Simular product pages
-
I have 27000 products on my website, showed one by one on a separated webpage. Google index them almost all (+- 25000). But the SEOmoz report shows them as duplicated content. Indeed, most of the page is identical, only changing description and price of the product which is indeed not more than 2% of the total content of the page. On the bottom of the product page are shown the alternatives for this product, mainly other colors. So, within the same family of products that can have 50 products, the site creates 50 webpages showing the product and it's family. That's why nearly everything on the page is identical within this family of products.
My guess is, as Google indexed them all, I should not worry about duplicated content.
Is my guess correct?
Thanks for a soon answer.
Rik
-
Are you telling me now that I shouldn't be worried that much about SEOmoz flagging 6000 errors on duplicate content as long as my pages get indexed by Google and my site ranking well?
-
You're right on that count. Google doesn't exactly open-source their algos and share them with everyone. We did just change the way we detect duplicate content, and made a blog post about it yesterday. Fewer false positives should exist regarding duplicate content, but things like this will probably still get flagged.
-
OK, I understand. I saw others doing the same. I only never guessed why they did group products where only the color is a variation. Now you gave me a head-ache as this is a very very major change in my approach if I want to group my products on one page. In case I want to set up canonical for the preferred version, I need to sort out how to do this programmatically as I might have 27000 different product pages, HTML-wise I only have one. But this can't be that hard to find out.
I stay with one doubt, however you might be right. My site is 4 years old and for almost 3 years was on Number One in organic Google in Belgium with a competition of more than 4 million. If Google at one time had considerated my approach of one page per product as duplicate content I never would have get there.
Highly appreciated, your comment as well as the one of donford.
Thanks.
-
I think this is exactly what you are looking for -
http://maileohye.com/seo-tips-for-e-commerce-sites/
And personally what I feel is that these pages will be considered duplicate and therefore, you need to fix them by setting up canonical for the preferred version. Or if there is one standalone page, you need to block other pages/ color variations from search engines. Let me know what you think.
-
The pages you show are (in my eyes) completely different, much more different than the ones I have.
Two samples both indexed where only the color and the price differs. The site ranks well in Google, the pages are showed when entering the product code. The pages itself have very low trust (1).
As the site ranks very well, the pages are indexed and SEOmoz showing duplicate content error, it must be that the used algorithm is different between Google and SEOmoz.
-
It sounds like you're on target if your pages are returning high or well on SERP's. To answer the question about the % of difference that I don't know, I can show you an example using our o-ring pages.
AS001 size orings in 2 different materials
Basically the same information but added some material specific information to each page to help differentiate them in the search engines. Again not sure what % difference that is, but we have no dup content warnings here at SEOmoz.
-
Thanks for your answer and yes it makes sence. However my products shift in brands, every brand has families and every family has product codes. As the product code being the keyword - many visitors are looking for the product using the product code as a keyword - the SE doesn't have any problems to show the right page. If a visitor use the family name or the brand name in a search, my site has specific landing pages for those searches.
I launched my question because I am worried that my site will go down in the organic ranking because Google could consider all those product pages as duplicated content. I never worried before because I'm in the top 3 for years now. I only started to worry the moment I started to use SEOmoz and they give me thousands of errors for duplicated content.
Mainly, how much must a page differ in content to be considered unique and not risking a penalty from Google for duplicated content. Or otherwise, how much must a page differ for SEOmoz not considering it anymore duplicated content.
-
This is common for eCommerce sites, the error should be taken seriously, however there usually isn't an easy fix. The end goal of course is not necessarily for Google or any SE to index them, rather that when a particular keyword is hit the page is returned in the results.
Last year I upgraded our ecommerce site which sells orings (very similar products) I spent a lot of extra time to try and differentiate each o-ring page from one another. In the end it paid off, no duplicate content, all pages indexed, and placing well in SERP's.
So to answer your question while having them in Google's index is helpful, I would say you should worry about the duplicate content error as it is indicative that crawlers / search engines may have trouble returning the correct page for your specific keywords.
Hope that makes sense
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How do I split page content?
So I offer two services for which each has an FAQ page (let's call them S1 and S2). The problem is that I also have a longer FAQ page that covers both services (S1-2). I would like to eliminate the longer one and attach the relevant content to each of the shorter pages but i'm concerned that deleting pages with a lot of content might be a bad idea. I could redirect I suppose but I wouldn't know which page S1 or S2 to point redirect to. Any advice on this?
Content Development | | NationalPardon0 -
How to write a good case study page?
Hello all, What components go into making a good case study please? Is there a specific structure that works well from an seo perspective - or is it just about making something read well? Thanks William
Content Development | | wseabrook0 -
Content Architecture - Breakout Pages
If you have a page that summarizes four different product types adequately in a chart that requires no scroll, is there an SEO justification to also breaking out each product into a separate page, but basically it would contain the same information? The SEO in me says yes, because that's more crawlable content you can optimize, but wouldn't it go against usability and general common sense?
Content Development | | SSFCU0 -
Services Page vs Page For Each Service Offered
Read an interesting article about how websites with just a "services" page suffer and they should try to create a meaningful page for each service they offer... Read so many blogs right now that I can't remember where I saw it
Content Development | | JamesFx0 -
Block Low Quality Pages?
What are your thoughts on blocking (in robots.txt) and/or noindexing low-quality pages to defend against Panda, assuming you can't remove, redirect, or add quality content to it? Also, assume there are no external links pointing to these low-quality pages, no social shares, and zero incoming organic traffic. Has anyone had experience with this as a solution to Panda?
Content Development | | poolguy0 -
New pages do not rank
Hello, Google caching the new pages, but is not appearing in search results. Why? site: www.papajogos.com.br
Content Development | | papajogos0 -
I have a page where you can download a PDF of the material - should I exclude the PDF from the search engines?
In my niche, there is a controversial research article that is very popular. I am writing a rebuttal to this article and giving another point of view. My article has the potential to be really good link bait for my site. The original article is often printed out to be shown to professionals in my niche. My hope is that people will do the same with mine. So, I plan to have a PDF version of my article available on my page. The article that is visible on my site (i.e. non PDF) will be a graphic rich article that is easy for the reader to go through. I plan to have the PDF have all of the same text, but it won't have as many graphics - it will look more like a scientific research article. So, should I exclude the pdf from search engines so that it isn't duplicate content? Or does that even matter seeing as it is a duplicate of my own content? I want people to link to the main article, not the pdf. Any tips would be greatly appreciated!
Content Development | | MarieHaynes1 -
Changing Text on Pages
For one of my sites I'm in a situation where I have 6 main pages that are for lack of a better word "showcased," one of which being the homepage. The problem is that I am seeing pretty good traffic growth, but my conversions/sales are really weak, and I'm about 95% positive that this is because there is too much information on all of those pages --- each one has about 1500 words or so. The site architecture and link structure on the site is good as out of the couple of hundred pages on the site only 3 of them aren't indexed according to Google webmaster tools. What I want to do is rewrite the text on those six main pages with more of a sales type of feel and limit them to 500-700 words or so. This will have no impact on the link architecture whatsoever, but I'm a bit worried that it will have a negative impact on my continual traffic growth. Actually, I'm not as much concerned about the continual part as the steady new content stream should take care of it, but I would be very concerned if I lost the rankings that I have right now. Granted, those rankings aren't worth as much as they could be because conversions are down, so so it's kind of a catch-22. The question is, how dangerous is what I'm planning on doing? On a side note, my lack of conversions has nothing to do with my description or title tags that show up in the results as they are targeted properly and written for sales. The problem is that the pages, though rich in content, are a bit too rich in content and need to be fixed to work in unison with the descriptions and titles.
Content Development | | RussNauta0