Marketing URL
-
Hi,
I need a bit of advice on marketing URL's.
The destinations URL is http://www.website.com/by-development.php?area=Isle Of Wight&development=developmentname.
If we wanted to use www.website.com/developmentname on literature to send people to the ugly URL above, what would we do?
Would we need to rewrite the ugly URL to the neat and then 301 the ugly to the neat?
Currently, the team are using a new domain of neatandrelevant.info and 301 redirecting it to ugly URL but there are lots of different developments they want to send people to so a new domain is bought for each development which seems a bit unnecessary. They point to different pages on the ugly URL website.
Assuming canonical tag would not be needed then because the ugly URL page would be redirected.
Also, as the website has ugly URL's anyway, would it not be best practice to use rewrites anyway so that the URL's read www.mywebsite.com/region/development?
Would it confuse things to then have extra short marketing URL's missing out /region?
Hope that makes sense....
-
I don't understand the point of the external domain, either - I tend to agree with you that sub-folders would be perfectly fine here. Unfortunately, there are two issues at play:
(1) You've got to direct the short, marketing URLs to the main site URLs. That's a relatively easy - you could either use rewrites or redirects (rewrites are probably better for humans, in this case). Google can't generally index URLs that are on printed materials, TV ads, billboards, etc. (unless people start linking to them or promoting them on social), so your SEO risks are pretty minimal. The safest bet would be a straight 301-redirect.
(2) The other issue is the long/ugly URLs on the site in general. If you want to move the entire site to the short URLs and then use those short URLs for marketing, that's great, but then you'll need to 301-redirect the entire current site. There are definitely risks to that approach, and I'm not sure it's necessary here. The benefits really depend on the scope of the current site and whether the URL structure is creating problems, like spinning out duplicate pages. You could also potentially use rel=canonical to solve some problems, but again, changing your site-wide URLs involves risk.
I wrote more on (2) here:
-
Just wanted to clarify - [www.getmove-in.com/sub] is a folder or sub-folder. A sub-domain would be [sub.getmove-in.com]. We rarely recommend sub-domains for SEO these days.
-
Had a nudge from Moz to look at the question again to try and get the answer I need - thanks to those that have helped so far though.
The site our (other and independent) marketing team are trying to send people to is http://www.getmove-in.com/ - specifically the pages about individual developments such as http://www.getmove-in.com/by-development.php?area=Isle%20Of%20Wight&development=Pan%20Meadows. The problem is it's an ugly URL and not good to put on the bottom of printed leaflets.
What they are after is a snappier URL. They have currently 'solved' it by buying a new domain www.panmeadows.info to publish on leaflets. This domain redirects to the internal page http://www.getmove-in.com/by-development.php?area=Isle%20Of%20Wight&development=Pan%20Meadows. It seems an odd way of doing thing and means that they have to buy a new domain each time they want to publicise a new development.
What would be ideal is if they could use www.getmove-in.com/panmeadows as a URL. I suspect that even if they could get a neater URL structure to the site, the URL would be in a longer format such as www.getmove-in.com/development/isleofwight/panmeadows or www.getmove-in.com/isleofwight/panmeadows which is longer-than-ideal for a leaflet.
First question: Should all the pages on the site be re-written to neater URL's? (and I'm guessing in the absence of being able to do a redesign and 301 the pages as Wesley suggested this would be the case).
Second question: If we can do this, would we need to 301 the old ugly URL pages to the new? (guessing you do)
Third question: If we can do that and we get neater URL's, how do we get even shorter ones for the purposes of writing on leaflets (marketing URL's) e.g. www.getmove-in.com/panmeadows. What would be the technical bit behind someone seeing www.getmove-in.com/panmeadows on a leaflet and ending up on the content on the page http://www.getmove-in.com/by-development.php?area=Isle%20Of%20Wight&development=Pan%20Meadows.
Sorry if it's written confusingly
-
Thanks again Nathan.
Still struggling to understand why they are doing what they are doing. It may well be custom CMS - it was created by an external design agency who may well have suggested the additional domain 'strategy'.
Am hoping to have a chat with the team that set all this up to see what we can do because the URL's are ugly and the domain buying seems a bit strange to me.
-
No problem,
Thanks for sharing the URL, that really help clear things up.
After doing some digging around this is what I've come up with. Keep in mind that this is my opinion and not a guaranteed answer.
- Your URL is www.getmovin-in.com, this is the root domain.
- Ever page created on your site should be a sub-domain. e.g. www.getmove-in.com/sub-domain page.
- There should be no need to purchase these pages, they are just created and labeled neatly
- I have no idea what CMS they are using, it is not wordpress (which is what I work with). According to the developers site it is a hand built CMS. Not sure why they would do this when there are others already built and really easy to use.
- You basically have a non-profit/real-estate site. Here is a good example of that kind of site here in the states, http://www.hudhomestore.com
Unfortunately I have little experience in dealing with this type of site, but I can tell you, if you site returns a search result like region, city, price, etc, then you will have those ugly URLs. I want to say there is a way to deal with it but I'm not sure. You might try browsing through the blogs at distilled.net, or even contacting them since they are based in the UK I believe. (I am not good with European geography, forgive my ignorance! )
Again I hope this helps, even if only a little.
-
Thanks Nathan,
I don't understand the logic either. The site was designed before I arrived and the relevant department has only just told me how they are marketing individual developments.
The site is http://www.getmove-in.com/. It is a CMS but I don't know what as I don't deal with this website. Also don't know hosting details.
The sort of site they have bought to 301 is panmeadows.info.
-
if you are using a CMS like wordpress, then you should be able to just simply rewrite the url after the ".com/" to what ever you want. I don't understand why you would need to buy a new url and 301 anything, even if your not using a CMS.
I am guessing based off what you wrote, that you have a "Main site page" with navigation somewhere on the top or side. If this is correct then i would say you need to stop buying new domains and simply create a "developments" tab in the navigation with a drop down listing the different pages and create simple clean urls for each page. e.g my: www.mywedsite.com/createuniqueurl
This is the best advice i can give with the information provided. It's also kinda difficult to explain!
Hope this helps
-
Unfortunately that's not an option at the mo. A contract has been signed with the web design company.
-
I think the best option would be to move all the content to a better URL structure and make sure to set up 301 redirects from the old URL's to the new URL's.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Site is generating long path URLs
Hi, We've seen recently in Search Console Coverage report that website is generating long path URLs that we actually don't have.
Technical SEO | | eUniverse
Here's an example: https://autocovers.co.uk/car-mats/outdoor-basic/indoor-car-covers/shop/contact-us/shipping-delivery/about-us/about-us/indoor-car-covers/ Does anybody knows what's the issue behind it? Thanks!0 -
Affiliate Url & duplicate content
Hi i have checked passed Q&As and couldn't find anything on this so thought I would ask.
Technical SEO | | Direct_Ram
I have recently noticed my URLS adding the following to the end: mydomain.com/?fullweb=1 I cant seem to locate where these URLS are coming from and how this is being created? This is causing duplicate content on google. I wanted to know ig anyone has had any previous experience with something like this? If anyone has any information on this it would be a great help. thanks E0 -
To include / at the end of a URL or not
Hi I have recently noticed my site works with / and the end of a URL and without. I wanted to know if there is any SEO impact on this? Will it be seen as 2 different pages? if so what is the best option to go for www.mydomain.com/page/ or www.mydomain.com/page Thanks E
Technical SEO | | Direct_Ram0 -
Are you allowed to point different urls to same page
hi, i have some urls that i am either going to put on hold or thinking about pointing to one of my sites. what it is, i am looking at re-designing the pages but not until next year, so i thought i would point some of the urls to a site that i am happy with to different pages, but not sure if i am allowed this or not so for example, if i have a site on cars, and one of the url is www.rovercars.co.uk i was thinking about pointing it to the page that is about rover cars. can anyone let me know if this is allowed or not please
Technical SEO | | ClaireH-1848860 -
Duplicate Content and URL Capitalization
I have multiple URLs that SEOMoz is reporting as duplicate content. The reason is that there are characters in the URL that may, or may not, be capitalized depending on user input. A couple examples are: www.househitz.com/Pennsylvania/Houses-for-sale www.househitz.com/Pennsylvania/houses-for-sale www.househitz.com/Pennsylvania/Houses-for-rent www.househitz.com/Pennsylvania/houses-for-rent There are currently thousands of instances of this on the site. Is this something I should spend effort to try and resolve (may not be minor effort), or should I just ignore it and move on?
Technical SEO | | Jom0 -
Changing .html to .asp in URLs
Hi Mozzers, I have a question. The webmaster of a client of mine needs to make changes to some files which will effect the URL's. Essentially everything is staying the same but the end of the URL will change from .html to .asp. This is because the site will be dynamically loading content (perhaps from a database) (i.e. latest news to come from their blog etc..) In order to do this we would need to change the filenames of the whole website. (i.e. personnel.html would become personel.asp). Changing URLs can harm indexation but a small change to the end - would Google drop these pages? A 301 redirect is not possible from old URL to new. What impact would this have on Rankings? Thanks Gareth
Technical SEO | | Bush_JSM0 -
Magento URL Question
Calling all Magento Kings out there! I'm working on a client' site - powered by magento. I'm looking to rewrite a lot of the URLs. I know there is the URL rewrite tool, but I think what I need to do may go beyond this. Typical example would be: Old URL - http://www.xxxxxxxx.co.uk/fabric/product/product-black-screen-print-and-silver-fabric.html New URL - http://www.xxxxxx.co.uk/fabric/product/silver I know that magento's URLs seem to be created through categories so wanted to double check with someone the best way to do this. Also, I've heard that 301 redirects of non www to www in the .htaccess has a knock on effect on discounts? All comments greatly appreciated.
Technical SEO | | PerchDigital0 -
Why google index my IP URL
hi guys, a question please. if site:112.65.247.14 , you can see google index our website IP address, this could duplicate with our darwinmarketing.com content pages. i am not quite sure why google index my IP pages while index domain pages, i understand this could because of backlink, internal link and etc, but i don't see obvious issues there, also i have submit request to google team to remove ip address index, but seems no luck. Please do you have any other suggestion on this? i was trying to do change of address setting in Google Webmaster Tools, but didn't allow as it said "Restricted to root level domains only", any ideas? Thank you! boson
Technical SEO | | DarwinChinaSEO0