I should look into? I would also appreciate any analysis, insights, or analytic tools you can provide.
traffic_zpsevs8mdcb.jpg impressions_zps0s1igziy.jpg position_zpsh6ipsvpx.jpg
-
Whenever your are Preparing for a Website Relaunch that involves change your URL structure abruptly you will have a dip however 90% seems extremely drastic
However this is very common in this photograph http://i.imgur.com/UtYUyCX.jpg
use this free tool from kapost to inventory your content https://app.kapost.com/auditor
I you not know what you did to prepare print for this side from 301 redirect which should be page for page using redirect match then slowly over time make sure everything is done properly http://i.imgur.com/lutF4aj.png
Read: https://moz.com/blog/web-site-migration-guide-tips-for-seos
- See: http://www.stateofdigital.com/40-deepcrawl-tweaks/
- https://www.clickz.com/clickz/column/2158206/-checklist-website-redesign-migration
- http://www.catalystsearchmarketing.com/9-seo-tips-successful-site-migration/
I like to move slowly and I always use Deep Crawl screaming frog is great too but in my opinion the DeepCrawl is the way to go.
- https://www.deepcrawl.com/knowledge/best-practice/what-you-need-to-prepare-for-a-website-relaunch/
- https://www.deepcrawl.com/knowledge/best-practice/test-development-changes/
- https://www.deepcrawl.com/knowledge/guides/comparing-a-test-website-to-a-live-website/
- https://www.deepcrawl.com/knowledge/tag/migration/
- https://builtvisible.com/deepcrawl-co-uk-crawler-choice-large-websites/
- http://www.lunametrics.com/blog/2013/04/29/big-content-site-migration-tips/
Because you mentioned WordPress and Drupal I would recommend reading these lunch checks prior to major modifications
- https://pantheon.io/docs/articles/wordpress/launch-check-wordpress-performance-and-configuration-analysis/
- https://pantheon.io/docs/articles/drupal/launch-check-drupal-performance-and-configuration-analysis/
remember Google is going to play it safe make sure you know why the traffic has disappeared. If you want I will write your site through one of my tools for you?
all the best,
Tom
sorry for all the references I can tell you that they have helped me a lot.
Preparing for a Website Relaunch
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Mobile First Index: What Could Happen To Sites w Large Desktop but Small Mobile Sites?
I have a question about how Mobile First could affect websites with separate (and smaller) mobile vs desktop sites. Referencing this SE Roundtable article (seorountable dot com /google-mobile-first-index-22953.html), "If you have less content on your mobile version than on your desktop version - Google will probably see the less content mobile version. Google said they are indexing the mobile version first." But Google/ Gary Illyes are also on the record stating the switch to mobile-first should be minimally disruptive. Does "Mobile First" mean that they'll consider desktop URLs "second", or will they actually just completely discount the desktop site in lieu of the mobile one? In other words: will content on your desktop site that does not appear in mobile count in desktop searches? I can't find clear answer anywhere (see also: /jlh-marketing dot com/mobile-first-unanswered-questions/). Obviously the writing is on the wall (and has been for years) that responsive is the way to go moving forward - but just looking for any other viewpoints/feedback here since it can be really expensive for some people to upgrade. I'm basically torn between "okay we gotta upgrade to responsive now" and "well, this may not be as critical as it seems". Sigh... Thanks in advance for any feedback and thoughts. LOL - I selected "there may not be a right answer to this question" when submitting this to the Moz community. 🙂
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | mirabile0 -
Merging Two Unrelated Sites into a Third Site
We have a new client interested in possibly merging 2 sites into one under the brand of a new parent company. Here's a breakdown of the scenario..... BrandA.com sells a variety of B2B widget-services via their online store. BrandB.com sells a variety of B2B thing-a-majig products and services (some of them large in size) not sold through an online store. These are sold more consultatively via a sales team. The new parent company, BrandA-B.com is considering combining the two sites under the new brand parent company domain. The Widget-services and Thing-A-Majigs have very little similarity or purchase crossover; so just because you're interested in one doesn't make you a good candidate for the other. We feel pretty confident that we can round-up all the necessary pages and inbound links to do proper transitioning to a new, separate third domain though we're not in agreement that this is the best course of action. Currently the individual brand sites are fairly well known in their industry and each ranks fairly well for a variety of important terms though there is room for improvement and each site has good links with the exception of the new site which has considerably fewer. BrandA.com DA = 73 - 19 years old
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | OPM
BrandB.com DA = 55 - 18 years old
BrandA-B.com DA = 40 - 1 year old Our SEO team members have opinions on what the potential outcome(s) of this would be but are wondering what the community here thinks. Will the combining of the sites cause a dilution of the topics of the two sites and hurt rankings? Will the combining of the domain authority help one set part of the business but hurt the other? What do you think? What would you do?0 -
Why is this url redirecting to our site?
I was doing an audit on our site and searching for duplicate content using some different terms from each of our pages. I came across the following result: www.sswug.org/url/32639 redirects to our website. Is that normal? There are hundreds of these url's in google all with the exact same description. I thought it was odd. Any ideas and what is the consequence of this?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Sika220 -
Huge e-commerce site migration - what to do with product pages?
My very large e-commerce client is about to undergo a site migration in which every product page URL will be changing. I am already planning my 301 redirect process for the top ~1,000 pages on the site (categories, products, and more) but this will not account for the more than 1,000 products on the site. The client specified that they don't want to implement much more than 1,000 redirects so as to avoid impacting site performance. What is the best way to handle these pages without causing hundreds of 404 errors on site migration day? Thanks!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | FPD_NYC0 -
Redirecting Pages from site A to site B
Hi, I have a client who have a solid, high ranking content based site (site A). They have now created an ecommerce site in addition (site B). To give site B a boost in terms of search engine visibility upon launch, they now wish to redirect approx 90% of site As pages to site B. What would be the implications of this? Apart from customers being automatically redirected from the page they thought they where landing on, how would google now view site A? What are your thoughts to thier idea. I am trying to talk them out of it as I think its a poor one.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Webrevolve0 -
Traffic down after site migration
Hi! I've been working on a campaign for http://www.alwayshobbies.com/, which has seen a 35% in drop in traffic since changing ecommerce platforms. It's now been two months, but there is no sign of recovery. We are in the middle of cleaning up the link profile as part of a resubmission request, but that has been ongoing since before the migration. A lot of redirects were needed after 10k 404s appeared in Webmaster Tools after the new launch, but these have been reduced to around 500. We've been pretty thorough here, but I thought it would be worth checking in case there's something we've missed.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | neooptic0 -
Please help on this penalized site!
OK, this is slowly frying my brain and would like some clarification from someone in the know, we have posted multiple reconsideration requests the regular "site violates googles quality guidelines" .."look for unnatural links etc" email back in March 2012, I came aboard the business in August 2012 to overcome bad SEO companies work. So far i have filled several disavow requests by domain and cleared over 90% of our backlink profile which where all directory, multiple forum spam links etc from WMT, OSE and Ahrefs and compiled this to the disavow tool, as well as sending a google docs shared file in our reconsideration request of all the links we have been able to remove and the disavow tool, since most where built in 2009/2010 a lot where impossible to remove. We managed to shift about 12 - 15% of our backlink profile by working very very hard too remove them. The only links that where left where quality links and forum posts created by genuine users and relevant non spam links As well as this we now have a high quality link profile which has also counteracted a lot of the bad "seo" work done by these previous companies, i have explained this fully in our reconsideration request as well as a massive apology on behalf of the work those companies did, and we are STILL getting generic "site violates" messages, so far we have spent in excess of 150 hours to get this penalty removed and so far Google hasn't even batted an eyelid. We have worked SO hard to combat this issue it almost feels almost very personal, if Google read the reconsideration request they would see how much work we have done too remove this issue. If anyone can give any updates or help on anything we have missed i would appreciate it, i feel like we have covered every base!! Chris www.palicomp.co.uk
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | palicomp0 -
Network Of Sites...
Hi Guys, Just wondering if anyone can help me out... We have recently been hit by the Google penguin update and I'm currently working though all the bad / spammy backlinks that previous SEO companies have built for us. I have come across 1 particular domain www.justgoodcars.com they seem to have a lot of different domain names: <colgroup><col width="390"></colgroup>
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | ScottBaxterWW
| http://www.justpulsarcars.com/nissan-pulsar-warranties/1/United_Kingdom/all.html |
| http://www.justpumacars.com/ford-puma-warranties/1/United_Kingdom/all.html |
| http://www.justpuntocars.com/dutch-site/fiat-punto-warranties/1/United_Kingdom/all.html?selectcountry1=United_Kingdom |
| http://www.justpuntocars.com/fiat-punto-warranties/1/United_Kingdom/all.html?selectcountry1=United_Kingdom | Now all of theses domains names have exactly the same IP Address?? Above is just a few I would say there are 100s of them. Do you think this could have an affect on us? Thanks, Scott0