Google Penalisation - Any help would be appreciated!
-
Hi,
We’ve recently received a Google notification of unnatural linking along with a confirmation that we're being penalised. There were a few other sites that we owned that perhaps had too many links pointing to our main domain so we trimmed them down and submitted a reconsideration request and got the following back:"Dear site owner or webmaster of http://www.refreshcartridges.co.uk/,
We received a request from a site owner to reconsider http://www.refreshcartridges.co.uk/ for compliance with Google's Webmaster Guidelines.
We've reviewed your site and we still see links to your site that violate our quality guidelines.
Specifically, look for possibly artificial or unnatural links pointing to your site that could be intended to manipulate PageRank. Examples of unnatural linking could include buying links to pass PageRank or participating in link schemes.
We encourage you to make changes to comply with our quality guidelines. Once you've made these changes, please submit your site for reconsideration in Google's search results.
If you find unnatural links to your site that you are unable to control or remove, please provide the details in your reconsideration request.
If you have additional questions about how to resolve this issue, please see our Webmaster Help Forum for support.
Sincerely,
Google Search Quality Team"I want to stress that we have never in the past and do not currently buy any backlinks. The problem that we face now is that our site has been online for best part of a decade, there are thousands of people linking to us and I have absolutely no idea where to start.
We don’t use an SEO Company but in the past few months have been using SEOmoz to improve our on-page optimisation. I know it’s a massive ask but if could a member of the SEOmoz community or a staff member quickly take a gander and let us know if anything in particular sticks out like a sore thumb it would mean a great deal to me.
Of course, if needed we’ll employ the services of an SEO company but I’m hoping one of you guys will see something immediately obvious that could really help us out!
Thanks in advance.
Kind regards
Chris
-
All in all this has been a pretty bad news day
Right then, time to get cracking. Thanks for all your help today Ryan, it is really appreciated.
-
Unfortunately no.
The way you described is for when you are algorithmically penalized, but not for a manual penalty. For a manual penalty you need to address all the bad links.
Violating Google Guidelines is not a crime, but a legal mindset would probably best convey the situation. If you are caught stealing money, would a judge be satisfied with you returning most of it? No. The judge would require you return all of the stolen money. When you build manipulative links, Google wants them all addressed.
-
Actually, sorry, one more question. I appreciate all the help you're giving me and don't mean to bombard you with what if's!
I'm assuming that you're allowed a certain percentage of 'bad' links when compared with the number of 'good' links. For example, if the webmaster of a massive website such as Amazon log in to their Google Webmaster Tools panel I'm assuming they don't have any penalty notices caused by a few crummy links that will invariably be on a FFA site somewhere when weighed against their 425,000,000 good links.
As such, will our task be to just remove as many bad links as we can and then whatever remains will hopefully be offset by the good?
-
**I really don't want to have to get a new domain name so I guess we'll have to just get cracking. **
Obtaining a new domain name is the most drastic step possible and not recommended in most cases. It would be done primarily due to a site owner's inability to resolve the penalty themselves and not being able to afford hiring someone else to do it.
Purely out of interest though, surely a competitor could just keep adding our site to FFA directories and unrelated blogs and make it impossible for us to get the penalty removed?
What you are asking about is simply not a concern if you take the proper SEO steps on your domain. Having a penalty is like having your house on fire. Your question is something like "Should I put out the fire? What is someone else comes and lights a match at my house?" It is more theoretical then a realistic issue.
-
Oh dear, that's not what I wanted to hear!
I really don't want to have to get a new domain name so I guess we'll have to just get cracking. Purely out of interest though, surely a competitor could just keep adding our site to FFA directories and unrelated blogs and make it impossible for us to get the penalty removed?
-
Chris H, the above answer was a direct response to Christopher Wood's question. Please disregard.
-
Hi Chris,
In brief, your efforts are good but they will not lead to a penalty removal. Once you have a manual penalty, you need to obtain a comprehensive list of every known link to your site. Even if you use all the links from Google and OSE, it is not enough. You need all the links from multiple toolsets. Next, you need to go through every link and determine which links violate Google's Guidelines. Lastly, you need to contact every site owner who is providing a manipulative link and convince them to remove it. If the link is not removed, you need to very thoroughly document all aspects of the process.
Most people who attempt the above fail to satisfy Google's requirements. There is an incredible amount of work involved.
-
Would it be less time to get a new domain name and start over?
I'd like to think that it's not quite at that stage. Regardless, it would be nice to know what exactly had been done so we could ensure that it just wouldn't happen again.
I lose sleep at night worrying because I posted in the World Rock Paper Scissors Associations Website's forum a comment about a bankruptcy lawyer.
Waaaaaaa? I'm really worried now. Ryan, when you say there is actually such an association are you talking between such a site and Refresh Cartridges?
-
Would it be less time to get a new domain name and start over?
That's always an option. Many site owners do not wish to take this approach due to having a domain name which matches their company name. Other site owners have owned their domain for many years and do not wish to lose the links they earned.
If you have a keyword domain name or other low value domain that has not earned many links, then changing domains may be the best approach.
I lose sleep at night worrying because I posted in the World Rock Paper Scissors Associations Website's forum a comment about a bankruptcy lawyer.
I assumed you were joking but then realized there actually is such an association. Clearly one link will not cause a penalty. I have viewed dozens of penalized sites and they all had an overwhelmingly spammy profile with 90%+ of the links being questionable.
-
Hi Ryan,
Thank-you so much for such a helpful post. I've removed the links from refreshcreations.co.uk, computerarticles.co.uk and vatloophole.co.uk with immediate effect. These are all sites which I own so removing links to my 'baby' felt a little bit gutting but as the links were all sitewide it is entirely possible that Google saw them as being manipulative. I'm assuming that once they confirm that they are no longer penalising us that I could reinstate the links with a nofollow attribute?With regard to the link for http://www.tei-c.org.uk/Digital_Technology_for_Graphic_Design I have e-mailed them asking to be removed but I don't hold up much hope for them doing so - God knows where this link came from! Rather naively I'm hoping that Google isn't worried about an odd link here or there on a PR0 site which I have no control over so will now request reconsideration and see what happens.
Just to confirm, am I correct in saying that article writing is still alive but that the articles should be relevant and of a good quality but only include a link to the site in the 'about the author' section? I only ask as this was going to be our next project; writing high quality articles for various technology sites with a link back to Refresh Cartridges.
Am going to have a thorough look through your http://www.seomoz.org/blog/identifying-link-penalties-in-2012 post now and the comments and ensure there's nothing else we can do.
Thanks again for your help.
-
Would it be less time to get a new domain name and start over?
I lose sleep at night worrying because I posted in the World Rock Paper Scissors Associations Website's forum a comment about a bankruptcy lawyer.
-
Hi Chris,
Based on your post, it seems you received a notice in your Google Webmaster Tools informing you your site was penalized for manipulative links. You then submitted a Reconsideration Request to which Google basically repeated the original message....your site is manually penalized for manipulative links.
The bad news is this type of penalty is the most difficult penalty that can be received. It takes a great deal of time and effort following specific steps to remove. To gain a bit of details regarding the penalty, please review this article: http://www.seomoz.org/blog/identifying-link-penalties-in-2012
Using OSE, I noticed the top link to your site seems manipulative:
http://www.tei-c.org.uk/Digital_Technology_for_Graphic_Design
You also have many other low quality links showing which appear manipulative in nature:
http://www.refreshcreations.co.uk/ (sitewide footer link)
http://www.computerarticles.co.uk/ (it appears the link was removed but it also seems this site is operated by your company)
**I want to stress that we have never in the past and do not currently buy any backlinks. **
You may not pay for them, but it seems many links were created by yourself or an agent (employee, developer, seo, link builder, etc) working on your behalf. These links are manipulative according to search engine guidelines and need to be removed.
A link should be an "independent vote" meaning another site owner chose to offer the link for a valid reason, such as your exceptional product or service. If you are able to create the link because you own or operate the site, or because you paid a fee, that link would be deemed manipulative. Even if you submit content to a free directory, article directory, etc. most of those links (think 99%) would be considered manipulative.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Help Me With These Horrible Crawl Errors
I am currently using Opencart to run a fairly popular ecommerce website. I have done quite well in terms of rankings so far. However, the Opencart platform only goes so far. There are endless amounts of crawl errors, from duplicate content down to missing meta tags. There is no easy way to add canonical tags. The pages that are being listed in the crawl errors seem to be mainly search URL's that i have no idea how Moz found them. An example of the page is: .....com/index.php?route=product/search&tag=home+office+flooring Which has ten duplicate pages all missing meta tags. I have used Google webmaster tools and htaccess to deny access to these pages with the slug "route=product/search" but it doesn't seem to work. So my question to you guys is as follows: Is it worth trying to fix these errors and do they have an effect on SEO? If so, how do I prevent these errors that seem to grow at every crawl? Cheers, Danny
Search Behavior | | DannyHoodless0 -
Search Analytics update in Google Webmasters Tools? Where can we find search queries bringing traffic to website?
I just got up and see Search Analytic's being updated today totally. Their is no option to see old reports. As Search Analytics only share 999 keywords.
Search Behavior | | csfarnsworth
Whats next now?
How can a webmaster finds all search queries bringing traffic to his website?
Any paid or free tool?
Google Analytic's > Acquisition > Search engine optimization > search queries will this area helps? Whole question revolves around. Any good tool that will help you find all the queries bringing traffic to my website?0 -
Does anyone know of a predictive demographics software that helps a website predict its audience based on cookies, or whatever info it has?
Hi guys, I'm looking for a predictive analytics software for better understanding our audience online. Has anyone heard of or used a software that takes the visitors currently coming to your site and uses that data to 'predict' more information about them? Such as age, location, purchasing power, etc? Please let me know if you have!
Search Behavior | | Raconteur
Thanks,
Sabilah0 -
Personalised Geo-targeted results - How does Google pass link juice?
Hello, Many websites now serve specific home page offers based on the location of the customer, my question is, how does link juice flow around a site when the links (this case from the homepage) are served up based on a visitors location? Internal links from your homepage are valuable for ranking that product well in the SERPs so how does Google deal with this? So, for example, a car hire website based in the UK. If you arrive on the care hire website sat in Manchester (Northern UK city), on the homepage the website serves offers of car hire deals in Manchester, Leeds, London and international destinations. If you arrived on this website from London (Southern UK City), you would not see the Manchester link at all but London, and other cities in the South. In this case, when Google crawls the car hire website, it will see internal links but a)which version and b) is there any way of sharing this link value around? Basically, we want to understand if Manchester in this case will get the benefit of an internal homepage link from Google even though we only show Manchester to people FROM Manchester, OR, do Google only give juice based on one version of the website, a generic UK version? Or to put it another way, is there any way of cashing in on both geo-targetting the customer based on their location AND getting link juice from those geo-specific home page links? Perhaps there is some code or way of telling Google that people from Manchester (a certain % of our visitors) will see a homepage internal link for Manchester that will pass some small % link value?
Search Behavior | | xoffie0 -
My website disappears off google!
So this might be kinda of a weird question... Every morning and night I check the ranking of a website that I am building.. The ranking has gone up a lot the last two months. It went from the fifth page to now the second page. I have a issue where some days I check Google my website is completely gone! I go through every page for my keyword and it's not there! After a couple of days of frustration I check again and all of a sudden it is there but now at a higher ranking... I went through the code to make sure there's a not a not follow code in the robots.txt page... Btw another weird thing is so then I look up my website on a google out of country like google.sg and I'm ranking first page like number 5 but again disappeared off google usa. Literally driving my crazy.. does anyone know why this could be? Btw the first time it disappeared I went into webmasters and sent a request because I thought I got penalized but they responded they could not find any spam and I was NOT penalized...
Search Behavior | | BecCan0 -
Google Places rankings go away, but organic rankings stay the same / get better?
Hello, I hope you all can help me out here with the information I could provide. Anyways, the past number of months I have had 1 of our clients rank extremely high organically and on Google places. For example: My client is a law firm so if you search “CLIENTS-TOWN Attorney” they would come up organically on the first page and if you were in that town and search “CLIENTS-TOWN Attorney” or even just “Attorney” they would also come up in the Google Places list. Now for some reason starting a week ago I noticed they have completely disappeared from Google Places. No changes have been done to their site and everything is the same as it was. Their organic searches are the same if not better than before. Do you guys have any clue as to why this happened and how I could possibly turn this around? Thanks for your help in advance!
Search Behavior | | WhiteHat120 -
Visitors via Android App in Google Analytics
Hey there Mozzers! For one of our clients, we've developed an application on both Android and iOS. In the app, there is a link to the regular website. Can I see these visitors from the IOS/Android app in Google Analytics? Can I find them via Refferals? Thanks a lot in advance! Partouter
Search Behavior | | Partouter0 -
Google slow to index new domains and subs?
Anyone finding Google slow to index new websites at the moment? Made a new site on Thursday and posted a number off high quality, relevant, backlinks to it the same day and now on Monday it is still not indexed. Have see the same with a couple of sub domains I have created off a website with a moz score of 40. Normally can get new sites indexed within hours but this seems super slow.
Search Behavior | | Grumpy_Carl0