How to Solve Mysteries for Disabled Products?
-
I want to solve mysteries regarding disabled products on my eCommerce website. I want to give one example for my one product to know more about it.
Product URL: http://www.vistastores.com/indoorlighting-patiolivingconcepts-20947.html
Product Name: Floor Lamp in Monterey Bronze Finish
- Before 3 Months, This product was live on my website with In Stock status. Google have crawled that product, added in XML sitemap, added in Google merchant center, added in too many external website during link building campaign.
- Before 15 Days, This product was live on my website with Out of Stock status. Now, visitor can visit this page but, can not add in shopping cart.
- Now, This product is disabled from website and not available for sell. I have done lot of work to compile content, image, page rank and many other SEO stuffs to get rank with specific long trail keyword. This product is suddenly disabled from website so, it's shows 404 error and redirect to custom 404 error page.
- But, I am not satisfy with 301 redirect to set 302 redirect. But, is it really good?
- Is it require to set 301 or 302 redirect on disable products?
- I will never sell this product again on website. But, what about my indexing, external links, page authority?
- This is creating too many up an down in webmaster tools data, merchant center data, xml sitemap data and impression data.
What is best solution for it? Can any one share good example for eCommerce website.
-
It's really good explanation. I am going to set redirect. But not 301 but, 302. Because, I want to drill down more on same subject and will find out alternative solution with my problem.
I am not opposing you. I am picking parallel solution [~302 instead of 301] what you recommend.
BTW: Thanks for your time on my question. I am still not mark it as answered. Let's see what happen in next response.
-
Hi again,
Currently you have that product number listed under two different URL's
http://www.vistastores.com/indoorlighting-patiolivingconcepts-20947.html is returning a 301
http://www.vistastores.com/floor-lamps-patio-living-concepts-20947.html is returning a 404.
There are those who would say that it is perfectly fine to return a 404 as long as the 404 page contains proper navigation links and access to other products etc.
I do not disagree with their opinion as far as what should be on the page that is returned (your custom 404 page does this), but in the case of an ecommerce site, I disagree that it is a good idea to just let all expired products return 404 errors.
The nature of ecommerce is such that this will eventually result in search engines seeing an ever-growing list of broken links on your site. With large ecommerce sites, this could result in thousands of 404 errors which the search engine will see no attempt is ever made to correct or reduce.
If you choose to allow searchers to be sent to your custom 404 page, I take a different approach:
- Name the custom 404 page something innocuous like /custom-introduction
- Remove the 404 references from the Title, description and page text - just use a simple explanation that the product is no longer available and invite the visitor to select from the categories available to search for another product, without mentioning the term "404 not found"
- add a catch-all 301 redirect which sends any request for a page that does not exist on the server to /custom-introduction.
By doing this you will avoid creating an ever growing list of 404's, but as I said, there are those who don't worry about that at all.
As to not using 301's because you have put all that work into the pages, if they are disabled in your store the content will no longer be visible to the search engines anyway. As much as we all hate having our hard work seemingly come to nothing like this, it is very much the nature of the business in ecommerce. Products come and go all the time. This is exactly why the 301 redirect is the best option - because it passes almost all of the link value to the new page. So your hard work has not been wasted, but helped to improve the value of another page on the site.
Hope that helps,
Sha
-
Oh... That's really great.. But, I don't want to set 301 redirect to associated products or category? You will ask that, why? Because, similar products are available on my product page. You can check any product page. So, user can find out similar product from there.
Another reasons are as follow.
- I am doing hard work to get ranking for specific product page. If I will set 301 redirect so Google will cut down my impression with that specific keyword.
- I have measured that, Google is not passing equal page rank or similar data to redirect page. If I have 50 products with 3 page rank so it's not that much beneficial to me.
- Web designer, product mangers and similar other people are working to hard to decor any product page. So, why should I redirect that page to any where after hard work?
- You are right as per SEO point of view but, it is over my head. Why why why I redirect any one to my bedroom after decor entire living room with full of light?
-
Hi there,
Unfortunately products that go out of stock are one of the biggest frustrations for ecommerce site managers. Where products are sourced from another company you can be very much at the mercy of the way that they manage their inventory. This means you need to decide which method of dealing with expired products will work best for you.
From what you have described it sounds like the product was marked temporary out of stock by the supplier, then more recently changed to "Do Not Reorder" status. So, the product has permanently expired and will not be restocked at any time in the future.
Your best option in this situation is a 301 redirect, which will pass link value from the page to whichever page you decide to redirect to. This is where you need to make decisions.
You have essentially 3 choices when choosing an appropriate page to set your redirect target.
- If you have a product in your inventory that is very similar, you could redirect to that as the product may be of interest to people who were looking for the original product.
- If you do not have a similar product, then you can redirect to the higher level category page for that item.
For example, redirect to http://www.vistastores.com/lighting - Finally, since you have an internal search mechanism, you could choose to redirect to a search for a relevant term.
For example, redirect to search ?q=lighting
The aim is to always send the visitor to the most relevant or helpful page to improve the chance of them converting.
Hope that helps,
Sha
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Duplicate Content Product Descriptions - Technical List Supplier Gave Us
Hello, Our supplier gives us a small paragraph and a list of technical features for our product descriptions. My concern is duplicate content. Here's what my current plan is: 1. To write as much unique content (rewriting the paragraph and adding to it) as there is words in the technical description list. Half unique content half duplicate content. 2. To reword the technical descriptions (though this is not always possible) 3. To have a custom H1, Title tag and meta description My question is, is the list of technical specifications going to create a duplicate content issue, i.e. how much unique content has to be on the page for the list that is the same across the internet does not hurt us? Or do we need to rewrite every technical list? Thanks.
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | BobGW0 -
Ecommerce sites we own have similar products, is this OK?
Hello, In one of our niches, we have a big site with all products and a couple more sites that are smaller niches of the same niche. The product descriptions are different with different product names. Is this OK. We've got one big site and 2 smaller subsides in different niches that cross over with the big site. Let me know if Google is OK with this. We will have a separate blog for each with completely different content. There's not really duplicate content issues and although only the big site has a blog right now, the small ones eventually will have their own unique blog. Is this OK in Google's eyes now and in the future? What can we do to ensure we are OK? Thank you.
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | BobGW1 -
How does Google handle product detail page links hiden in a <noscript>tag?</noscript>
Hello, During my research of our website I uncovered that our visible links to our product detail pages (PDP) from grid/list view category-nav/search pages are <nofollowed>and being sent through a click tracking redirect with the (PDP) appended as a URL query string. But included with each PDP link is a <noscript>tag containing the actual PDP link. When I confronted our 3rd party e-commerce category-nav/search provider about this approach here is the response I recieved:</p> <p style="padding-left: 30px;">The purpose of these links is to firstly allow us to reliably log the click and then secondly redirect the visitor to the target PDP.<br /> In addition to the visible links there is also an "invisible link" inside the no script tag. The noscript tag prevents showing of the a tag by normal browsers but is found and executed by bots during crawling of the page.<br /> Here a link to a blog post where an SEO proved this year that the noscript tag is not ignored by bots: <a href="http://www.theseotailor.com.au/blog/hiding-keywords-noscript-seo-experiment/" target="_blank">http://www.theseotailor.com.au/blog/hiding-keywords-noscript-seo-experiment/<br /> </a> <br /> So the visible links are not obfuscating the PDP URL they have it encoded as it otherwise cannot be passed along as a URL query string. The plain PDP URL is part of the noscript tag ensuring discover-ability of PDPs by bots.</p> <p>Does anyone have anything in addition to this one blog post, to substantiate the claim that hiding our links in a <noscript> tag are in fact within the SEO Best Practice standards set by Google, Bing, etc...? </p> <p>Do you think that this method skirts the fine line of grey hat tactics? Will google/bing eventually penalize us for this?</p> <p>Does anyone have a better suggestion on how our 3rd party provider could track those clicks without using a URL redirect & hiding the actual PDP link?</p> <p>All insights are welcome...Thanks!</p> <p>Jordan K.</p></noscript></nofollowed>
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | eImprovement-SEO0 -
Redirecting 86'd Brand Product Category Page
What would be the approach if my website is no longer selling products for a brand that is driving top organic traffic? Where should I redirect the traffic on the page? I'm trying to decide between the homepage or another similar brand product page.
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | JMSCC0 -
E-Commerce - Include the product creation DATE?
Hi there! I would to ask you if it's advisable to include the creation date of new products (the product description ) in a e-commerce shop, I mean, if it makes a difference (in SEO terms, of course). Thanks for the info and my best regards! Z.
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | zkouska0 -
Help with E-Commerce Product Pages
Hi, I need to find the best way to put my products on our e-commerce website. I have researched and researched but I thought I'd gather a range of ideas in here. Basically I have the following fields: Product Title
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | YNWA
Product Description
Product Short Description SEO Title
Focus Keyword(s) (this is a feature of our CMS)
Meta Description The problem we have is we have a lot of duplicate content eg. 10 Armani Polos but then each one will be a different colour (but the model number is the same). I don't want to miss out on rankings because of this. What would you say is the best way to do this? My idea is this: Product Title: Armani Jeans Polo Shirt Blue
Product Description: Armani Jeans Polo Shirt in Blue Made from 100% cotton Armani Jeans Polo with Short Sleeves, Pique Collar and Button Up Collar. Designer Boutique Menswear are official stockists of Armani Jeans Polos.
Short Description: Blue Armani Jeans Polo SEO Title: Armani Jeans Polo Shirt Blue MA001 | Designer Boutique Menswear
Focus Keywords: Armani Jeans Polo Shirt
Meta Description: Blue Armani Jeans Polo Shirt. Made from 100% cotton. Designer Boutique Menswear are official stockists of Armani Polos. What are peoples thoughts on this? I would then run the same format across each of the different colours. Another question is on the product title and seo title, should these be exactly the same? And does it matter if I put the colour at the beginning or end of the title? Any help would be great.0 -
Ecommerce Products on Homepage
Hi, If we highlight products on homepage, they rank better as they are linked to from the homepage - we cannot increase the amount of products or links on homepage for dilution reasons. So, if we change the products on homepage for some others, presumably those will get the link juice benefit? I think what I am asking is, is there any "longevity" once the product has been removed from the homepage as a link - will it lose it's "priority value" or will it retain some of it's importance after the homepage link has been removed? If that is the case, I could circulate my products via homepage over a course of time to help them all get some benefit no? Help!
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | bjs20100 -
Product Reviews – Link Building Strategy
I own Simply Bags and have been sending sample bags to bloggers as a link building strategy. The following four links are a sample of recent product reviews. http://bit.ly/Mk6Z1t http://bit.ly/Mk6Smq http://bit.ly/Mk7atN http://bit.ly/Mk7wR8 Product reviews were considered a good link building strategy. After Panda & Penguin is Product Reviews still a good strategy? Please comment on the quality of the four sample links. Thanks
White Hat / Black Hat SEO | | b4tv
Bob Shirilla0